35 of 38 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Not enough stars to do this justice
To try and do justice to these wonderfully original works in a few lines is an impossibility. The three books together make up what turns out to be a magnificent odyssey. It is a strange but ultimately rewarding journey you make with these characters. You get to know the characters well and enjoy their dry laconic wit. But the most striking feature is the main characters...
Published on 2 Dec 2008 by Bob Salter
3 of 5 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Do you speak Spanish?
I see Roger Waters' book to take to the desert island was the first of this trilogy, which I too thought very good. The whole thing with the wolf was fascinating and ultimately very moving. After that though, I lost interest, gradually. And what was all that Spanish about, with no translations? just irritating.
Published on 21 July 2011 by Andy G
Most Helpful First | Newest First
35 of 38 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Not enough stars to do this justice,
This review is from: The Border Trilogy: All the Pretty Horses / The Crossing / Cities of the Plain (Paperback)To try and do justice to these wonderfully original works in a few lines is an impossibility. The three books together make up what turns out to be a magnificent odyssey. It is a strange but ultimately rewarding journey you make with these characters. You get to know the characters well and enjoy their dry laconic wit. But the most striking feature is the main characters are so likeable. They are the best of American manhood. They stand up for all that is good in the star spangled banner. In fact they simply stand up for all that is good. If I could ride, which I can't worth a damn, then these are the young cowboys I would be happy to ride with if they'd have me.
In "All the pretty horses" we meet young John Grady Cole who with his companero set off South of the border on a whim. They meet a character called Blevins who seems like trouble and sure enough turns out to be trouble with a capital T. A mexican ranch and a pretty senorita are involved but the spectre of young Blevins comes back to haunt the good old boys. They end up suffering under Mexican justice. The rest I will not spoil other than to say it is a rollicking good read.
In "The Crossing" we meet the equally likeable Billy Parham and his younger brother. This is my personal favourite of the three books. The material is unpromising but McCarthy weaves magic with it. The boy Parham captures a wolf and decides to return it across the border to old Mexico where he stays for a bit longer than intended. On his eventual return he finds his parents have been murdered. He pauses briefly to pick up his brother and they head back over the border to hunt for the murderers. The book takes up an epic feeling as the journey takes on a never ending quest. Parham becomes a strange Quixotic figure in an alien landscape. Although he speaks perfect Spanish he and his brother seem like " Strangers in a strange land". The finale is a heart rending affair.
In the final book "Cities of the plain" Billy Parham and John Grady Cole are brought together in a magnificent story of tragic doomed love and friendships that run deep. Again much of the story takes place South of the border. It is a fitting finale to the trilogy.
All three books are breathtaking in their scope and ambition. One reviewer I read compares McCarthy with Hemingway. I will commit heresy here by saying that McCarthy is far better. His examinations of friendship, family ties and a love that crosses boundaries of state and the human heart simply amaze. All the characters are heart rendingly real. They are all too human. McCarthy will one day be recognised in the pantheon of the Worlds great writers. I love these three books as I grew to love the characters in them. That is the effect they have on you. This is a remarkable trilogy.
Be warned that Spanish is used liberally in all the books. My only knowledege of the language is through watching too many Westerns, so it would not get me far in old Mexico. Personally I found this only enhanced the feel of the book. I would also add that some knowledge of the American West is an aid, although not essential. The ghosts of the past loom quite large in his books. This is 'manna from heaven' for an old western buff like me, but more than this it is writing that far transcends its own genre. This is a series, that like Pat Barker's "Regeneration" trilogy, will undoubtedly in the not too distant future be heralded as literary classics.
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Three memorable books,
This review is from: The Border Trilogy: All the Pretty Horses / The Crossing / Cities of the Plain (Paperback)I found it quite difficult to resolve these three books in my mind. They don't neatly fit into any pre-existing pigeon holes and as such they have to be assessed alone without reference to other similar books in similar genres. The chief characters are engaged by so many random events and meetings, some of which are relevant to the overall story, some of which are not. This can be a little confusing until you get used to it - just like real life in fact. Likewise McCarthy's style of writing is unlike anything I've come across. To some extent he makes up his own rules about grammar,syntax and punctuation but the end result is well worth it. If there is a message from McCarthy's books it is that life for people at the bottom of the pile is unrelentingly hard and is there to be endured to its conclusion which will be sad and inglorious.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Border Trilogy,
This review is from: The Border Trilogy: All the Pretty Horses / The Crossing / Cities of the Plain (Paperback)To get the most from this book you really need a knowledge of Spanish because whole sections of dialogue are left untranslated. The description of the border lands is rich and atmospheric but as a UK reader I was a little lost on the geography. The middle book of the trilogy (The Crossing) I found to be a little rambling but the first and third books were much more succinct with a doomed romance as a common theme.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Epic heroic fable, real and surreal to great effect,
But the struggle to survive the adversities of life, whether the hostility of nature in the wild, or the dysfunctionality of human society, are all too real. The duplicities and horrors of the Mexican revolution, the cynical abuse of women by pimps, the stealing and killing by roaming criminal gangs, are powerfully portrayed as the challenge for the heroic life. The survival of a supportive network of generous household hospitality and virtue to sustain the hero in action is a hope we might all share.
