Customer Reviews

3 Reviews
5 star:    (0)
4 star:
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
Most Helpful First | Newest First

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars A Solid Conclusion To The Daleks Masterplan Saga, 11 Dec. 2014
Timelord-007 (The Eccentric Wanderer) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Doctor Who Daleks: The Mutation Of Time (Audio CD)
Doctor Who: Daleks - The Mutation of Time.

Product Info.
Product Info.
Running Time 350 Minutes.
Adapted By: John Peel
Narrated By:
Peter Purves & Jean Marsh
Dalek Voices: Nicholas Briggs

What's Up Doc?
The Daleks Masterplan is well underway with the Time Destroyer, the most deadly machine ever devised, they will conquer the Universe & only one person stands in their way - the Doctor for he has stolen the precious Taranium core which is vital to activate the machine.

Travelling through Time & Space, the Doctor and his companions are forever on the move in case the Daleks track them down. But after several months, to their horror, the TARDIS indicates that they are being followed.

Timelord Thoughts.
This is the second of two novelisations written by John Peel & is based on the TV serial 'The Daleks' Master Plan' based on the mostly missing First Doctor Tv serial "The Daleks' Master Plan" & has now been adapted to audiobook format featuring original actors Peter Purves (Steven Taylor) & Jean Marsh (Sara Kingdom) with Nicholas Briggs voicing the Daleks.

Picking up were 'Mission to the Unknown' left off, this second part novelisation adapts the final six episodes of the mostly missing 12-part First Doctor serial 'The Daleks' Master Plan' & the end result is a bit of a mixed bag.

Strangely there's a more comedic tone to the first half of this second part adaptation which seems tonally wrong as the first half of this serial 'Mission to the Unknown' was darker & grittier especially the aftermath of Katrinas death, these comedic aspects aren't Peels fault as he's simply adapting from the original scripts of co-writer's Terry Nation & Dennis Spooner, with the latter reintroduced the Monk into this epic adventure who's inclusion doesn't work at all well with the tone of this story.

To be fair to John Peel he does write a far more convincing explanation for how the Doctor is able to overcome the Monk's tampering with the TARDIS lock & widens the gap of this adventure by several months for the TARDIS travellers allowing for plenty of unrecorded adventures to feature Sara Kingdom which have since been recorded by Big Finish in a various set of audio dramas.

Peel even includes the light-hearted Christmas episode 'The Feast of Steven' even though it has nothing to do with the overall storyline & feels completely out of place with its humourous tone & silly food fights & would've benefited from being omitted from this audiobook adaption entirely, thankfully the Doctor doesn't reproduce his fourth wall antics here & doesn't wish us all a 'Merry Christmas'.

The highlights of this story for me were Peels adaption of the tragic arc for Sara Kingdom which feels in part a Greek Tragedy as Sara suffers terrible feelings of guilt over the death of her brother Bret Vyon & feels a emotional rage that burns inside her that gives Sara the strength & determination to try & defeat Mavic Chen & put an end to the Daleks Masterplan once & for all but pays a terrible price for it.

The narration duties are once again shared between Peter Purves (Steven Taylor) & Jean Marsh (Sara Kingdom), who take turns reading sections of the story, each of them perform a compelling delivery especially Purves interpretation of the late William Hartnells First Doctor who captures his tones & mannerisms extremely well.

The Dalek voices are of course provided by the excellent Nicholas Briggs who injects such a sinister vicious terrifying tone to the Doctor's deadliest enemys & makes them sound a genuine threatening menace to the universe, while Simon Power returns to scoring & sound effect duties enhancing the drama of this audiobook adaptation & creates a great exciting tension filled atmosphere.

Doctor Who: Daleks - 'The Mutation of Time' is a excellent follow up to 'Mission to the Unknown' & while not as effective tonally as it's predecessor early on it does become more dramatic & engaging towards the later half of the adventure & gives a excellent conclusion to this epic Dalek adventure that's well worth adding to your Doctor Who audiobook collection.

Timelord Rating.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars A Story of Two Halves, 24 Jun. 2014
Amazon Customer "Boo62" (Ilkeston Derbyshire United Kingdom) - See all my reviews
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Doctor Who Daleks: The Mutation Of Time (Audio CD)
This story follows on from one of the best Doctor Who audiobooks I've ever heard, 'Mission to the unknown'.
In that, ( I recommend you listen to that 1st as not only is it superb but it does help explain a lot of what is going on here), the Doctor and his companions are up against the Daleks efforts to control time using something called Taranium which they get from a duplicitous Earth president along with help from a gang of nefarious Galactic rulers all convened on a planet called Kemble.
The Doctor steals the element & he and his chums set off in the TARDIS with the grumpy dustbins in hot pursuit.

This story at first appears to have completely forgotten that plot and as the first hour or two pass it seems the plot is lost all round as we are treated to some of the worst humour and daftest plot elements of any Doctor Who story I've ever heard.
The three hapless heroes stumble from time to time, (including a cringeworthy early movie story which see's the Doctor help Charlie Chaplin come up with a film plot!).
To be honest I came close to giving up altogether at that point as I was pretty miffed at how far things had strayed from the brilliance of the first story.

