Customer Reviews


5 Reviews
5 star:
 (1)
4 star:
 (3)
3 star:
 (1)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars When gods learn contrition
Miles' earlier work on a desert people's god, "God: A Biography," focused on a deity new at the job. Miles' portrayal depicted a god learning the role. He's inconsistent, breaks promises, commits genocide and grows increasingly dictatorial. At one point, a single man challenges him, winning a moral victory which clearly disturbs this irrational spirit...
Published on 26 Dec 2005 by Stephen A. Haines

versus
3.0 out of 5 stars Absorbing, intriguing - but not completely satisfying
In this second volume of his `biography' of God as he [sic] appears in the Bible, Jack Miles treats us to an absorbing analysis of how the divinty's character in the New Testament `radically revises the meaning of God's life [in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament] as a whole' (266). The author assumes for literary purposes, and in contrast to the historical-critical approach...
Published on 23 Sep 2010 by Jeremy Bevan


Most Helpful First | Newest First

4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars When gods learn contrition, 26 Dec 2005
By 
Stephen A. Haines (Ottawa, Ontario Canada) - See all my reviews
(HALL OF FAME REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)   
Miles' earlier work on a desert people's god, "God: A Biography," focused on a deity new at the job. Miles' portrayal depicted a god learning the role. He's inconsistent, breaks promises, commits genocide and grows increasingly dictatorial. At one point, a single man challenges him, winning a moral victory which clearly disturbs this irrational spirit. Finally, like an elderly curmudgeon, the deity simply withdraws from those he wishes to worship him.
According to Miles, after a long span of time the god has learned remorse. He has subjected his followers to a succession of invasions and dispersals. Israel becomes a client state of the Assyrians, Babylon, Greece, and now, Rome. As with many aged, powerful men, the god has reflected on his own actions and decided some positive actions are in order. He doesn't consider his career a failure, but discerns humanity's course isn't following its destined path. Genocide and other manifestations of his power are no longer the answer. A new course is necessary, so he becomes the Incarnation - a deity housed in a human body.
Miles portrayal of Christ's life shows how poorly this deity understands his creation. After all, as a god with neither peers nor serious challengers, he fails to understand human characteristics. Throughout the account, Christ is ambivalent in his assigned role. He shifts from expressing his divinity to being but a man, confused and perplexed by the role forced on him. He doesn't question his fate, knowing, at least in his adult life, that he is to be sacrificed. He understands the need for his role, but anticipates the pain as any of us would.
Miles relates how uncertainty leads to ambivalence in the behaviour of this Incarnation. Repelling followers at first, he begins gathering adherents, but, they too, are confused. Mostly Jews, his recruits think his mission is to restore Israel as promised. When they fail to understand his claim to a wider mission, they fail to comprehend. How can this "messiah" claim to redeem Israel when he offers succor to strangers and enemies? When he dies in such squalid circumstances, a social criminal, the distress among his followers is intense. Miles notes the significance of such a death, describing it as "a huge and horrifying surprise". Christ has not imparted his knowledge of the finale, leaving his followers confused and adrift. Even the resurrection seems hardly worthy of notice. There's no grandeur, no powerful declarations, little drama. The meaning of it all must be derived over time until the deity's original intention can be imparted to others. The result is not the god's accomplishment, but the people who had faith in the idea and imparted it to others.
Miles' account is full of inconsistencies and elf-contradictions. These are not author's faults, however, resulting instead from the material he consults and brings to our view. The Incarnation is as inconsistent as his "father," which isn't surprising given his previous career. Christ asserts the teachings of the Prophets foretell his coming, yet the god Miles portrays seems to know nothing of "love" in those days, particularly love of all humanity. The god's focus, promises and failures, are for Israel alone. How then, does this deity in its human incarnation, expect anyone to believe his new identity? Miles concludes that the act of sacrifice is self-explanatory needing no further elaboration.
Miles postscripts the story with a literary analysis of its telling. One interesting facet is the Bible's use of irony. Irony uses or "double meaning, or reversal of meaning. . . and will not stoop to explanation." He suggests that in this case, long-standing practices are suddenly reversed, then there is a place for irony in religion. He admits to the novelty of the concept, but argues that it fits the Judeo-Christian story. It's a compelling and challenging idea, but then, so is this book. [stephen a. haines - Ottawa, Canada]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The Gospels as Art, 3 Oct 2003
By 
A historian reading the Gospels as historical documents might attempt to find clues to underlying facts behind the texts; which sayings of Jesus might be original, which miracle stories might point to the reality of a real real Galilean faith-healer? Traditional theology has looked to the Gospels as the definitive accounts of the the incarnation of God on earth revealing in parable and metaphor as well as in plain language the nature of God's relationship with mankind and the potential for atonement between man and God. Jack Miles avoids both these approaches, saying that if the Gospels are like a stained Glass window we should look at the window itself and at what it represents whithout trying to see through it to what it can only obscure.
The Gospels in his book are analysed as works of literature, very much in their historical and cultural context and very much with an eye to their original and timeless meaning but without the encumbrances of either a secular, sceptical arrogance or a credulous, faithful naivity. It is a brave and challenging attempt to read and understand the Gospels simply as they are and to try to see what they were meant to convey.
His conclusions are bold and suprising. An analysis that traditional Jewish beliefs about their God were becoming unsustainable in the first century before being shattered by the destruction of Jerusalem, and a model of christian atonement which is very distict from both the Pauline model and from conventional modern christianity
A fine read for anyone wanting a fresh angle on scripture.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars An ingenious way to read the Bible, 11 Mar 2005
By 
Ralph Blumenau (London United Kingdom) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)   
Treating Christ as God Incarnate, this book is a sequel to the author's God: a Biography, which showed how God developed in the course of the Old Testament. In this book He finds that He needs to change still further. As brilliant as its predecessor. The way the author alerts the reader to the tiniest nuances of language in the New Testament is masterly. The two books make you forget that the books of the Bible were actually all written by different people and over a huge span of time. Miles' approach makes the entire Bible appear as if it had been conceived as one seamless work of literature. Historically that is nonsense, of course; but even so it is a rewarding and stimulating way to read the Bible.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


