31 of 32 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Humanising the myth
Oxford historian Robin Lane Fox has written a superb biography of one of history's most mythologised characters.
Fox never patronises his audience with his writing style but neither does he make any assumptions that the reader is pre-armed with a firm grasp of classical history. He clearly explains where he gets his sources from, who he trusts, if there are...
Published on 6 Sep 2006 by Mr. Tristan Martin
4 of 8 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Good, but too self-indulgent to be truly great
This is an improvement on the same author's Pagans and Christians: In the Mediterranean World from the Second Century AD to the Conversion of Constantine. Although it adopts the same approach of throwing at the subject everything that the author knows, in this case the finished result remains accessible as it focuses (naturally enough) on the life and experiences of a...
Published on 19 Sep 2011 by Jeremy
Most Helpful First | Newest First
31 of 32 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Humanising the myth,
This review is from: Alexander the Great (Paperback)Oxford historian Robin Lane Fox has written a superb biography of one of history's most mythologised characters.
Fox never patronises his audience with his writing style but neither does he make any assumptions that the reader is pre-armed with a firm grasp of classical history. He clearly explains where he gets his sources from, who he trusts, if there are conflicting accounts and where his judgements lie.
The book relates an epic story and Fox tells it in great detail; normally, the more detail a book provides, the better but in this particular case, the book loses one star in its rating because Fox's sentences can run to great lengths and become rather muddy (I'd give it four and a half if I could). Don't let that put you off buying this book, though, as it animates quite successfully Alexander's life and times, the politics and the geography. This book is especially recommended to those of you who have Oliver Stone's film, Alexander Revisited, to which Robin Lane Fox was an advisor.
94 of 101 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A masterful stody of one of history's greatest generals,
By A Customer
55 of 59 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Alexander The Great - Highly Recommended,
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Hard Campaigning For The Casual Reader,
Amazon Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Alexander the Great (Paperback)Couple of warnings about this book: Written in 1973, albeit with some revisions since, this is still a book where the majority of the text is heading towards being 40 years old. That in itself is not an issue (although some of the sections on homosexuality show a lot more of 70s sentiments than current thinking) as the book is detailed and well written.
And that is the other warning: It is VERY detailed. Don't expect a standardised history of Alexander, this is probably very close to the definitive detailed work and at times it can be hard going, but the expanse of detail makes it worthwhile.
If you are starting out looking for a history of the man, I'd probably point you away from this, but if you have chewed your way through a good many histories and want something more, then this is definately for you.
Well researched hardly describes it, but I do think casual readers will fall out within the first few chapters. Also as someone just about to graduate into their first pair of reading glasses along with their 'everday' specs, it is tightly printed so make sure you have some good specs handy!
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Essentail reading for "Advanced" Alexanders,
This review is from: Alexander the Great (Paperback)This is "the" book for those wishing to get to grips with every detail. But I have to echo the drawbacks from previous reviewers: detailed, complex English in places, and very poor maps by today's standars: even the new 2004 edition is a essentailly a reprint from the 1970's.
Beginners would be far better off with Michael Wood's "In the Footsteps of Alexander the Great"; then read the original ancient sources; then this.
39 of 45 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Not for the beginner,
But be warned.....there are some not so good things.
First, the language in which the book is written is unduly complex - lots of double negatives, very involved sentences, etc. I simply don't think this is good writing: admittedly the events being discussed are complex, but surely even the most complex concept or event can be expressed using simple, accessible, language?
Second, the maps really aren't particulary useful. They are small, dark, and difficult to read. So the geography is rather baffling - unless of course you already have considerable knowledge of the ancient world, or an atlas of it to hand.
Third, for the beginner it's easy to get bogged down in the level of detail. There's little sense of a wood, or even of the outlines of one, just of thousands of trees.
Fourth - so MUCH military history! Endless pages about chariots and spears. I did find these a little dull, though I'm sure that's an unfair criticism - tastes differ. And of course you could argue that an account of the world's greatest military leader would necessitate a certain amount of military history.
Overall, I found this book difficult to finish - although having done so, I know a lot more about Alexander and his world than I did before. And I'm tempted to re-read it. I imagine that it's a very rewarding book for someone who already has an overview of the subject - but perhaps it's not the best introduction to it.
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A Biography of One of the 'Great' Men of History,
This review is from: Alexander the Great (Paperback)This is a big book in volume as well as content being over 500 pages long but Oxford historian Robin Lane Fox has contrived to make it interesting for the reader from beginning to end. Many facts have been written about Alexander over the years, some true, some doubtful and much that is pure speculation. This in turn has given Alexander a mythical quality, bordering on god like proportions.
The author's writing style is both concise and lucid with no pretensions to the fact that he is the master and the reader by his very nature is the pupil. In a nutshell the author writes for everyone not just the scholar. This book is for anyone with an interest in the life and times of Alexander. The author progresses through the life of Alexander putting a little more meat on the bones with every passing phase of Alexander's relatively short life.
This is a book for everyone. For those who have found it difficult, or even impossible in the past to read and I mean read a history book from start to finish, rather than just go cherry picking facts from the numerous pages, then this is a good book to get your teeth into. It can be read almost like a novel, but is far more interesting than any fictional book.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Hard Work Brings Rewards,
This review is from: Alexander the Great (Paperback)This is not an easy read as other reviewers have noted. It's "old school" history writing and may prove too much for those more accustomed to the more informal style of narrative history books which have appeared in recent years. It's also let down by some of the poorest typesetting I have ever seen in a book and the quality of its maps, at least one of which is almost illegible in parts.
Those qualms aside, it does reward the persistent reader with a thorough and detailed account of a fascinating character and period in time.
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars addictive,
This review is from: Alexander the Great (Paperback)I have tried to read a few biographies of Alexander the Great. Unfortunately I was never able to get very far. Having read this book I now understand why that was... Alexander became so mythological in proportion, and the swirling, contrasting evidence makes serious understanding almost impossible. Or so it should be without the absolutely splendid scholarship of Robin Lane Fox.
He doesn't baulk at the challenges for a second. Instead he is quite open in saying "look, we just can't be sure of this!" and then goes on to expound his own point of view, firmly based on evidence, so that the ultimate picture is balanced, challenging and utterly thrilling!
Without doubt Alexander changed the face of the world. This book dares to question who the 'man behind the myth' actually was, and I fell in love with him over and over as I recognized what Robin Lane Fox repeatedly makes clear; his humanity. Highly recommended, if a bit difficult to get through at first.
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Highly recommended - an excellent book...,
This review is from: Alexander the Great (Paperback)Alexander has always been a fascinating figure to me. Modern society likes to compare him to Hitler and focus on the number of deaths involved in his conquest of the Persian Empire, but you just can't retrospectively judge figures from history with modern morals and ethics. Whatever else he was, Alexander was probably the greatest conqueror, general and explorer in history - to do all he did by the age of 32 is astonishing. Robin Lane Fox really brings the world of Alexander to life, but he never veers off into imagination or speculation - he constantly reminds readers of how little there is left, how much is still unknown. He writes clearly and lucidly and never assumes too much knowledge but doesn't patronise either. I would have preferred less emphasis on the battles and more on the day-to-day life, but that's a small criticism.
Most Helpful First | Newest First
Alexander the Great by Robin Lane Fox (Paperback - 4 Nov 2004)