12 of 12 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Monumental , sound and sobering
Anthony Beevor's book provides an excellent and often compassionate account of this most appalling human tragedy. It is written in his well established authorative yet readable style. I am not an historian as such but as far as I can tell, from other books I have consulted, Beevor has successfully brought together the account of this event and clearly demonstrates why...
Published on 26 Sept. 2012 by Ariadne
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Text Great, But!
I'm no expert. I assume the facts are accurate, and it is well told. Also has a lot of personal first-hand experiences and quotations. BUT the maps are TERRIBLE and far too few, most even lack a legend. To wit - even the end-paper map is almost totally useless! I'm surprised Mr. Beevor could allow this to occur. In contrast, his Stalingrad has better, more informative...
Published 10 months ago by Robert Thomas Macrery
Most Helpful First | Newest First
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Monumental , sound and sobering,
Anthony Beevor's book provides an excellent and often compassionate account of this most appalling human tragedy. It is written in his well established authorative yet readable style. I am not an historian as such but as far as I can tell, from other books I have consulted, Beevor has successfully brought together the account of this event and clearly demonstrates why WWII still casts the long shadow across generations like mine, fortunate enough not to have experience of it at first hand. I have been a little surprised that some celebrated episodes are not referred to even in passing, but I accept that in a single volume like this, some events may have played a rather minor part in WWII as a whole. It is a harrowing account and one wonders how anyone who lived through the Second World War would not be altered and conditioned by it. The brutality of it as described here is at times utterly distressing.
The book suffers from a deficiency in maps (there are a few but they are not the best). A work like this could do with a supporting website to provide clearer and more detailed cartography, or failing that, at least perhaps a recommended war atlas to provide locations and campaigns that formed the contexts of the war, and the chapters of this book.
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Text Great, But!,
This review is from: The Second World War (Paperback)
I'm no expert. I assume the facts are accurate, and it is well told. Also has a lot of personal first-hand experiences and quotations. BUT the maps are TERRIBLE and far too few, most even lack a legend. To wit - even the end-paper map is almost totally useless! I'm surprised Mr. Beevor could allow this to occur. In contrast, his Stalingrad has better, more informative maps. For those who rely on maps for a more visual record of battles (as opposed to a verbal telling), The Historical Atlas of World War II (Chartwell Books, 2008) is about as good as it gets.
266 of 283 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A panoramic tale of woe and triumph from a master historian,
The sheer immensity of the Second World War is even now, after more ink has been spilt on it than on almost any other event in history, almost impossible to grasp. The war affected countless people in every conceivable small and big way, it changed the fate of innumerable nations and set the tone for issues with which we are still grappling, and it showcased the very best and very worst in human nature. Very few historians are capable of capturing this epic panorama of tragedy and triumph on paper. Happily for us, Antony Beevor is one of those chosen few who can. In the past few decades he has established himself as a war historian of the first rank. This volume can be seen as the culmination of a stellar career during which he has introduced us to the very nature of war and its human elements. Beevor's sweeping, magisterial account of this great conflict excels in three ways that are characteristic of his past scholarship on D-Day, Stalingrad and Berlin.
Firstly, Beevor delivers the raw strategic and historical facts with a relentless, crisp pace, covering all major events, participants and theaters of war. The history is informed by a treasure trove of material cited in the notes, including personal sources such as the invaluable diary of Soviet correspondent Vasily Grossman. There are 50 chapters and the title of each chapter describes the one or two key events narrated in it. The brevity of the chapters makes the book accessible and great for bedtime reading. A particular skill of Beevor's is in condensing the most important information in relatively brief paragraphs. Rather than provide separate extended quotes from the prime participants, he excerpts these quotes within the paragraphs. Even a book that is 800 pages long cannot possibly spend too much time on every single event; Beevor understands this and is remarkably facile at saying much in a minimum number of words. It's also worth comparing this volume with the acclaimed recent book by Max Hastings. Hastings's is more of an on-the-ground perspective detailing the travails and triumphs of ordinary people. Beevor's is a higher-level account that nonetheless includes enough personal details to bring out the brutality of the war. Both are outstanding.
