Top critical review
Tolkin! Another one for the Bin
on 5 November 2015
Utter crap! Tolkin must be turning in his grave! Reads like a list of historical events that are pointless, ometimes unrelated and hard to follow. Not worth the time to read. Not a bit like the amazing story lines in Hobit and Lord of the Rings. Its hard to believe that the same person wrote this pap. I was Very, Very, Disappointed with this and the other 2 books I bought This book makes the Slimarillion look like a masterpiece and I thought that was terrible! Also I just can not understand while some other reviews said this was a good book, They must be a strange kind of people!