Customer Reviews


98 Reviews
5 star:
 (70)
4 star:
 (23)
3 star:
 (2)
2 star:
 (1)
1 star:
 (2)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


101 of 103 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars History as it should be written.
The conflict between Ottoman Turkey and Christian Spain for mastery of the Mediterranean basin had a huge influence on the development of the modern world, yet is probably not something you know very much about, even if you studied history at school. Roger Crowley deals with the key period of this struggle during the 16th Century in a page-turner of a narrative peopled...
Published on 5 Jun. 2008 by Michael Edwards

versus
35 of 40 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Great story
Crowley does an extraordinary job putting together three extraordinary stories that marked the 16th Century in the Mediterranean: The siege of Rhodes, the siege of Malta, and the Battle of Lepanto. These stories, especially that of the siege of Malta, makes the book read like a novel, most enthralling and nail biting.

Although Crowley has written a very...
Published on 21 Oct. 2008 by Borja Echegaray Aguirrezabal


‹ Previous | 1 210 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

101 of 103 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars History as it should be written., 5 Jun. 2008
By 
Michael Edwards (Gloucestershire U.K.) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
The conflict between Ottoman Turkey and Christian Spain for mastery of the Mediterranean basin had a huge influence on the development of the modern world, yet is probably not something you know very much about, even if you studied history at school. Roger Crowley deals with the key period of this struggle during the 16th Century in a page-turner of a narrative peopled with almost larger-than-life personalities - Suleiman the Magnificent, Bluebeard the Pirate (actually there were father and son Bluebeards) - Andrea Doria, the mercenary Admiral, and a supporting cast of Kings and Popes. What becomes clear is how very close the Ottomans came to extending their Empire into France, Italy and Spain, and how much better organised they were than the European powers who faced them.
The centrepiece of the book is the siege of Malta. The heroism of the defenders would not be believed if it were fiction, and the complex tale is told with exemplary clarity.
You may find parallels in the 21st Century, but Roger Crowley wisely doesn't labour them. Read it twice!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


12 of 12 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Empires of the Sea, 4 Dec. 2008
By 
Read a review in the Wall St. Journal which wetted my appetite. Being a history buff it intrigued me. The book was an excellent read, covering the Seige of Malta, the Battle of Lepanto and the Contest for the Center of the World in the sixteenth century. The constant battle for supremacy in the Christian/Muslim world with it's shattering disregard for human life. After it was all over little had really changed and that state of affairs continues to this day. Magnificent descriptions of battles, especially the sea battle at Lepanto which is described as "Europe's Trafalgar" during which 40,000 were killed in four hours and really ended the crusades of the time.
There is a lot to relate to in today's world.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


20 of 21 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Pacy narrative history lifted by two gripping set pieces, 10 Dec. 2009
By 
Kentspur (Er...Kent) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)   
This is a pacy, easy-to-read overview of the steady westward movement of the Ottoman Empire in the Sixteenth century Mediterrean and it's crunching full stop at the Battle of Lepanto in 1571. Like the many books on the Crusades, it has modern resonances and maintains an even-handedness throughout.

The strengths are the descriptions of the siege of Malta- in particular - and the cataclysmic battle of Lepanto. The weaknesses are a little bit of 'reaching' to make this area, perhaps, more fundamental to modern Europe than it actually was - describing the conflict as a 'world war' for example and the failure to convey what the combatants in a naval battle are actually trying to do or achieve. How does a sea battle 'work'? I am sure the author was trying to avoid the level of detail that takes a book like this - very much a popular history - into a military history sales cul-de-sac, but I felt this undercut some of the tension. The siege description was far more gripping.

Nevertheless in a decent epilogue, Roger Crowley makes the pithy point that rising prices and cheap labour costs in the Christian West did as much to undermine the Ottomans as Don Juan's galleys. Capitalism wins again!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


17 of 19 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars EMPIRES OF THE SEA, 22 Jun. 2009
By 
Hillpaul (West Sussex, GB) - See all my reviews
Another cliff-hanger from Crowley as he tears aside the veil of a `clash of civilisations' to show the people beneath, some of whom, yes, fought for Christianity or Islam, some of whom like Hayrettin Barbarossa fought for revenge and profit as much as for the Prophet. Some like the countless thousands of galley-slaves fought to stay alive (the supply of whom stripped coastal regions and perpetuated the war in a self-feeding cycle).More realpolitik than religion, this is Pirenne's divided Mediterranean, both sides aping the defunct Roman Empire, trying to project their version of it. Starting with the siege of Rhodes and Famagusta whose commander met a gruesome end, skinned alive and the skin stuffed and dressed in finery and sent to the Sultan, this book tells the next chapter of Ottoman expansion after the Fall of Constantinople and a grim remorseless story it is.
Thematically structured into two parts, the siege of Malta and the battle of Lepanto, both presented as huge triumphs in the West, Cervantes describing Lepanto as the `greatest event witnessed by ages past, present and to come', slight setbacks in the East.
As for Malta, forget the Alamo which held out for two weeks, the fight to hold St. Elmo's fort which held out for a month would read like a pot-boiler if it were not true, down to the very end when its captain Miranda had himself tied to a chair because of his wounds and waited by the gate with his pistols and his swords for the Janissaries who stormed the building.
Lepanto where the two fleets blundered into each other, produced an apocalyptic battle that is hard to credit when reading the story in the comfort of an armchair. The rate of death, 40,000 in the first four hours, would not be equalled until WWI.
A loss which the Ottomans were able to replenish within a year, but the value of Lepanto and Malta was to show that the Ottomans could be beaten on land and at sea. The West gave up trying to reconquer the Holy Land and the Ottomans refocused on Eastern Europe where logistical overstretch and a moribund intellectual outlook eventually did for them. Both recognised the de facto split in the Mediterranean which exists to today.
Narrative history at its best. I can't wait to see what he does next.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


35 of 40 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Great story, 21 Oct. 2008
By 
Crowley does an extraordinary job putting together three extraordinary stories that marked the 16th Century in the Mediterranean: The siege of Rhodes, the siege of Malta, and the Battle of Lepanto. These stories, especially that of the siege of Malta, makes the book read like a novel, most enthralling and nail biting.

Although Crowley has written a very accurate and detailed account of these clashes between the Christian and Muslim worlds, one gets the impression, that he tends to minimize the role of Christian leaders, their armies and the importance of their victories, and maximizes that of the Ottoman side. For example, he doesn't give much importance to the conquest of Tunis by Emperor Charles V, while he gets to the detail with other minor Turkish exploits.

The author is notably pro Turkish throughout most of the book, presenting the Christians as more religious fanatics than the Muslims, when probably both were exactly the same. The fact that Crowley lived for a long period of his life in Istanbul may explain this and that he recreates himself longer when detailing the fascinating ottoman world. This is perfectly clear, when at the end of the book he goes through the list of mausoleums and great internments of all the ottoman main characters, while he ignores the final resting place of the Christian kings and admirals.

However, the book is fully recommendable, and anybody interesting in this period of history, and in the last of the crusades, will surely enjoy it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


36 of 43 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Superb narrative history of an epic struggle, 4 Aug. 2008
By 
David Burke (Ireland) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
The clash of civilisations is not a new notion. Civilisations have clashed for thousands of years, as rival tribes and nations with varying cultural mores and religious beliefs have struggled for supremacy.
In recorded history, Greek fought Persian, Roman fought Carthaginian (and countless others), and Christian fought Muslim.
It's the latter that we think of today when we shudder at the memory of 9/11 or sigh over the pointless loss of life in the Middle East.
This is a struggle that has flared up intermittently since the First Crusade in 1096 brought a motley crew of robber knights, religious zealots and sundry opportunists to wrest the holy places of Palestine from the hands of their Muslim overlords.
The crusades petered out towards the end of the 13th century, but at least one of the organisations that was born in the blood and sand of the Middle East survives today. They are the Knights of Malta, and while we know them as providers of an excellent voluntary ambulance and first aid service, their history was not always as peaceful.
The Knights Hospitaller of St John of Jerusalem, of Rhodes and of Malta figure largely in a marvellous new book which chronicles one phase of the Christian-Muslim conflict, the bitter struggle for mastery of the Mediterranean between 1521 and 1580.
In Empires of the Sea Roger Crowley brings back to mind half-remembered history lessons - the fall of Rhodes, the rise of the Barbary corsairs, the siege of Malta and the decisive battle of Lepanto.
Most people now who think of Malta in military terms focus on the siege during World War II when the tiny mountain top between Sicily and North Africa withstood months of attack by the German and Italian air forces. For its endurance, the island and its people were collectively awarded the George Cross, the highest British civilian award for gallantry.
But almost 400 years earlier, the Maltese and their then rulers, the Knights of St John, were tenacious in the defence of their stronghold against a huge Ottoman army which besieged them from May to September 1565.
The Ottomans, referred to by most of their oppponents as the Turks, although they comprised many more races, were experts at siege warfare. Crowley has already written about their capture of Constantinople and this book starts with the attack on Rhodes in 1522 after which the Knights were allowed to sail away to Malta. Among those who left was a young knight, Jean de la Valette, who as Grand Master of the order presided over and inspired the successful defence of Malta forty years later.
La Valette is just one of the giant personalities who people this account. On the Ottoman side are the sultans, Suleiman the Magnificent and his son Selim; the military commanders, Ali Pasha and Mustapha Pasha; the fearsome corsair Barbarossa; and many more.
For Christendom there are Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor, and after him his son, King Philip of Spain; the Genoese admiral Andrea Doria; the Venetian Sebastiano Venier; and the great Romantic hero Don Juan of Austria. Don Juan was the illegitimate son of Charles, half-brother of Philip, and his victory at the crucial naval battle of Lepanto in 1571 sparked innumerable poems, songs and dramas. He was even celebrated by GK Chesterton in his poem "Lepanto" as late as 1915.
If the personalities are giant, the events are huge. Vast amounts of gold were poured into building and equipping ships on both sides, and at times the losses were enormous. The naval battles were fought with galleys, rowed often but not always by slaves, which rammed each other to provide platforms for fierce hand to hand fighting.
The book reads like a thriller. It is narrative history, and the narrative it relates would scarcely be credible if it were presented as a work of fiction.
Heroes and villains abound, often in the same camp. Both sides are capable of great cruelty and great courage. In the siege of Malta La Valette stands in his armour in the front line of the defence as the Turks swarm up the rubble of a defensive wall.
At the last minute, on the most dangerous day of the siege, as in the most clichéd war movie, the cavalry literally comes over the hill and attacks the undefended enemy camp in the rear. The almost-triumphant Turks break off the attack to retrieve their valuables and re-take their camp, and valuable breathing space is gained.
Tales of individual heroism crowd the bigger picture. The commanders fought alongside their men. At Lepanto Ali Pasha, the Ottoman chief, shot dozens of arrows at his enemies as his flagship was captured. Don Juan danced a galliard on the gun platform as they sailed towards the enemy. A man hit in the eye by an arrow plucked it out, eyeball and all, tied a cloth around his head and continued fighting.
The battle was a turning point in history - never again did the Ottomans pose such a threat to the West. Up to this, even Rome was at risk from their ambitions.
Having just finished this book, I am inclined to go back to the beginning and start all over again. I certainly hope to do so before I visit some of the places where great and terrible deeds were accomplished. If you enjoy your history embellished with colour and enlivened with anecdote, this is the book for you.