Unlike many other works, Beevor begins his story not with the traditional German invasion of Poland in 1939 but with the Soviet defeat of the Japanese in Manchuria one month earlier. In fact one of the major strengths of the book that sets it apart from many other volumes is its constant focus on the conflict in the Far East between Japan, China and the Soviet Union whose origins preceded European events. This theme surfaces regularly in the book as it should since the Japanese occupation of Manchuria, as exemplified by the horrific Rape of Nanking, was as momentous for the future of the war as anything else. Along the same lines, while Beevor does cover major battles in Europe and the Pacific like the Battle of Britain, France, El Alamein, Stalingrad, Pearl Harbor, Normandy, Italy, Midway and the U-Boat conflict with verve and clarity, he also has separate detailed chapters on (relatively) minor but still key war zones like Egypt, Greece and Burma. An especially rousing story is of the small Finnish army virtually demolishing the overwhelmingly large Soviet forces at the start of the war through guerrilla warfare. Large, clear maps displaying movements and sites of major battles accompany every account. Descriptions of weapons systems, code-breaking and terrain-specific equipment all benefit from Beevor's concise style. In chapters on the Holocaust and Soviet purges, he chillingly documents the incalculably horrific crimes of the twentieth century's two genocidal tyrants, Hitler and Stalin, even as he does not fail to detail their shrewd genius in manipulating human beings and events. Stalin especially clearly comes across as an egomaniacal but calculating strategist who ensured his share of the postwar spoils during meetings with Roosevelt and Churchill at Yalta, Tehran and Potsdam.
Secondly, just as he did in past works, Beevor is remarkable at documenting the human element in the war in all its terrifying cruelty and redeeming glory. All the horrors of the war are on full display here; the NKVD murdering its own people by the hundreds of thousands, the Japanese mutilating Chinese women with bayonets, the cold killing soldiers so swiftly that they resembled grotesque ice sculptures, the citizens of Leningrad eating their own children in the face of desperate starvation and madness, Russian soldiers raping every female between eight and eighty after "liberating" Berlin, and of course, the systematic, industrialized mass murder of Jews during the Holocaust. A particularly disturbing and startling fact which I was not aware of concerns horrible experiments with biological agents performed on American POWs by Japanese doctors, often with fatal results. The disturbing thing is that Douglas MacArthur granted immunity from prosecution to these doctors in the hope that they would provide detailed records to the Allies. This story only drives home the fact that the war which Beevor writes of was unimaginably horrific and blurred moral boundaries, and particularly because it is unimaginably so, the passage of time should never blind us to it. While many deeds in the war were undoubtedly immoral, ambiguous morality was also a constant theme, whether it concerned MacArthur's behavior or the strategic bombing of German cities. We are still debating these issues.
But there are also acts of incredible altruism described in here; ordinary Germans sacrificing themselves to protect Jews, hopelessly outnumbered Jews rising against monstrous despots (as in the Warsaw uprising), and people transcending religion, class and political sentiments to save the lives of total strangers. These accounts are accompanied by characteristically vivid - and at times amusing - character sketches which concisely showcase the essential qualities of major participants; for instance, Chamberlain is out of depth with his "winged collar, Edwardian mustache and rolled umbrella". All major human alliances, including the famously successful relationship between Churchill and Roosevelt, are chronicled with wit, compassion and insight. Another of Beevor's talents is in conveying the sheer absurdity and surreal nature of war; for example there's Hermann Goering complaining about the price of shattered glass panes during Kristallnacht, and the French gingerly broadcasting a song named "I will wait" even as German forces amassed across the border in plain sight in 1940. Most emblematic of how downright bizarre war can be is the story of a Korean private named Yang Kyoungjong who was captured and conscripted successively by the Japanese, the Soviets and the Germans.
Finally, Beevor does a stunning job at giving us an idea of the sheer irrationality and utterly brutalizing nature of war and how it changes everyone and everything. Fifty or sixty years after the fact, the Second World War appears like a series of rationally organized if tragic incidents culminating in the victory of good over evil. It's accounts like this that dispel that illusion and tell us that so many events were just based on good or bad luck. But in concluding this magisterial narrative, Beevor leaves us with the caveat that in the irrationality of war lies hope, the possibility that things could have been different had people acted just a little differently. In case of the Second World War that would have translated to France, Britain and the United States recognizing Hitler's ominous and growing power in the 30s and banding together to stop him. Of course it is convenient to conclude this in hindsight, but it still makes a case for always being alert in recognizing the wrong turns that human nature can take. Indeed, Beevor reminds us in the end that "moral choice is the fundamental element in human drama, because it lies at the very heart of humanity itself". This is a lesson we should remember until the end of time.
76 of 82 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars accessible yet horrifying single volume history of WWII,
This is a superbly written, and very readable, account which covers the global sweep of the Second World War, with clear explanation of the factors which drove events at the time, as well as excellent narrations of the events themselves. There is also a strong human dimension in the writing - the motivations of the key players and the effects of war on the lives of combatants and civilians is recounted superbly, often in the words of those who were there.