3.0 out of 5 stars Absorbing, intriguing - but not completely satisfying, 23 Sep 2010
By 
Jeremy Bevan (West Midlands, UK) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)   
In this second volume of his `biography' of God as he [sic] appears in the Bible, Jack Miles treats us to an absorbing analysis of how the divinty's character in the New Testament `radically revises the meaning of God's life [in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament] as a whole' (266). The author assumes for literary purposes, and in contrast to the historical-critical approach to the NT that has prevailed for much of the twentieth century, that everything Jesus says, does or suffers in the NT should be regarded as said, done or suffered by God. This means that all God's earlier (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament) words were effectively Jesus' as well, and all he says, everywhere he goes, is charged with resonance as a result. Unable to save his chosen people militarily from the Romans by divine power, God in Jesus instead sacrifices himself (commits suicide, as it were), as both God and human, to show them that the only hope of resurrection lies beyond death, rather than before it.

The perspective that Miles' approach gives the NT and its revivifying of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament themes is a fruitful and intriguing one, graced once again by the author's rich and densely culturally allusive writing. But - it seems to me - it's ultimately less satisfying than his portrait of God in volume one (God: A Biography). For one thing, the NT is arguably less differentiated than the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament, giving God's character in Jesus less room for development. But more problematically, Miles' approach spiritualises and eschatologises all that Jesus came to achieve, overlooking in particular the resurrection's very practical, earthly and immediate, indeed revolutionary, impact on the lives of Roman subjects at the time. It's also very difficult to get completely away from the weight of recent historical-critical scholarship's emphasis on Jesus' human life that inevitably lies in the background of a work such as this - and which itself has been as fruitful a source of reflection on the ways of `God among us' as his purported divinity has. For these reasons, then, Miles' second volume is not altogether successful - though absorbing and intriguing once again, it has to be said.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Excellent discussion of the Gospels in a fresh light., 19 July 2004
In this book Jack Miles looks at the four Gospels from the point of view of a literary critic, dissecting the story rather than a religious scripture. His analysis concerns most of the entire narrative of Jesus' life and Miles offers a lot in the way of historical insight, subtle meaning in dialogue and the cultural weight of the story. Unwittingly, I'm sure, Miles also has written this book in a way that lends itself very well to being a good reference text. Miles critique will not please the evangelical Christians, or Christian "fundamentalists" by virtue of the fact that his approach is primarily intellectual. It must be stressed, however, that Miles is not trying to act as a theologian, although in places he does lean in that direction. The downsides of this book are that Miles fluctuates between writing clearly and then inpenetrably. There are places where the fact that he know's he is clever expresses itself in his unnecessarily arrogant style. But that is only in places. Another disappointment with the author is that I personally contacted him with questions concerning the gospels which were not addressed in the book, and his answers where utterly inadequate. Miles is an expert, albeit an arrogant one, on a narrow field of thought. When pushed beyond the boundaries of his expertise, he falls apart at the seams but retains all the arrogance of someone who still knew what he was saying. Nonetheless, this does not detract from the quality of the published book, and I very much enjoyed reading it for it's own sake. As a person with an interest in reading books about Christianity by authors who can offer some brainpower behind their theories, I utterly enjoyed reading Jack Miles.
You should also know that the book comes in two guises: hardback and paperback. I know I'm probably unorthodox in this respect but I much prefer the hardback edition despite its higher price. This is because the paperback edition has quite small print and I like to make pencil notes all over the margins. Also I find it hard to finish a book if the letters are tiny - it seems like its much more to read than it should.
Anyway, I would recommend this book, even though I don't think that the author is very humble or helpful if you want to know more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Christ: A Crisis In The Life Of God
Christ: A Crisis In The Life Of God by Jack Miles (Paperback - 7 Feb 2011)
10.99
Usually dispatched within 1 to 4 weeks
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews