Most helpful critical review
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful
Too many errors, too much duplication, too little substance
on 17 March 2011
Without any doubt, the worst developers guide I have come across.
Lovely print quality, with heavy and glossy paper, so first impressions are excellent. However...
From the beginning I found erroneous examples, where text seems to have been copy and pasted wrongly. Parts of the explanations were therefore discussing the wrong code samples. Then some of screen shots were obviously incorrect. And all the while, the code examples are repetitive in the extreme. These, illustrated step by step, repeat all of the code in each step, so that a 9 line code segment may end up with an additional 30 repeated lines. This becomes tedious by the end of the first code sample, but is repeated all the way through the book. I did not bother counting the number of pages given over to the Latin text content for the HTML being manipulated. But one example had a whole page of Latin elements!
At a guess, this 320 page book could be reduced to less than 100, and in so doing it may even be improved. I could not, in good conscience, recommend this book to anyone.
Would Amazon accept this one back for the reasons stated above? I doubt it.