One quibble, though: it's surprising that Faber, the publishers of poetry, were not more assiduous in their editing. Scrabbling is one word that is grossly over-used by the author, and discrete does not have the same meaning as discreet.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5 of 6 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Empires of the Sea, 11 Jan. 2009
By 
Mr. A. Walker-powell "Tony Powell" (Sydney NSW Australia) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
This is a splendid book for the general reader. In about 300 pages Crowley describes the Christian/Muslim 16th Century conflict in the Mediterranean. The end of that century also marks the end of the supremacy of the Mediterranean in the West, which until then had been the centre of Western Civilization. Crowley creates a picture in words as the reader is transported, Google-Earthlike, from Philip II sitting like a spider in the centre of a web directing the business of the Spanish Empire to Suleiman flamboyantly extending the Ottoman Empire. The description of the Battle of Lepanto in 1571 is so vivid that I felt I was an observer standing on the poop of Don John's flagship. It seems to have had a similar effect on Roger Crowley because he wrote that Lepanto was the biggest battle in the West until Loos in 1916 (sic). Loos was fought in 1915 and I believe the battle of Tannenburg between Russia and Germany in 1914 was considerably bigger. More relevant is the fact that in terms of men and ships Lepanto was not surpassed until the Battle of the Coral Sea in World War 2.
Today's technology enables the reader to use Google Earth to see the battle sights. Forts St Elmo and St Angelo in Malta can be viewed looking as I imagine they were 500 years ago. The reader can see the entrance to the Gulf of Corinth the same as when Don John of Austria saw it before Lepanto.
The only material concern that Crowley did not discuss was the question of hygiene in the Siege of Malta. Until the Boer War, army losses due to sickness and wounds were greater than those killed in action. The Knights of St John as part of their hospitaller remit cared for the sick. I understand that they minimized sickness in their galleys by transferring the slaves to cells in Fort St Angelo when the boats returned from operational duty and temporarily lowering the boats to the bottom of the harbour so that they could be freed of the slaves' excrement and other accumulated filth. I understand that sickness among the besieging Ottoman forces was a major concern. I would be surprised if sickness was a similar problem in the Knight's forces.
Although the events happened up to 500 years ago the conflict is topical: players and locations are different, but the struggle between the West and militant Islam goes on. One could substitute George Bush and the United States for Charles V and Spain, for example. Although there are examples of chivalrous behaviour between opposing commanders of the like of Don John of Austria and the Ottoman fleet's commander, Ali Pasha, the behaviour of Lala Mustapha, the Ottoman commander before Famagusta was of unspeakable brutality. His action of having the surrendering Venetian commander Marcantonio Bragadin, skinned alive whilst under the protection of a truce is so horrific that it continues to poison relations between Turkey and the West, to this day..
Empires of the Sea is well worth having. What splendid movies that include the Siege of Malta or the Battle of Lepanto could be made!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Amazing historical book about post medieval naval warfare and a world changing battle., 27 Feb. 2015
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
Muslims conquered the Christian and Jewish Holy land in 637 AD, and invaded Christian North Africa in 647 AD. By 788 AD they had largely conquered Christian Spain. In the meantime they invaded Christian Gaul (or modern France). In 732 AD they were comprehensively smashed between Poitiers and Tours by the Franks and stopped in their tracks under the Carolingians, progenitors of Charlemagne.
Following the Christian Crusades to secure the Holy Land for Christian pilgrims, the west was blamed by Muslims for starting the wars between the Christians and Muslims.
The first Christian Crusade in 1096 to allow Christians access to the Holy Places resulted in the Conquest of Jerusalem in 1099. Subsequently the Muslims retook Jerusalem.
Rhichard the Lionheart famously took part in the third Crusade (1189 - 1192) and reconquered Acre and Jaffa, but he never saw Jerusalem.
The Plantagenet warrior Edward I was the last Crusading English King, he took part in the 9th and last Crusade. as Prince Edward in 1271 to 1272. He returned to England after some success and the personal slaying of a Muslim who attempted his assassination, when his father Henry III died leaving England without an on-site king.
In 1453 the Ottomans captured Constantinople the capital of the Byzantine (Greek) Empire, aka the Eastern Roman Empire, Christian Bastion in the East.
The Muslim Moors were eventually excluded from Granada in Spain in 1492, the year Columbus discovered the Americas.
In 1529 the Turks under Suleiman the Magnificent laid seige to Vienna but failed to conquer this great European city.
