Customer Reviews


3 Reviews
5 star:    (0)
4 star:
 (1)
3 star:
 (2)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


25 of 29 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The war's almost over! And so, hopefully, is this series
And the war slogs on. Harry Turtledove's Settling Accounts: The Grapple continues his alternate history of the second world war, in a world where the Confederate States still exist and they are run by a Hitler-like madman who is intent on wiping out the black population. In my review of Drive to the East, I mentioned that I was getting a bit sick of the wrestling...
Published on 30 July 2006 by David Roy

versus
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars More of the same for fans of the series
In the latest volume of his ongoing alternative history series, Harry Turtledove moves beyond the battle of Pittsburgh, the turning point in the war between the U.S. and the Confederate States with which he concluded the previous installment. The Confederacy, which had enjoyed dramatic success at the start of the war, now finds itself on the defensive as the U.S. drives...
Published on 1 Oct 2006 by MarkK


Most Helpful First | Newest First

7 of 8 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars More of the same for fans of the series, 1 Oct 2006
By 
MarkK (Phoenix, AZ, USA) - See all my reviews
(TOP 1000 REVIEWER)   
This review is from: The Grapple (Settling Accounts Trilogy) (Hardcover)
In the latest volume of his ongoing alternative history series, Harry Turtledove moves beyond the battle of Pittsburgh, the turning point in the war between the U.S. and the Confederate States with which he concluded the previous installment. The Confederacy, which had enjoyed dramatic success at the start of the war, now finds itself on the defensive as the U.S. drives them back. Increasingly the Confederate president, Jake Featherston, grasps onto the slim hope of secret weapons to turn the tide against the superior numbers and resources of the United States, which is bearing down upon the South in a campaign with echoes of the American Civil War.

Fans of the series will find much to satisfy them here. Once more he chronicles events the course of the war through the experiences of over a dozen characters scattered on both sides, though by this point the diversity of experience is much reduced as nearly everybody he chronicles is at the front; home front interludes are virtually nonexistent. The tactics of present-day wars are even more apparent in this installment they were before, as combatants use suicide bombers, car bombs, and even truck-mounted machine guns in ways more familiar to soldiers of today than those of sixty years ago.

Yet while readers will find many of the same strengths that engaged them in the previous volumes, the weaknesses are there as well While the plot moves forward nicely, the individual episodes themselves have a rote and repetitive feel to them. Characters find themselves repeating the same actions from scene to scene, and even their dialogue is largely the same as before. The increasing confinement of the narrative to the battlefield only enhances this, as characters do the same things over and over because they find themselves stuck in the same situations - something that Turtledove successfully avoided in his far more diverse coverage of the alternative First World War in the earlier volumes.

In short, readers of the earlier volumes will find much the is familiar here, as events move down well-work paths towards an inevitable conclusion. About the greatest surprise contained within these pages is that Turtledove doesn't wrap up the war, but instead plans at least one more installment of his 'Settling Accounts' series, entitled 'In At the Death'. Fans will probably be rewarded with more of the same as before, as the whole series finds a groove that is both comfortable and predictable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


25 of 29 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The war's almost over! And so, hopefully, is this series, 30 July 2006
By 
David Roy (Vancouver, BC) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The Grapple (Settling Accounts Trilogy) (Hardcover)
And the war slogs on. Harry Turtledove's Settling Accounts: The Grapple continues his alternate history of the second world war, in a world where the Confederate States still exist and they are run by a Hitler-like madman who is intent on wiping out the black population. In my review of Drive to the East, I mentioned that I was getting a bit sick of the wrestling metaphors (how the Confederates needed a knockout punch, but since it wasn't delivered, they were in the wrestling match of their lives). So what does Turtledove do? He continues using the metaphor and puts it in the title! Despite some big problems with this book, I do have to say it's probably the best book in the series so far. Yes, many of Turtledove's normal faults are there, but he's eliminated some others and actually strengthened some other areas. It's not a wonderful book on its own, but compared to the rest, it's definitely up there.