Things pick up though when everyone turns up in ancient Egypt and when the story finally ends up back on the planet Kemble we are all set for a grandstand finish with the Daleks giving full reign to their nastiness, their 'friends' getting their just desserts and everyone making one last mad dash for the TARDIS.

In the end this concludes really well and very sadly too. It doesn't completely erase the first awful two hours but it does do enough to earn it's four stars and make this worth a listen.

The recording is not the greatest and can be a little fuzzy at times but the narration is pretty spot on. It's funny how Jean Marsh always starts off sounding too posh and mannered in her reading but within a few minutes her style grows on you and she is a dab hand at adding urgency when needed. Peter Purves has a great voice for audio and the two make for a great pairing.
Some recognition should go to Nick Briggs not just for his work as the voice of the Daleks,(he manages some great variety) but also to recommend his own work with Big Finish. His magnum opus, 'Dalek Empire', is a massive 4 part series 18 part classic play that is impossible to over estimate. If you love the Daleks you will be in seventh heaven & I recommend it without reservation.

The Mutation of time however I have some reservations about but they are outweighed by an improved plot midway through & a neat ending to the superb story begun in Mission to the unknown. This is not quite up there with the classics but it's still, eventually, a good 'un & worth a listen.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

6 of 7 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The Daleks' Master Plan (part two), 13 July 2010
This review is from: Doctor Who Daleks: The Mutation Of Time (Audio CD)
THE DALEKS' MASTER PLAN was an epic story that unfolded over thirteen episodes (the one part MISSION TO THE UNKNOWN followed - after a gap of four weeks to tell the story of THE MYTH MAKERS - by the twelve part epic that was THE DALEKS' MASTER PLAN itself) and as such was a story rather too epic to be told in one of the slim Target novelisations of the 1970s and 1980s. Wisely then, John Peel split the story into two separate books of which this is the second, and this audio option has followed much the same format. Be warned then, if you buy this rather impressive 5-CD tale, to get the full story you will probably want to invest in PART ONE: MISSION TO THE UNKNOWN at some point.

However it is worth it because this is a very strong retelling of one of the finer epics from the early years of the TV series and the lengthy running time of the original tale means that some very strong characterisations are possible and that the tragedy of the story of Space Security Agent Sara Kingdom and the machinations of the wicked and treacherous Mavic Chen, the Guardian of the Solar System no less, both unfold on a rather epic scale.

This half of the story picks up from the end of the previous volume with a retelling of the events of the first DOCTOR WHO "Special Christmas Episode" - episode 7 of the 12 - which didn't really progress the plot but actually makes for a few chapters of what is a bit of light-hearted fun before the story takes a darker turn as we are returned to the planet Kembel and rejoin the story from where it was left, with the Daleks and their allies now needing to track down a missing vital element which is needed to help complete their "master plan", and the Doctor just happens to have control of it. For once the TARDIS is actually able to be piloted with rather more success than is usual and a chase through time ensues encompassing locations such as ancient Egypt at the time of the building of the pyramids, and an encounter with another old enemy. Eventually the plot moves back to Kembel and a final devastating encounter with the Doctor's oldest and deadliest of foes.

This volume retells the story told in episodes 7-12 of the television story which is something of a journey through time (whereas the first half was more of a journey through space) but still manages to be a quite successfully self contained as a story in itself although it is the weaker of the two volumes in terms of its dramatic tone and storyline.

Reading duties are shared once more between actors Peter Purves (companion Steven Taylor in the original) and Jean Marsh (who played Sara Kingdom) and whilst they both have very distinct styles, both read the story very well, each doing a couple of chapters at a time presumably because it would have been rather difficult on both them and the listener to have the same voices throughout. The transitions between the blocks they read are unannounced and can take a moment or two to adjust to, but the story is told in dramatic terms and holds the attention very well. Dalek voices are provided by current TV series Dalek voice Nicholas Briggs which probably avoids a lot of general embarrassment all round. The story is enhanced by some subtle but effective sound effects and music all of which makes for a rather impressive package.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Doctor Who Daleks: The Mutation Of Time
Doctor Who Daleks: The Mutation Of Time by John Peel (Audio CD - 3 Jun. 2010)
In stock
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Doctor Who Daleks: Mission To The Unknown (Doctor Who Classics)
5.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (5)   
Buy new£13.25
In stock

Doctor Who And The Dalek Invasion Of Earth
Doctor Who And The Dalek Invasion Of Earth by Terrance Dicks (Audio CD - 5 Nov. 2009)
4.7 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (11)   
Buy new£13.25
Not in stock; order now and we'll deliver when available

Doctor Who Daleks: The Chase
Doctor Who Daleks: The Chase by John Peel (Audio CD - 7 July 2011)
4.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (3)   
Buy new£13.25
In stock