163 of 169 people found the following review helpful
on 21 April 2004
This account of the author's experiences as a Japanese prisoner of war is, as you'd expect, a fairly harrowing one. But what lifts this remarkable tale is the book's humanity and compassion, and the tenderness of its narrative.
Whether Eric Lomax is re-living his childhood fascination with steam locomotives and trams, or describing the horrendous, inhuman acts of torture, the prose are consistently imbued with an almost poetic and innocent sense of wonder.
The details, observations and character sketches are authentically andvividly drawn. But it is the final passages of this book which document the author's determination to come face to face with one of his torturers, that make this extaordinary book so moving, compelling and ultimately uplifting.
Alex Pearl, author of 'Sleeping with the Blackbirds'
94 of 99 people found the following review helpful
on 1 June 2005
Eric Lomax, like many young men of his generation, had a love for steam railways that bordered on an obsession. It was ironic then that he ended up as a prisoner of war on the notorious Burma Railroad, enduring torture and experiencing dreadful war crimes perpetrated against Allied prisoners.
This poignant book plays with the reader's emotions, first stoking up outrage at the appalling treatment meted out to this gentle man by his Japanese captors, then unexpectedly flipping its perpective to deliver a brilliant and unexpected climax.
The result is a literary gem, but it is Lomax's honesty rather than his cleverness as a writer that ensures that this book succeeds. I recommend it strongly.
69 of 74 people found the following review helpful
on 14 December 2001
I can't recommend this book too highly. Probably the best book I've ever read about the Second World War and mans inhumanity to man. Yet it still leaves you with a belief in mans essential goodness. Buy it.
87 of 95 people found the following review helpful
In February 1942, the city of Singapore, defended by 80,000 British and Commonwealth troops, surrenders to the Japanese. The loss of Singapore, coupled with the preceding loss of the British warships Repulse and Prince of Wales, is described by Churchill as the darkest British moments of the Second World War, whilst the capitulation of Singapore becomes the British Army's greatest defeat.
Amongst the tens of thousands of British soldiers rounded up and taken into captivity is Lt. Eric Lomax, a Royal Signals officer. Initially, the vast mass of British POWs hugely outnumbers their Japanese captors, leading to a relaxed atmosphere where the British prisoners mostly police themselves. Overconfident, many of the British prisoners began building home-made radios to keep a closer eye on the course of the war. However, as time passes the POWs begin to be dispersed, many being sent to be worked to death on the River Kwae railway as it slowly makes its way across Thailand and into Burma. In these smaller camps, much more aggressively policed by Japanese guards, the prisoners find their confidence and expectation of good treatment rapidly disabused. Lomax's involvement in the construction of clandestine radios leads him to being imprisoned, humiliated, tortured and condemned to a number of horrific prisons in and around Bangkok.
Eventually the war ends and Lomax returns home, but finds that his torture continues. His experiences lead to the breakdown of his first marriage, an estrangement from his father and decades of nightmares and broken sleep patterns. Only in the early 1990s does Lomax finally receive the counselling and psychiatric help he has needed, a process which eventually leads him back to Thailand and a meeting with one of his Japanese tormentors, an interpreter who rejected his nation's barbarous methods of torture and militarism and has spent the decades since working to ensure that the Japanese do not forget what they did in the war. In this meeting Lomax eventually finds a kind of peace, fifty years after the war ends.
The Railway Man is a memoir of one man's experiences in the Second World War. It opens with a summary of Lomax's childhood and background, his experiences as a railway and engineering enthusiast, his decision to enlist before WWII even starts and his eventual involvement in the debacle of Singapore's fall (the city's monstrous defences were oriented seaward, allowing the Japanese to simply walk in from the rear and take it almost completely unopposed). This is followed by the largest part of the book, as Lomax recalls his experiences in various POW camps and later prisons, in which he recounts his treatment at the hands of the Japanese. These sections are definitely not for those with weak stomachs. The cruelty of the Japanese to those who surrendered to them is well-documented, but even so the sheer, inhuman horror they inflicted on Lomax is shocking. However, even more startling is the lack of counselling or treatment Lomax received upon his eventual release, and the mild mistreatment inflicted on the former POWs by their liberators (such as former POWs, in many cases malnourished and weakened by four years of captivity, being expected to do the work of fully-healthy, fresh recruits on the return voyage to Britain).
The book ends with Lomax's experiences as a much older man, meeting one of his former tormentors face-to-face in Thailand, revisiting his old prison camp and then visiting Japan. This section of the book is the most powerful, as Lomax's utter hatred and loathing of the Japanese comes through the text vividly. He has no interest in forgiveness or reconciliation until he meets his former adversary and discovers the extreme lengths he has gone to to make amends for his actions in the war, including directly challenging Japan's culture of denial and disinterest in the war crimes committed by its soldiers during the war.
The Railway Man is one of the most powerful experiences of life in wartime I have ever read. Lomax illuminates the so-called 'forgotten war' by showing the rank foolishness that led to Singapore's capture, the overconfidence of the British POWs whose initial freedoms led them into a false sense of security, and the horrors of torture, in which no punches are pulled. Lomax describes his own mistreatment in a somewhat dispassionate tone for the most part, but occasionally his fury and anger at his mistreatment comes through, undimmed by fifty years of peace (the book was originally published in 1995). Lomax refuses to consider himself a hero, citing many of his fellow soldiers whose feats were more impressive (such as the Scottish officer who grabbed a rifle off a startled Japanese guard to put a bullet through one of his own men dying from cholera after the Japanese proved unable to shoot him accurately), but, as with many old soldiers, Lomax dismisses his own achievements too easily. Lomax refuses to give out any names or compromise the network that led to the construction of the radios, despite being put through treatments almost too horrendous to contemplate (including the Japanese practice of repeated waterboarding), saving the lives of his colleagues. The final section, dealing with the reconciliation, is quietly hopeful, with the reader left hoping that the author has indeed exorcised his demons through the process of the meeting and the writing of this book.
The Railway Man (*****) is a remarkable story, powerful, moving and intense, and again confirming that people can endure incredible hardships under extraordinary circumstances when the need is greatest. It is a book that everyone with an interest in the Second World War should read. It is available now in the UK and USA.
Bookmark and Share
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful
on 21 March 2010
Mr Lomax's harrowing account of his imprisonment during WWII is a window on a part of history that we should all learn from. Much of Mr Lomax's story is similar to thousands of POWs during this time, but, by his own admission, many are unable to speak of their experiences, much less share them in writing. This makes his story all the more compelling and important to understand.
It was with increasing admiration that I read each page, not least the subsequent years after the war, coming to terms with what he had experienced; suffering in silence during much of this time before finally confronting his past.
I feel it a matter of due respect that I refer to the author formally as Mr Lomax and recommend highly that this book be read and reread for generations. Importantly, the account is well told and events described in such detail that I was able to imagine the environment and the people with startling clarity.
Frightening, uplifting and inspirational; an honour to have been a witness through the eyes of Mr Lomax and I owe him thanks.
39 of 43 people found the following review helpful
on 31 January 2008
I have never read a book so fast in all my life! A real 'page-turner', a riveting story. Its incredible that anyone could survive the experiences described in this book. I think that this book is crying out to be made into a film. It has everything that would make a truly great film :- a time of turmoil, an exotic location, a mild-mannered character drawn into a horrifying set of circumstances and surviving against staggering odds, humanity displayed at its best and at its worst, the backdrop of a world war, and ultimate reconciliation and forgiveness - the solution of an inner torment that could be solved in no other way.
I hope to see this on the big-screen one day.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
on 16 December 2014
If you are looking for literary brilliance then this book is not quite that. It's written well, clear, articulate, but it is not a great work of literature in the sense of Dostoevsky or Virginia Woolf. What it is, however, is a brutally honest account of the defeat of the British in Singapore and the subsequent imprisonment, enslavement and torture as experienced by Lomax at the hands of the Imperial Japanese Army. Lomax's story then unfolds as he tries to reconcile his experiences with the relative pettiness of civilian life, a reconciliation he eventually achieves through meeting, and forgiving, one of his torturers more than 40 years after his liberation. Lomax's account moved me through, hatred, sadness to eventual happiness and wonder at the ability of human beings to rise above even the most horrific of experiences to find a common humanity and shared hope for a better future.