The Confederate army is retreating in disarray from Stalingrad...I mean, Pittsburgh. The United States destroyed a whole army in that inferno, and has now taken the momentum away. General Irving Morrell, the flashy "barrel" (tank) commander, wants to continue driving a wedge through the entire Confederacy, and it's becoming apparent that he can do it. The Confederates are on their heels, retreating so they don't get cut off, and losing ground in huge chunks. Could the war be over soon? Meanwhile, the "final solution" for the black people in the Confederacy continues, though US troops are coming close to the biggest extermination camp, Camp Determination, which may add impetus to the attempt by some people in the North (notably, Senator Flora Blackford) to get the word out about what is going on. Jake Featherston, dictator, madman, and president of the Confederacy, can't allow that to happen. But the more troops he sends to defend the camp, the less he has to defend the rest of the country. Things are looking incredibly bleak for the Confederacy. But the race to build a "uranium bomb" may hold the key to the end of the war.

Let me get my normal complaint about Turtledove out of the way so I can go on to the rest of the book. Yes, the repetition in this book is monotonous. He insists on introducing characters again and again, having them say the same things (I don't know how many times we are told that the Confederates were supposed to win a one-punch victory, or that Featherston should have listened the first time to the scientist who brought the idea of the uranium bomb). The good thing is, he's found new things to repeat, and stopped repeating a few others! There's barely a mention of zinc-oxide cream for Sam Carstens' light complexion, for example. In the last book, he compensated for not repeating this by repeating almost everything else. This time, it's not quite that bad. There is some justification for introducing your characters multiple times (I don't agree with it, but it does exist), but there is none for repeating the same actions, phrases, or figures of speech over and over again.

Which brings us to another problem with the book. A lot of the individual character sequences start to sound the same after a while. This is most notable in the scenes with Dr. O'Doull. He's a combat surgeon, and every time we see him (except one sequence where he's back home on leave), he's patching people up, commenting on patching people up, and making jokes or philosophical observations with his combat medic. None of these scenes advance the plot or the themes much. We get the fact that war is terrible, that a doctor's work is never done in a war zone. To a lesser extent, this is the case for most of the scenes in the book. Yes, he often gives the characters (except O'Doull) something new to do, but the scenes still have a basic sameness to them. It's like we're treading ground while waiting for the war to end. And it almost does, though not until the next book.

That being said, perhaps my statement that this is the best book in the series isn't saying much. It does, however, have some strengths. As always in this series, I love the plotting, wondering what Turtledove's going to do with the war. His inclusion of car and "people" bombs brings a bit of contemporary feeling to the book, and the fear they bring is palpable. I loved the scenes with the two black groups of rebels rampaging through Georgia. He's introduced a couple of new characters to make up for a couple of deaths, though he then kills a couple more main characters off. I love the fact that you have no idea who's going to live or die in this series, and all of the deaths seem unforced by the narrative. They also bring a bit of humanity to one of the characters, overwhelmed enough by what he's doing that he finally makes the final decision. I was sad to see this character go, but given what Turtledove was having him do, it seemed like the right choice.

One thing I would have liked to see more of was the Canadian rebellion. With the death of Mary in the last book, we lose our Canadian viewpoint character, and Turtledove never replaces her. Thus, we hear a few comments about the ongoing rebellion, a sequence mentioning the British trying to resupply them, but nothing more. Of course, the book is bloated enough as it is, so maybe it's a good thing he didn't add more.

The Grapple is a worthy addition to the Settling Accounts series, though you do have to work at it. If you can get through the prose and the dialogue, Turtledove has some interesting ideas. Consider this a qualified 4 stars.

David Roy
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4 of 6 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Not bad worth reading if you've got this far, 17 Oct 2006
By 
This review is from: The Grapple (Settling Accounts Trilogy) (Hardcover)
I quite liked this book. The story trots along at a fair old pace. If I had to be critcial he does rather slavishly follow real events of WWII a bit too far. I mean the battle in Pittsburgh is just Stalingrad (even down to little details eg for Roumanians read Mexicans) and you find yourself knowing what is going to happen next. My other irritation is that the book is so Americo-centric. Not just in terms of plot, that's fair enough, but all foreign characters are a bit stupid and whipping boys for Americans. It always annoys me how the British are portrayed in his books as the worst of American stereotypes. Overall, worth a read but it ain't Tolstoy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

The Grapple (Settling Accounts Trilogy)
The Grapple (Settling Accounts Trilogy) by Harry Turtledove (Hardcover - 1 July 2006)
Used & New from: £0.01
Add to wishlist See buying options
Only search this product's reviews