7 of 8 people found the following review helpful
on 20 August 2010
With me Sitchin is preaching to the converted. That said, this is a great synopsis of all his previous works. An excellent start for those who have yet to get into the Annunnaki. Whether one buys into it or not, his work is an exceptional analysis and clarification of mankinds' earliest history or rather pre-history with enormous implications for society should the Planet Nibiru re-enter the solar system in the near future! Great read!!! Well done Professor Sitchin!
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on 26 May 2013
This book, while interesting, just goes over the contents of the previous ones. It seems to be something put out there just to keep income rolling in. There are some areas of the book that put things slightly differently, but it contains nothing startlingly new. Genesis Revisited has been 're-vamped?
30 of 36 people found the following review helpful
on 9 July 2010
Zecharia Sitchin is close to 90 years old, and is still writing quality books about his 12th Planet Theory. It really is a remarkable accomplishment.
His work has expanded greatly over the decades, and this book provides something of a summation of the entire oeuvre, with some new material provided towards the end. "There Were Giants Upon the Earth" thus provides a substantive overview of what is essentially a completely alternative paradigm about human origins and history.
Sitchin starts with Alexander - an almost modern figure given his usual ancient references. Alexander's interest in immortality and the gods seems to provide a bridge between us and the ancient world. From there we plunge back in time, using the King Lists of Manetho and the land of Sumer for reference The ancient lists boldly assert the dominion of demigods and gods going back some 432,000 years, leading Sitchin to place the arrival of the Anunnaki on Earth to a point some 445,000 years ago.
These Anunnaki - the ancient astronauts from the planet Nibiru - forged us in their image and dwelt among humanity as gods (with a small 'g'). Each ancient civilisation knew them, although the names and tales varied with the times. But these gods were interchangeable across the pantheons of the ancients - myth to most of us now, but once present as real flesh-and-blood beings in Sitchin's paradigm.
These gods eventually intermingled with their human subjects to such an extent that demigods were born - who also played important roles in the mythology and chronologies of the ancient world. Sitchin explores these connections in great detail in this book, and weaves a complex but plausible picture. The Earthborn generations of Anunnaki aged quicker than their Nibiru-born parents, who aged quicker than those of their race that remained on the mother world.
"The records show that the Anunnaki did realize that those who had come and stayed on Earth (Enki, Enlil, Ninmah) aged faster than those who stayed back on Nibiru; and that those who were born on Earth aged even faster. The changes from life on Nibiru to life on Earth apparently affected not only the longevity of the gods (and demigods), but also their physique, making them less giantlike as time went on." (p261)
Hence the decreasing life-spans of the Biblical Patriarchs, whose provenance may have been connected with the Anunnaki. These considerations become important towards the end of the book as Sitchin looks closely at the lineage of various historical figures in Sumer. If his theories are correct, then we would expect that the royal lines of the Sumerian city states would be closely interwoven with the gods associated with the cities. This leads Sitchin to some daring conclusions: Human remains found when tombs in Iraq were excavated during the early parts of the last century might hold clues to our common ancestry. Significantly, those remains are at hand - preserved and kept by the curators of the British Museum.
It is Sitchin's express wish that the remains of Queen Nin-Puabi should be subjected to DNA testing. He is confident that the code will prove to be Anunnaki. Nin-Puabi is not just a queen, he asserts - she is an Anunnaki goddess!
That startling revelation will surely remain an open question. The curators of the British Museum are not likely to excitedly pursue genetic testing on behalf of a maverick researcher, let's face it. Not unless they were VERY confident that he was wrong. Still, they can't complain that Sitchin is unwilling to put his theories to the test!
On another note, this book contains a section that is directly pertinent to my Dark Star revisionism. In his vague fashion, Sitchin draws attention to my work, without naming me directly:
"Some who have read The 12th Planet and accepted its conclusions regarding Nibiru still wondered how the Anunna could survive on a planet whose orbit takes it far away from the Sun; wouldn't they, and all life, freeze to death right off?" (p136)
Well, yes, they would. There really is no getting around that - besides bringing in a Dark Star. Nevertheless, Sitchin does try to address this problem in a different way.
In an effort to strike a balance in this argument, I'm taking the unusual step reproducing Sitchin's argument here in full:
"My answer has been that we and life on Earth face the same issue even though Earth is at a presumed "liveable distance" from the Sun; all we have to do is leave Earth's surface a little bit, and we'll freeze to death. Earth, like other planets, has a nuclear core that produces heat - it gets warmer and warmer as miners tunnel down. But our very thick rocky mantle makes us dependent on heat coming from the Sun. What protects us is Earth's atmosphere. Acting as a greenhouse, it keeps in the warmth we get from the Sun.
"In the case of Nibiru, it is again the atmosphere that offers protection; but there, the need is mostly to keep in the heat coming from the planet's core and prevent it from dissipating out into space. For it is only for the part of its 'year' that Nibiru's elliptical orbit provides a warm 'summer'; during its much longer winter, the planet depends on its inner-core heat to keep its life going." (ibid)
After 11 years, Sitchin and I are no closer on this thorny issue. If you shifted the Earth to the outer solar system, its entire atmosphere would quickly freeze out to form a thick icy crust on the surface of our world. No atmosphere would remain at all. That's just how it is.
Yes, the Saturnian moon Enceladus has surprised us all by retaining liquid water. But it is internally heated by its proximity to its massive parent world (Saturn). The internal tidal forces are directly a result of the gravitational field Enceladus finds itself in. Nibiru needs such an interaction, too. More so, in fact, because its distance from the Sun is so much greater.
It saddens me that I have failed to get this essential point across effectively. The presence of a Dark Star is required for Sitchin's entire paradigm to work. The science, I'm afraid, is very much on my side.
Despite this on-going issue, this book provides an excellent summation of the world according to Sitchin - it is a fascinating read for anyone wishing to explore an completely alternative paradigm.
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful
on 19 July 2010
After many years of promoting his Nibiru theory, Mr Sitchen's newest book is, I would suggest, a general summing up of his previous works, added together with some very important and interesting claims. To suggest that humans (as we know them today) came about because of the mixing of hominid/alien DNA, is not of course a new theory. Indeed, if it is actually true, then the lineage of kings that exists today is probably a direct result of these outside alien influences on our history.
Mr Sitchen, as always, writes in a style and manner that makes his arguments seem both valid and interesting, backed up by his many years of meticulous research. Accurate or not, his assertions are backed up by enough valid data that even the most skeptical of readers would surely struggle to not be intrigued. Those with an open mind will be left pondering for many days after finishing this book.
The claim that Puabi's remains could actually prove to be the missing link that proves a human/alien hybrid was the basis for our whole civilation, is fasinating. Hopefully the Natural History Museum (where those remains are stored), will stand up and be counted. It is in their hands to literally change our recorded history, but somehow i doubt they will be willing to accept the challenge.
All in all, a fasinating read.