Quick note on the movie. The movie dramatises and changes many critical events as you might expect. I imagine Lomax would be horrified at the description of him as being "the best of us" when talked about by his other surviving comrades. But that's movie land and the film is, at least, a decent advert for the book.
25 of 28 people found the following review helpful
on 14 January 2014
Very well written account of the SE Asia theatre of WW2.
'Into the Valley of Death rode the 600' has not much on the 50,000 into the Jungle railroad of Burma.
For me historically informative as indeed a Signals Officer is well placed to be.
Puts a completely different perspective on 'The Bridge over the River Kwai'. Authors comment on the film,
'.....the best fed POWs I have ever seen....'
Clash of cultures Western and Japanese clear in the narrative.
The lasting effects on the survivors and the author and to some extent both sides points up starkly the unsung heroes
that war veterans can be. Reminds us that the same was true of WW1 combatants.
The reconciliation, almost incredible, shows how confronting the anger can bring closure.
29 of 33 people found the following review helpful
on 25 October 2005
Eric Lomax's book is a remarkable tale of courage, endurance and forgiveness. I bought the book whilst on holiday in Singapore and thought it superb from beginning till end.
I have a great love of literature but sadly there isn't much on the bookstore shelves to get excited about. Nowadays, it seems that there are way too many "authors" who have never really lived and the superficiality of their prose is clearly that of the untried apprentice. On the other hand, Eric Lomax may not be a famous author but the beautiful simplicity and humility of his brutal tale make it worthy of fame. It is clear from the outset that his his voice is one of genuine authority: the authority of a man who has earned his right to authorship through an immense suffering.
I recommend this book as a classic of its kind and as one of particular value to anybody who has suffered in circumstances not of their own making.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
I very nearly gave up on this book in the early stages. The true life of a train spotter is the absolute antithesis of my choice of read. I was encouraged to persevere by the members of my book group and the book certainly improved once Eric Lomax left his home and travelled as a young signals officer to Malaya, where he is eventually taken prisoner by the Japanese.
Initially Eric and his friends are protected from the worst treatment by their knowledge of mechanics. They are put to work repairing the machinery used to construct the Burma/Siam railway. They have certain freedoms, being able to wander the island, from which there is no escape, and purchase fruit and veg to supplement their prison rations. Naturally they are desperate for news from the rest of the world and manage to construct a radio set from bits and pieces. Although it is dismantled after every use and the constituent parts hidden from sight, the Japanese somehow learn of its existence and the six mechanics are treated brutally. Two die from the beatings and Eric Lomax is so severely bruised that his whole body is black and both wrists are broken. Eric is also found to have a map of the area and this creates additional suspicions amongst the Japanese, who question him endlessly, with more beatings and semi drownings in an attempt to extract information that he does not have.
The survivors are taken to Outram prison, where they are fed just two bowls of rice a day. Disease is rife and many died. Eric survives by taking a chance and convincing the warders that he is severely ill. He is transferred to the hospital section of the notorious Changi prison, heaven in comparison to Outram.
After the war there was no treatment for sufferers of Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome, it was not known that the effects of torture could have long lasting consequences and survivors were expected to assimilate back into 'normal' life. Inevitably Eric suffers from nightmares, but also from an inability to express emotions and give of himself. He has survived by becoming very closed and withholding emotion and this has altered his personality. Fifty years later he receives the help he so desperately needed to deal with the effects of his abuse.
The final chapter sees Eric confronting the interpreter who had been present for the endless days of questioning. This man had been the centre of the hate he felt for the Japanese and the meeting of the two provides some closure for Eric Lomax's sufferings.
Not an easy read, not just for the train-spotting, but also for the harrowing abuse. It was, however, an eye-opener about life for the prisoners of war under the Japanese. The struggles of a survivor to readjust to life after war also made for interesting reading. A worthy contribution to WWII literature that will become part of the documentation for generations to come.
All respect to Eric Lomax.