Most helpful critical review
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
Interesting book about design language and usability
on 12 January 2010
Mixture of popular account and technical detail sit oddly together. Some powerful insights about why some products/designs don't work, but not enough detailed analyst to be really useful to a designer, and yet too much to be compelling to a casual reader or to constitute a statement of a philosophy.
Also curiously dated, though in a way more interesting for that - a relic from the pre-broadband, pre-smartphone world. It's interesting how some of the 'hard constraints' that he perceives have just melted away with more processing power and bandwidth - he fantasises over the thought of a PDA not nearly as powerful as the smartphone in my pocket at the moment, and complains that online information services are constrained by bandwidth and cost limitations - Google search is simply beyond his imagining, in 1988. Wonder what similar blunders we are making now...