The delicate intricacy of McCarthy's text richly colours the detail of every event, absorbing the reader intimately into the narrative. The length of the book and the inclusion of Spanish in the dialogue, which have been criticised and sent up by some reviewers, most amusingly by J Taylor in a comment on his own review, in fact are effective devices to create and convey atmosphere. The reality is long and arduous, and southern US states are bilingual.
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars strangely compelling trilogy of the west, but not a western!,
By A Customer
This review is from: The Border Trilogy (Audio Cassette)The border in question is the Mexico/USA border in the first half of this century, but don't let any impression that these books are westerns put you off! There are indeed horse thefts, ranchers and gunfights, as you might expect, but the atmosphere is far from Shane, or indeed Blazing Saddles. I've already reviewed the first book under its own name. The second book, The Crossing, concerns 16 year old Billy Parham, who leaves home and crosses into Mexico with a wolf he has captured alive, intending to release it into the wild, only to return to find his parents murdered. He and his brother spend the rest of the book attempting to regain possession of their father's stolen horses, and meet with both friendship and brutality on the way. The third book brings Billy Parham together with the main character of the first book, John Grady Cole. All three are written in a spare prose style entirely devoid of emotion or overblown description. McCarthy does not attempt to enter his characters heads or make us empathise with them, yet by the end you do. The style is just right for the material, and for the reader. Brad Pitt reads well, in a soft smokey emotionless drawl just right for the characters.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Life changing novels,
4.0 out of 5 stars TWO ODDYSEYS AND TEN YEARS ON.,
The trilogy is a saga of courage, despair and triumph against adversity, interrupted by several excessively lengthy yarns by various strangers they meet, which the author uses as a vehicle for expounding various philosophies on life, but which are irrelevant to the story and don’t appear to progress it in any way. Dialogue is laconic, none too articulate, often humorous (and punctuated with much spitting and tooth-picking), while the narrative is often long-winded to the point of being boring. His descriptions are graphic and often poetic, the story strangely compelling, but some long tracts make heavy reading.
McCarthy’s writing style is varied, ranging from acute brevity to excessive detail, in which he will never settle for two words if he can manage to squeeze in twenty. I was intensely irritated by his discourtesy to the reader by omitting apostrophes, hyphens and quotation marks (although one does get used to it), and am nonplussed by his consistent use of lower case initials for ‘ italian’,’jew’, ‘english’ and ‘french’, while honouring Spanish, American and Mexican with capital letters. Most irksome is the fact that a lot of the dialogue is in Spanish, for which only occasionally does he employ any of the usual devices for assisting understanding. Much of this I could fathom from a passing knowledge of other European languages, but the precise meanings of some long conversations were obscure, and required constant recourse to a Spanish dictionary, which was time-consuming and frustrating.
Nevertheless, the saga is very moving, and leaves a strong impression.
5.0 out of 5 stars Why I enjoyed the Border Trilogy,
I think Mc Carthy descriptive powers, his ability to weave a complex story; to create credible characters with whom the reader may empathise or dislike in their happiness, fear or loneliness; to build mood and tension and to create scences of violence, or calm and serenity , whether it is pastoral or landscape, the sky at night, the vastness of the plains or of an interior, are truly compelling.
I have also some of his other works, including Blood Meridian, No Country for Old Men, The Orchard Keeper, Suttree, The Road.
What I find so interesting about his writing is how Mc Carthy can write in different styles from very terse brief sentences as in No country and the Road , to almost lush descriptive styles as in some of the Trilogy.
I consider Cormac Mc Carthy is one of the finest modern novelists writing today.
5.0 out of 5 stars A work of genius, it creeps into your heart and soul.,
It is hard to imagine the deprivation and hardship of times so recent, and the dependence on, and relationships with the animals is captivating.
5.0 out of 5 stars The Border Trilogy by Cormac McCarthy. Stunning!,
Most Helpful First | Newest First
The Border Trilogy: All the Pretty Horses / The Crossing / Cities of the Plain by Cormac McCarthy (Paperback - 3 Aug 2007)