1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on 3 January 2013
The book may be, at best, a reasonable version of the original episodes, but Christopher Benjamin does a great job as reader, bringing energy and emotion. He creates a splendid Mr. Sin, and his reading makes for a very enjoyable four hours. The music and sound effects work very well, and this reading will be a great companion to the excellent Jago and Litefoot audio releases from Big Finish.
1 of 3 people found the following review helpful
on 30 January 2013
Through the mists of time there are only a handful of DOCTOR WHO stories that are unequivocally regarded as - and it's a word that is all too quickly attributed - "classic". How do you define a "classic"? Is it be viewing figures, or the writer, or the assembled cast, or "repeatability" (how many time can you re-watch a story without becoming jaded or bored), or accuracy of production or post-production? Or is it a combination of all that criteria?
It's not unreasonable to challenge any Critic who publicly states that "Story X " or "Story Y" is a true "classic" as we all have your own defined criteria. Arguments - well, heated discussions - are rife in this digitally-led fan world but there is a consensus that there are definitive DOCTOR WHO stories that are above criticism and have become "iconic classics".
One such is DOCTOR WHO - THE TALONS OF WENG-CHIANG.
It's 1977, and three stories in, another seemingly impressive Doctor/Companion relationship was burgeoning on the screen that threatened to eclipse the previous one, and the series continued to career toward a darker, more intense consciousness. Enter the frame a storyline from TERROR OF THE ZYGONS' writer, Robert Banks Stewart title THE FOE FROM THE FUTURE and stalwart Director, David Maloney, and instantly born was an "iconic classic". As THE TALONS OF WENG-CHIANG, this six-pater has stood the test of time, whether as a broadcast entity or as an adapted 130-page novel from the fertile keyboard of Terrance Dicks, and now as an unabridged audiobook reading by Christopher (Henry Gordon Jago) Benjamin released by purveyors of quality audio, AUDIOGO.
It's January 2013, and, with the release of DOCTOR WHO AND THE TALONS OF WENG-CHIANG, Christmas has come early this year.
Expertly produced, professionally lavish in historically-accurate music cues evocative of the story's setting &wonderfully read by Benjamin, this release is equal in stature to (David)Troughton's reading of DOCTOR WHO AND THE WAR GAMES - a release that epitomises the loving dedication of the commissioning production team at AUDIOGO - and should be any fans shelf.
Even though the DVD (a release that would benefit from a "special edition"...) is readily at hand, hearing Benjamin read the line "...Doctor, are you down here? Well, cover me in creosote. I never knew this was here..." is pure childhood magic, and:
Jago: "The Sheffield song thrush. Last time she was here, there were eggs all over the stage. Now, ladies and gentlemen, it is my great privilege to introduce to you, in his extended season here at the Palace, the first of two appearances this evening, someone whose legendary legerdemain has entranced and entertained all the crowned heads of Europe. Here to baffle and bewilder in his eclectic extravaganza of efflorescent ectoplasm, that master magician from the Orient, Li H'sen Chang! His characterisation of Jago's right-hand man and Irish odd-job-man, Casey, avoids obvious parody and one is mildly sympathetic toward his demise at the talons of Magnus Greel".
The end of disc two is potentially the most dramatic ending to any unabridged DOCTOR WHO novelisation and will have to punching the eject button to release the CD and hurriedly inserting the next.
The pacing of the reading is perfectly gauged, punctuated with atmospherically seminal sound effects that are based in truth and reality without being a carbon-copy of the televised broadcast, and incidental music `stings' that the legendary DOCTOR WHO composer, Dudley Simpson, would approve. "Drum roll and cymbal". The tinkering the ivories, the joviality expressed by a theatre's gin-soaked audience, subtle dawn chorus and equine indignity, all of which skilfully measured by Simon Power of MEON PRODUCTIONS.
One minor issue, and I hate to be the `whistle blower' on this one but the sound effect of the Police Officer's whistle may be, just may be wrong; it didn't sound like an Acme Metropolitan Police Whistle but a "football whistle" instead. I could be wrong, though. Probably.
Overall, 2013 starts in an extraordinary style with the avuncular Benjamin beguiling a whole new generation of younger fans with his reading of DOCTOR WHO AND THE TALONS OF WENG-CHIANG.
Here's an idea for the AUDIOGO Commissioning Editor; if space permits, it would be appreciative - and feasible - to have a short interview with the original author to discuss the construction and differences of a novel based upon broadcast version. To have Terrance Dicks revisiting one of his original novels, almost providing a "writing master class" may be add value to any AUDIOGO unabridged release.
0 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on 30 September 2007
The story remains as strong as ever, with a strong sense of darkness present throughout. This is a story about a latterday vampire consuming young girls, set in a world of brutal murders, poverty, prostitution and where giant rats guard the villain's layer. This is a far cry from a space fantasy adventure but instead a downbeat story yet told in a tongue in cheek manner. The result is a highly readable and successful book.