This is an abbreviated backdrop to this book.
Most people are aware that the battle of Lepanto in the Eastern Mediterranean was one of the defining naval battles in world history analogous with Salamis, Actium, Trafalgar, and Midway and many other claimants such as Jutland. This book explores the naval battles and War between the Christian Kings of Spain (and Holy Roman Emperor) Charles, then Philip II of Armada fame, the Pope Pius V of the Vatican, and the Catholic Republic of Venice against the might of Ottoman Turkey under Suleiman the Magnificent and his son the Pasha Selim.
Rhodes, the stronghold of the Knights of St John (the Hospitallers of the Crusades), was overwhelmed first, but the Knights relocated far to the West in Malta. Malta became a target, but by the determination of the French Knight La Valette, after whom Valetta was subsequently named, and horrific conflict, the island was retained for about 200 years until temporarily invaded by Napoleon.
The book describes in great detail how the diminutive Christian fleet defeated much of the Turkish Navy near Lepanto not far from Athens. The battle did not lead to the recovery for Christendom of Constantinople (Istanbul), and certainly not the reconquest of the Holy Land. Both had to wait till 1918 but were very quickly for political reasons returned to Muslim and / or Jewish control.
It is a gripping account of post medieval warfare and the political background, researched and documented with meticulous scholastic authority, but very readable for the rest of us.
Thereafter the Turks consolidated their existing conquests but no longer pushed westward into Europe.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars An excellent example of history writing at it's best, 16 Nov. 2014
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
The period covered by this book is an enthralling one, and, in many ways, the story is the final end of the crusades. Although the crusades that everyone thinks they know about were long over, their effects were still reverberating around the Mediterranean. The European Christians had long since left the Levant, but their residue were still very much alive, such as the Knights of Malta, and the Ottoman Empire was still growing at the expense of much of South East Europe. Whilst some in Europe still had fanciful ideas of new crusades, the Ottomans were slowly expanding, and politically, each new Sultan needed to produce victories to consolidate his position. This led to decades of conflict.
This book tells the story admirably. It is a difficult story to tell; there are so many strands to bring together that it could easily be either too detailed or too vague. The author, for me, gets it just right, and tells the story in a clear, but authoritative way.
In many ways, it is hard to see how the Ottomans failed. They were a ( reasonably) united single entity, whereas Europe was a mess of conflicting countries and states with little or no common ground or purpose. The road to the eventual outcome is told clearly and sometimes reads almost like a good novel. Although there were victories and defeats on both sides, from the perspective of the time, there was no clear winner. Only with hindsight can we see that eventually, the Ottomans turned inward, and Europe turned largely westward to the New World. This rift, which led to each side lacking understanding of the other, is still affecting us today.
Anyone who has an interest in history will find this book very worthwhile reading.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Breathtaking, 24 July 2013
There is little more that I can say about this book that has not already been said. What I do know is that I have just started reading it for the third time. Yes it is that good. The author grabs your interest on page one and holds you captive until the final sentence. This is a story of Great Empires conflicting with one another, wishing to expand and swallow up the lands and peoples they do not possess. It is a story of fascinating characters who you will love, hate, fear and certainly be in awe of,be they Kings, Sultans, high ranking Knights, Janissaries or poorly low ranking cannon fodder or desperate civilians. The entire book could have been composed from the brilliant mind of an accomplished author of historical fiction but this is historical fact and those who populate its pages were real people. The descriptions of and the readers realization of what a galley slave had to endure will give many readers the shivers. The coastal populations of both Christian and Moslem lands bordering the Mediterranean lived in fear of being enslaved by roving bands of pirates and corsairs. Tens of thousands, including women and children were snatched and taken from their lands to spend the rest of their lives chained to a galley bench or sold into slavery both in Christian and Moslem lands. The descriptions of the land and sea battles between these two Empires are fascinating and again will astound. All in all this is nothing short of a masterpiece and deserves the awards it has gained.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


‹ Previous | 1 210 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Empires of the Sea: The Final Battle for the Mediterranean, 1521-1580
£12.08
In stock
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews