Customer Reviews


6 Reviews
5 star:
 (4)
4 star:
 (2)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 
Most Helpful First | Newest First

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The Ancient Iberians, 9 July 2008
This review is from: Rome's Enemies: Spanish Armies, 218-19 B.C. No.4 (Men-at-Arms) (Paperback)
There is a certian lack of information to be had on the Protohistoric Spanish. Usually they are only ever mentioned in English language texts in passing, either as allies or enemies of the Carthaginians or Romans. It's therefore satisfying to get hold of a book that describes the warriors of this period.

The earliest sections give you a look at the chronological timeline of events, before explaining the campaigns of Viriatus and the Numantine Wars. These help set the scene.

The book then describes the social organisation of the Iberians, their style of warfare, their weapons, armour and equipment. The author also has sections that cover the famous 'falcata' swords, Balearic slingers and Hispanic cavalry.

Angus Mcbride provides some of his best illustrations in the 8 pages of colour plates that are contained in the book. These portray the Iberians at their religious ceremonies, in battle against the Romans, setting ambushes and assaulting fortresses. As usual with McBride, the paintings are detailed, evocative and expressive. Dozens of black and white photographs, basic maps and line drawings help give you a better understanding of the period.

It's not every day you come across such a well written, beautifully illustrated and intelligently edited book on Ancient Iberian warfare. This book will be essential for anyone who has an interest in the Punic Wars. Interested amateurs, wargamers, reenactors and history buffs will also find this book a must have. Highly Recommended!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars 200 years of valiant resistance against Rome - now mostly forgotten, but worthy to be rediscovered..., 23 Jan. 2012
By 
Maciej "Darth Maciek" (Darth Maciek is out there...) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)   
This review is from: Rome's Enemies: Spanish Armies, 218-19 B.C. No.4 (Men-at-Arms) (Paperback)
Most educated people will recognise immediately the names of such great Rome's enemies as Hannibal, Mithridates, Vercingetorix, Arminius or Boadicea. But who, other than the most devoted ancient history passionates, ever heard of Viriatus, elected chieftain of Lusitani, whose career and personality were not unlike those of Sir William Wallace and who for eight years (147-139 BC) resisted Roman legions and dealt them many a heavy blow?

People who lived in ancient times on the territory of today's Spain and Portugal resisted Roman conquest for very exactly 200 years, from 218 to 18 BC, inflicting a great deal of defeats to invaders and claiming lives of numerous Roman commanders. The story of those conflicts merits to be known better than it is now and this little book can help in starting a more profound research on this topic.

There were basically four groups of nations in Iberian Peninsula in the First Iron Age. In the south and on the Mediterranean coasts lived the richest and the most advanced Iberians, who probably migrated to those lands from Northern Africa somewhere around year 1500 BC. Those first migrants probably were the founders of Tartessos kingdom, the first organized state on the peninsula. In time of wars against Rome Iberians were divided in at least 23 tribes, of which the principal were Turdetani, Edetani and Ilergetes. Those nations frequently fought one against other but in other times large tribal coalitions gathered together against common enemies.

Territory populated by the Iberians was large, from today's Andalusia (where dwelled the Turdetani) to the valley of Ebro (home of Ilergetes) and the southern parts of Pyrenees Mountains (strongholds of smaller tribes of Ceretani and Suessetani). Iberians were trading for centuries with Greeks and Phenicians and grew rich and powerful as the result - there were it seems as much as 200 cities on their territories. They were also the most exposed to foreign influences and therefore their civilization was considered by Greeks and Romans as the most advanced and the most sophisticated on the peninsula.

In the north and west of Peninsula lived the tribes made of Celts and completely "celticised" local people. Celts arrived in the peninsula probably around year 650 BC from beyond the Pyrenees Mountains, conquered numerous local tribes and fixed themselves first in what are today regions of Galicia, Asturia and Cantabria - provinces still named today after the three main Celtic tribes of the peninsula: Gallaeci, Astures and Cantabri. The society and civilization of those Celtic nations were close to those of pre-Roman Britain. From those north-western dwellings, Celtic tribes continued their migration south by more pacific means, mixing with locals.

In the rest of the peninsula lived numerous nations issued from a fusion between Celtic and Iberian influences and for that reason called Celtiberians. The most important amongst those tribes were the Lusitani, who occupied most of today's Portugal, the Vettones, the Vaccei, the Carpetani, the Arevaci and the Pellendones. The Lusitani were probably the most powerful single nation on the whole peninsula. The Arevaci, although less numerous, were rich and very efficient at war and their capital, Numantia, was with a population of around 12 000 people one of the biggest local cities (together with Carthago Nova, Saguntum and Gadira, known today respectively as Carthagena, Sagunto and Cadiz).