Antony Beevor's magisterial, and superbly researched, history is not biased towards coverage of a particular geographical region or country. This history explains the events of the war in each of the main, and many of the smaller, theatres of war; there is much here for, example, about the events in Asia, as well as the war in Western and Eastern Europe. As a general reader i found much that was new to me, and many fresh insights into the events of which I already had fairly good knowledge
Beevor makes clear the horror of war, and its appalling human cost, whilst providing a highly informative, beautifully illustrated and very readable narrative.
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The Second World War by Antony Beevor,
The Second World War by Antony Beevor is a well written book on an epic conflict on a global scale and a highly documented subject.
To take on a subject as complex and as multi-faceted as the second World War and still keep the narrative interesting would be a challenge to any author and yet Antony Beevor manages to do this in the books 879 pages.
The book deals with the all aspects of the War from the European and Pacific Theatres and their decisive battles and campaigns to the less well known ones such as those in North Africa, Burma and the campaigns in the Mediterranean region.
I also liked the way the book deals with not just the Major characters in the War such as Churchill, Hitler, Stalin etc... but also the perspective of ordinary soldiers on both sides and also the innocent civilians who got caught up in the conflict.
I first heard about the book through BBC History magazines Podcast where the Author Antony Beevor was interviewed and some aspects of his book and his approach to the material were discussed and it pricked my curiosity.
Needless to say the book is a compulsive read by an engaging author. I highly recommed it to those interested in the History of the World War Two and History lovers in general.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Exhaustive and exhausting,
This review is from: The Second World War (Kindle Edition)
Anthony Beevor's rather dry style contrasts with similar tomes from Max Hastings. To cover the whole of the war means economy of detail, but that means human aspects get less profound treatment than descriptions of battles and war politics. The range of the book is vast, and some aspects of WW2 such as the Chinese battles get much fuller description than I have read before.
One thing really stands out-the pivotal changes that came during 1943; before, all is Axis winning, after, all is their losing, but the point at which that happens is very clearly shown.
Of the two books, I marginally preferred Max Hastings' "Armageddon"-both detail the almost incredible scale of the death and destruction, not only of the Jewish race but of so many other victims of the Nazi regime. Both show how much worse it was than WW1, bringing perspective to the rather pro-British traditional views of both wars. But Max seems to convey the vast tragedy of it rather better.
77 of 86 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Beautifully written tale but is material too familiar?,
There is already a much more erudite and in depth review of the book above so all I can add are my impressions of it which may be of value to you.
Whilst I eagerly devour just about anything written about WWII I was particularly looking forward to this all encompassing book on the war. I am probably in the majority in that I have just finished Max Hastings' similar effort before tackling this and I have to say that this book is a much more - the only word I can think of is - entertaining read. It is truly a delight and I have finished it in a two day readathon. This has NOT been time wasted. I have one, probably obvious, caveat in that similarly to Mr Beevor's last book on D-Day there is not much new on display here. This could have been a problem had not well known events take on new resonance with the author's brisk and incisive style. For me this style still didn't make "D-Day" the great book it promised to be but it would appear that there is enough room when writing about the war as a whole to find nuggets that keep the pace going to the end.
All in all this book created a dilemma for me because in some eyes a 5 star review should be reserved for uncondtionally great books, and because this book largely goes over old ground perhaps it cannot be deemed "great" in that sense but I have looked at Amazon's "rules" and apparently a five star review should be reserved for a book one has "loved" and i loved this book.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Beevor's fine and literate single-volume history is an admirable synthesis,
To attempt to write a one-volume history of the greatest conflict in the history of mankind is a daunting task: you're bound to offend or displease someone by giving short shrift to their particular pet subject/campaign/national army/theatre of war, or omit some detail considered important by a minority of readers.
Antony Beevor's `The Second World War' stands out in a crowded field of single-volume WW2 histories by being extremely well-written in a style as succinct as it is intelligent and literate, organised into 50 roughly chronological chapters of unequal length and running to 783 pages excluding the index and notes. Beevor offers us a deep understanding of the interdependence of different parts of the global conflict, how for example the long and bitterly-fought war in China between the Nationalists and the invading Japanese armies impacted decisions by Stalin and the STAVKA how and when to deploy formations in the war against the Wehrmacht; at the same time 700,000 Japanese troops tied down in the Chinese conflict were unavailable for the Pacific theatre. Focus is brought to oft-neglected episodes like the short Soviet-Japanese war in the Nomonhan region of Mongolia in 1939 (which Beevor claims with justification marked the actual start of WW2), the brief but savage civil war in Greece in 1944-45 after the German forces departed, and the unbelievable scale of bloodletting in the battles for Budapest and Konigsburg where the death toll ran to hundreds of thousands.
A thorough analysis is presented as to how Churchill (with his obsessive desire for a post-war free & democratic Poland), the genial-but-deepdown-scheming Roosevelt and others in the British and US governments were repeatedly outwitted and out-maneuvered by the cold, calculating and deeply paranoid Stalin, the real victor of WW2. Few of the best-known military leaders - Rommel, Eisenhower, MacArthur, Montgomery, `Vinegar Joe' Stilwell, `Bomber' Harris of the RAF, De Gaulle, Mark Clark - come out of Beevor's narrative covered in glory, the character flaws of all these and many others laid bare.
A notable shortcoming is the poor quality of the maps, too small and lacking detail to be of any use to the reader unfamiliar with the campaigns and who might not have better reference material available. The choice and sheer range of subjects of the monochrome photos however is excellent, and does justice to the global nature of the war.
Beevor's book does not spare the reader details of the ubiquitous horror which characterised the conflict: eyewitness accounts of naked and shorn prisoners, half-starved, being driven by sadistic guards with packs of savage dogs into the gas chambers at Treblinka (where 800,000 were murdered in 13 months, more than at Auschwitz in the same period); the mass gang rapes, murder and pillage perpetrated by Russian soldiers in East Prussia in January-February 1945; the details of how tens of thousands of German & Japanese civilians were incinerated in firebomb attacks by allied air forces; the murderous persecutions of the NKVD against almost everyone including their East European allies and Russian prisoners `liberated' from German POW camps unjustly assumed to have been `collaborators' because they had obeyed their Red Army officers' orders to surrender. One particular detail to which Beevor devotes a couple of pages is the widespread practice of cannibalism among Japanese forces in Asia, who (evidence and testimony from survivors proves) regularly killed and ate Chinese, Burmese and Papuan civilians, POWs and even their own comrades. All this hatred and brutality does not sit well with our 21st century sensibilities but it happened, nevertheless, and just about within living memory.
Overall, Beevor has done a fine job with this massive subject. You will find his book particularly informative if you do not have extensive knowledge of the period but are looking for more than just a general overview; perhaps less so the history buff already steeped in the detail of the military campaigns and political background to the conflict. The writing style is crisp and engaging, the narrative gripping, the editing good (literally two or three minor grammatical errors in 800 pages). Regardless of your present knowledge and reading history about this conflict, this book is highly recommended.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Masterful and cinematic yet also personal and revealing,
Anthony Beevor's sweeping, colossal account of the disaster that was The Second World War is given a near-cinematic touch in this grand narrative history. While no individual book can hope to be all-encompassing on any single subject, especially one as multi-layered as WWII, Beevor presents what may be the definitive single volume account of the most destructive conflict in human history.
All the familiar bases are touched upon yet such is Beevor's skill as both researcher and writer, that he brings something fresh to each chapter. Yes, he does reuse small parts of his previous books but then, if you have already written superb histories of individual battles, why rewrite what was already excellent in the first place. Unfamiliar facets are also brought to light, for me at least, such as the conflict betwixt Japan & Russia on the Chinese mainland.
As with his previous books, what breathes life in to what could be dry military history is the personal anecdote, that really brings out the human dimension in these titanic struggles - the plight of refugees uprooted from their homelands, attempting to escape being literally crushed by a vast incoming army, or the fear of trapped civilians, waiting for one army and then another to destroy their historic towns.
If there was any one criticism to make of this book, it is that, like a great meal, there is perhaps just too much to digest and that could make it potentially off-putting for some. That said, certain readers will devour this book from end to end, while others may wish to dip in to this a chapter at a time. Regardless, Anthony Beevor has written such a rich and evocative account of this terrible war that it is impossible not to be touched by the sorrow, chaos, bravery, humanity and savagery that he illustrates in this masterful history.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Detailed 'tour de force' by one of the UK's top historians,
A superior detailed analysis of the 20th century's greatest conflict. Gives equal prominence to events in the Far East/Pacific theatre and the huge loss of life there. (Indeed the narrative begins with the Japanese seizure of Manchuria and clashes between the Japanese and Red Army in the years leading up to 1939 .) At over 800 pages, no sentence is wasted - each paragraph a wealth of detail . Presentation is important to me and this book is beautifully presented in hard back, its over 800 pages printed on white paper slightly thicker than that found in traditional bibles in order to keep the size and weight down.Indeed the bibliography appears on the author's website, presumably for the same reason. Lavishly illustrated with b/w photos and useful maps at endpapers . Make sure you buy the hardback version while it is half price on Amazon. You'll be delighted with your purchase !
Most Helpful First | Newest First
The Second World War by Antony Beevor (Paperback - 26 Sept. 2013)