There was one more tribe living in Spain in those times, a nation different both from the Celts and Iberians - the Vascones, who are today called the Basques. Their territory was limited to the most unaccessible mountain valleys in western Pyrenees Mountains. It is considered that they were (and still are) the last remaining survivors of the original population of Iberian Peninsula. Protected by their mountains they kept their language and separate identity when their brethren were assimilated by successive waves of Indo-European migrants/invaders, in times predating both Iberian and Celtic arrivals. Vascones didn't fight Rome, but negotiated their surrender against a large autonomy - and considering the poverty and the tormented landscape of their lands this arrangement suited Romans just fine.

This short book describes briefly the main tribes mentioned above and offers a commented chronology of all campaigns between 218 BC (first landing of Roman troops) and 18 BC, when Iberian Peninsula was declared secured and most of legions send to other provinces. There are roughly six stages of conquest (excluding minor rebellions and guerillas):

- 219-202 BC. Second Punic War. It is worth to remind here that this monumental conflict started precisely on the peninsula, with Hannibal laying siege to Roman protected city of Saguntum. In 219 BC most of Iberian territory was in fact part of Carthaginian Empire and Iberian and Celtiberian troops were a large part of Hannibal army which went to Italy. It took Romans 13 years of bloody fighting to wrestle the control of those lands from Carthaginians and their local allies - and there were still many Iberian and Celtiberian mercenaries fighting for Hannibal at Zama...
- 197-178 BC. Numerous rebellions of Iberian tribes against their new Roman masters - ultimately defeated, although with much difficulty.
- 155-132 BC. Lusitan and Numantin Wars (including the war against Viriatus). At the end of this period Rome controls most of the peninsula - but the blood price paid for all the conquests was very high.
- 82-72 BC. Sertorian Wars. Iberians and Celtiberians profit from civil war in Rome to side with an exiled Roman warlord Sertorius, who creates a de facto independent "kingdom" in the peninsula, before being ultimately defeated.
- 49-44 BC. War in Spain between Caesar and Pompeius. Local nations divide their loyalties between the two warlords.
- 29-18 BC. Roman conquest of last independent tribes of Peninsula: Iberian Vaccei and the three Celtic nations (Gallaeci, Astures, Cantabri).

For lack of space, only two campaigns are described in more detail: Viriatus resistance against Romans and the Numantin Wars. Even if the description is short and superficial, those are two really GREAT stories! I can only imagine what wonderful movies could be done about those heroic and tragic fights...

Weapons, armor and tactics of ancient Spain nations are a fascinating topic, here described briefly but still well enough to give a very useful introduction to the matter. External influences were many in the peninsula, like the "falcata" short sword which was the main personal weapon of many Iberians and Celtiberians - it was most probably an improved copy of the very efficient Greek "kopis" sword. The Celts on their side introduced to the peninsula their long "La Tene" swords and many local warriors favored them for their longer reach.

On another hand, the purely local short sword "gladius hispaniensis" impressed Romans so much, that they adopted it as the standard personal weapon of their infantry - renamed simply "gladius" it remained in service in legions for more than 400 years! A second local invention, the "soliferrum" ultra heavy javelin is of particular interest as - in my modest opinion - it could have been a major influence on the development of Roman "pilum". Finally another local specialty is not forgotten in the book - the almost legendary Balearic slingers who served Hannibal and later the Romans with terrifying efficiency.

Black and white illustrations are very good and the color plates by Angus McBride are a PLEASURE to the eyes! Maps on another hand are rather bad and it is a good idea to print something on this topic from wikipedia, to better understand the subject.

All in all, this is an excellent Osprey book, offering great value for a very moderate price. I am keeping my copy preciously and will never part with it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Another excellent addition to the Osprey Romes enemies series., 19 Mar. 2015
This review is from: Rome's Enemies: Spanish Armies, 218-19 B.C. No.4 (Men-at-Arms) (Paperback)
The perfect companion for all military history enthusiasts is: THE ROMA VICTRIX WINE BEAKERCalix Imperium, Roma Victrix Pewter wine beaker
Martinez covers the divisions and relationships between Celts, Iberians, Celtiberians, and Lusitanians comprehensively, listing the various tribes and sub-tribes, and showing on one map the approximate locations of the tribes.

The narrative discusses tactics, and touches on Viriatus's campaigns and the Numantine wars.

There are eight excellent colour plates by the late Angus McBride.

The Peoples of Protohistoric Spain
Warfare in Ancient Spain
Chronology
Impact of the Hispanic Wars on Rome
The Campaigns of Viriatus
The Numantine Wars
Armour and Weapons
Hispanic Cavalry
Balearic Slingers
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Old but still superb and one of the best, 29 April 2014
By 
JPS - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Rome's Enemies: Spanish Armies, 218-19 B.C. No.4 (Men-at-Arms) (Paperback)
This is an old Osprey title, first published in 1986 (and reprinted since) and illustrated by the much regretted Angus McBride. It only has one thing missing: there is no list of references for further reading simply because Osprey Men-at-Arms did not include any at the time, so the usual author/illustrator pair can hardly be blamed for that. Otherwise, it has it all, perhaps with the exception of a little glitch.

The first section lays out the scene by briefly presenting “The peoples of proto-historic Spain” and clearly describes the three main groups, and they social organisation and obligations, and the respective territories that they occupied in the Iberian Peninsula.
The two next sections present the warfare in Ancient Spain, and the impact it had on Rome. These sections, which include a rather detailed chronology, help to show to what extent the tribes in Iberia were major trouble for Rome, and, with the help of geography, continued to be so for about two centuries, well after the demise of Carthage, of Greece and the Hellenistic Kingdoms, and of Gaul, to name just these few.

To illustrate to what extent they were trouble, the (Spanish) author has picked the campaigns of Viriathus and the Numantine wars, showing that in both cases the Romans suffered multiple defeats and disasters before finally winning what had become wars of attrition. A related feature is to show that one reason for these ongoing and endemic rebellions was the very behaviour of most of the Roman commanders, with each new commander (although they were a couple of exceptions) stirring up trouble of his own through his exactions in order to gather plunder and glory and make a name for himself. To illustrate this, the author lists the rather huge amounts of gold and silver that a selection of commanders each extracted and came back to Rome with.

Here is where there is a slight glitch, with the author stating that “the Second Punic War was financed with the silver that the Romans extracted from the mines around Cartagena.” While true, this only happened at best during the second half of the war and certainly not before 209 BC (at the earliest) when Scipio conquered Cartagena from the Carthaginians. Before that (and, for some of the mines, perhaps even up to 206 BC, when the last Carthaginian army was defeated in Spain), the silver and gold mines from Iberia were financing the Carthaginian war effort, and Hannibal’s one in particular.

The next section is about armour, weapons and troop types, whether medium or light infantry, including the well-known and fearsome Balearic slingers, or Iberian cavalry. At least some of it, thanks to the stamina of the Iberian horses, could help carry an extra infantryman, thereby giving increased mobility to their forces and making them that much more difficult to catch for the more heavily equipped legions. One of the main features of this section is to show to what extent Rome “borrowed” much of its equipment from the Celts in general, and the Iberians in particular. The case of the “Gladius Hispaniensis” is the best known, of course, although the puggio (the legionary’s triangular dagger) is also of Iberian origin, while mail, some of the Roman helmets (the Montefortino types), the La Tène long swords (as “ancestors” of the spatha) and the large scutum shields were all borrowed from the Celts and improved.

Finally, there are the (simply gorgeous!) plates. One interesting feature is that, for each of them, the source of inspiration is clearly indicated and is even often included in the book through photos. One example is the superb golden pectoral of the Iberian chieftain who is part of the front page illustration. Another is the double plate (D-E) showing six Iberians hidden on the top of a hill and waiting to ambush a Roman column. While the authors mention quite candidly that they have put together characters whose appearance and equipment belonged to several different tribes, they also mention that there were cases where warriors from several of them could fight together, especially against the hated Romans. Five stars for a rather superb title.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4.0 out of 5 stars Caution, 2 Oct. 2012
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Rome's Enemies: Spanish Armies, 218-19 B.C. No.4 (Men-at-Arms) (Paperback)
I would echo the views of the previous reviewers but would add a note of caution. My copy seems to be reprint so teh normally excellent Osprey colour plates and a little blurry and out of focus - buy second hand !
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent book. Delivered on time, 1 Jan. 2015
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Rome's Enemies: Spanish Armies, 218-19 B.C. No.4 (Men-at-Arms) (Paperback)
Excellent book.Delivered on time .
Didn't know the Spanish were such a tough nut for the romans .
Well worth it for the info. I was looking for.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Rome's Enemies: Spanish Armies, 218-19 B.C. No.4 (Men-at-Arms)
Rome's Enemies: Spanish Armies, 218-19 B.C. No.4 (Men-at-Arms) by Angus McBride (Paperback - 26 Mar. 1992)
£9.99
In stock
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews