Customer Reviews


8 Reviews
5 star:
 (4)
4 star:
 (2)
3 star:
 (1)
2 star:
 (1)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


25 of 25 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars 4.5 Stars. A Wonderfully Atmospheric Novel.
'The Wine of Solitude', which was first published in 1936, is considered to be Irene Némirovsky's most autobiographical novel and is a poignant story of a young girl's difficult relationship with her beautiful, but vain and shallow mother. The novel is set during the period of the Great War and the Russian Revolution and is wonderfully atmospheric.

The...
Published on 26 Oct 2011 by Susie B

versus
3.0 out of 5 stars A dive into depression with little hope at end
Though beautifully written, the subject matter is difficult to turn into something positive by the end.
I would not say there's a plot to this novel at all everything is told and often shown to be what it actually is.
Some brut images of the mother and difficult tempestuous scenes.
Not an easy read.
Published 7 months ago by JULIE DEXTER


Most Helpful First | Newest First

25 of 25 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars 4.5 Stars. A Wonderfully Atmospheric Novel., 26 Oct 2011
By 
Susie B - See all my reviews
(TOP 50 REVIEWER)   
This review is from: The Wine of Solitude (Hardcover)
'The Wine of Solitude', which was first published in 1936, is considered to be Irene Némirovsky's most autobiographical novel and is a poignant story of a young girl's difficult relationship with her beautiful, but vain and shallow mother. The novel is set during the period of the Great War and the Russian Revolution and is wonderfully atmospheric.

The story begins a few years before the Great War, in Kiev, where a young Helene Karol lives with her parents and grandparents. Helene is devoted to her Jewish father, Boris, but has a volatile and difficult relationship with Bella, her mother. Bella married Boris to improve her financial situation and Helene feels a great resentment towards her mother who continually quarrels with her husband and is often unfaithful to him. As Helene is neglected by her mother, she builds a close and loving relationship with her governess and, as time passes, she comes to regard Bella with increasing dislike - "She nurtured in her heart a strange hatred of her that seemed to increase as she grew older...". Helene's dislike for her mother increases further when Bella starts a love affair with Max who is fifteen years her junior. Boris turns a blind eye to the affair and concentrates on his business, but his obsession with improving the company's profits means he has very little time for Helene, and this coupled with Bella's indifference towards her daughter, only increases Helene's isolation and resentment as she grows up.

However, there are more important issues at hand, when the October Revolution starts the family flee to Finland and then to France where Helene, now a young woman, begins to think of her romantic future. She starts a dalliance with a married man, but later turns her attention to Bella's lover, Max, in order to punish her mother whose looks are now fading. Helene, after years of feeling neglected, now realizes that her youth and strength give her "....an intoxicating power" and it is a power that she wants to use. However, as Helene becomes more perceptive at observing life going on around her, she realizes that certain traits which exist within her mother also exist within herself, and that she must not let her dislike of Bella lead her into a life that is a shallow copy of her mother's.

This is a beautifully written novel where Némirovsky wonderfully depicts a tumultuous period in history and her work has been thoughtfully and sensitively translated by Sandra Smith. It is true that one could take a moralistic tone with characters in this novel and say that few of them behave really well or deserve our sympathy, but this was a time in history when everything was played out in a turbulent world arena, where nothing remained stable and where lives were cast adrift by the catastrophic events of war and displacement. And Némirovsky captures that time perfectly.

Recommended
4.5 Stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


15 of 15 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Absorbing and beautifully written, 3 Nov 2011
By 
Suzie (Scotland, UK) - See all my reviews
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Wine of Solitude (Hardcover)
We first meet Hélène when she is eight years old, a lonely child, born in Kiev in pre-Communist Russia. She adores her father, who, although affectionate towards her, has eyes only for her shallow, self-centred mother and devotes little time to his daughter. So preoccupied is he with business ventures and with gambling, that he leaves Hélène outside the casino in Monte Carlo, emerging hours later surprised to find her waiting and too absorbed in his own affairs to realise that she must be starving hungry.

Her mother is vain, shallow, and dissatisfied with life as a wife and mother in Russia. Easily bored, she peruses the latest fashion magazines from Paris and dreams of the excitement, danger, and the lovers she would take if only she could live in Paris. Hélène detests her mother, with her marble skin and claw-like nails, so it is not surprising that she relies on her French governess, Mademoiselle Rose, for the love and companionship her family fails to provide.

As the years pass and she grows up, she is able to observe her mother's behaviour from a dispassionate distance. She notes the sagging flesh, the lines and wrinkles, and relishes the realisation that she can at last effect revenge and make her mother suffer as she herself has suffered.

Beautifully translated, the book is almost worth reading for the descriptions alone. You feel as if you know Kiev, even if you've never been to Russia, and St Petersburg, where `soft, damp snow falls from a yellowish sky and is whipped away by a furious wind', and the `sickly odour of filthy water' rises from the Neva.... `A thick fog wafted through the air like smoke. Hélène hated this strange city before she even arrived; now that she saw it, her heart ached as if something terrible was about to happen....' After the family flees St Petersburg during the October Revolution, you see the snowy wastes of Finland and experience the exhilaration of hurtling down a slope of pristine snow on a toboggan, laughing, young again, and, for a short time, free of care. And so at last to Paris. I think to reveal more would spoil it for those who haven't read it.

In many ways The Wine of Solitude is more absorbing and accessible than Suite Française so if you haven't read either I'd recommend starting with this one. Do try it, and I hope you'll love it as I did!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The Wine of Solitude-Nemirovsky., 27 Dec 2011
By 
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Wine of Solitude (Hardcover)
Having read all her other novels, translated so very well from the original French by Sandra Smith, I was very pleased to have this latest offering. It is a novel that explores a girl/young woman's relationship with her mother and to a lesser extent with her father. It exudes atmosphere and is considered to be a reflection of Nemirovsky's relationship with her own mother-according to the biography of Nemirovsky by Philipponnat and Lienhardt. Incidentally, this is available in English and well worth reading. 'The Wine of Solitude' is a must read for those who admire Nemirovsky's work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Must the sins, weaknesses, of the mother inevitably be repeated?, 2 April 2013
By 
Katharine Kirby "Kate" (HELSTON, Cornwall United Kingdom) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)    (TOP 100 REVIEWER)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Wine of Solitude (Paperback)
Our Book Club Choice April 2013

I feel in awe of by these double figure novels, written in perhaps ten years before such a wicked wasteful end. Prolific, driven, focused; Irene Nemirovsky worked away at her craft until she literally ran out of ink, spending her last days in Auschwitz, dying there in 1942, all the while her husband obsessively writing to the authorities pleading for her release. This drawing of attention to himself ensured that he too was captured and killed in Auschwitz soon after his wife. Now translated into 38 different languages, she clearly has universal appeal. Seeing `The Estate of Irene Nemirovsky' written at the beginning makes her fate all the more poignant and somehow brings her back to life.

Her daughters' more recent discovery of `Suite Francaise' six years ago, allowed us all a chance to read that great and memorable novel. Perhaps `The Wine of Solitude', first published in 1935, has been considered to be semi- autobiographical, and it all rings true. Sensitively translated again by Sandra Smith, in 2011, a supremely skilled interpreter of the Ukrainian Jewish French speaking but Slavic born Irene Nemirovsky. There is no sign of a language barrier; all is elegantly smooth and flowing. I enjoyed listening to Sandra Smith talking about Irene on you tube.

This book really richly rewards re reading. On the first pass you may be just sticking to sorting out the shape of the story, then secondly truly savouring the superb descriptive passages.

Hidden, well-placed clues also will emerge from the text. For example, the first time Max is mentioned, as a boy visiting with his mother Lydia Safronov. Another is the side story of French Mademoiselle Rose, Helene/ Lili's companion, nurse, nanny, and governess. She dares to say that she thinks sometimes Lili has a demon in her. This demon is shown to grow inside its host, a succubus, and an evil twin. Mademoiselle Rose, a humble, patient creature, brought up herself in an Ursuline Convent, whom Helene praises as being `the only pure, peaceful woman she had ever known', understands her charge too well. She even chooses her time to leave. I loved `The servant brought in a lamp, and with the doors and windows shut, a sweet safe little universe once more encircled the child and her governess, a world that was like a seashell, and just as fragile'....

The opening domestic scenes are as if we are looking into a doll's house with the old fashioned stiff little family carefully placed around the living room. I was touched by the grandmother, who is not a major part, `She was only fifty but she looked so old and weary'. She was the ultimate self-sacrificer. She put herself at the back of the queue and cried all the time, just longing to be of use. As to the old gentleman grandfather who spent 'all morning' polishing his fingernails, well, that is an image I'd rather not have in my head!

Escaping from Kiev in Imperial Russia, St. Petersburg, to Finland then Paris, the family all but break up, leaving Helene and her hated amoral mother Bella rubbing along together awkwardly. Irene Nemirovsky is renowned for her portrayal of monstrous mothers. Themes of fortunes won and lost, banking collapses, also arise as well as the dispersal of ancient family possessions - jewellery bartered for loaves of bread in terrible times. For a while the family are the recipients of such valuable debris, greedily filling their home with stuff, often not even unpacked, gathered wildly from ruined neighbours.

Perhaps the kernel of the story is the attitude of adults towards children at that time. The dog died but euphemisms are employed leaving Helene confused and waiting for its return. Our twenty first century way of parenting is so very different and this is something worth discussing. Bella wasn't prepared to submit to being a good mother. She maintained her sense of self and confidence in her entitlement to whatever she wants. She had, for her punishment, an ungrateful child.

Boris Karol, referred to as Karol, initially managed a factory although Bella announced that he `owned' the business. He then made and lost large amounts of money gambling, often really successfully. Helene felt she was like him rather than her mother; she yearned for him when he was away but gets very little attention from him in his presence. Why he always rolled over is a small mystery, he found it easier to give in - `They would shout and then they would stop'. His weakness was recognised by his first employer as a danger even before he done anything fraudulent or disloyal.

Helene wants a life that didn't seem possible - `Oh how I long to be French!' (A country which disappointingly would eventually betray her creator - thereby sentencing her to death). She uses writing as a means to escape but her early thoughts on paper are discovered, causing a desperately distressing response from her family. `Sometimes this child seems like an idiot. You'd think she landed on earth from the moon!'

At fourteen years old Helen falls hopelessly for a married man, Fred, a family from within her Finnish social circle. The awakening of her young spirit to passion is exquisitely written. A feeling of power begins to spark into her heart. Helene uses her experiences to seduce Max in the duel that takes up so much of the last part of the book. A coming of age novel in its truest form.

I wonder if anybody out there knows where the quotation - `le vin de solitude' comes from? It sounds like a classical allusion.

If Irene Nemirovsky survived surely we would have had one of the most intricate, useful and eyewitness accounts of the Holocaust. Being a stateless Jew, denied French nationality she went first, with no possible pardon.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Powerful story about a young girl's loss of innocence, 10 Sep 2012
By 
S. Barnes (UK) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
This review is from: The Wine of Solitude (Paperback)
The novel begins in a shabby apartment in a provincial town in the Ukraine ...'The silence of this sleepy provincial town, lost deep within Russia, was intense, heavy and overwhelmingly sad.' Eight-year-old Hélène sits at the dinner table with her mother, father, grandparents and French governess, Mademoiselle Rose. Devoid of affection from her mother, indifferent to the affections of her grandparents, Hélène has only eyes for her beloved Papa, who rarely makes the time to notice her, and her practical and caring Mademoiselle Rose. In this environment young Hélène's distance from her mother begins its descent to hatred, fuelled by her mother's love affairs, her treatment of her papa, her coldness towards her daughter and treatment of Mlle Rose.

As the family's fortunes change, Boris moves them first to St. Petersburg, leaving Hélène's grandparents behind and taking with them Hélène's cousin and Bella's lover, Max; subsequently, the Russian Revolution leads Boris and Bella to hide money and share certificates in every available piece of furniture, stuffing notes into sofas for safekeeping. Hélène sadly watches the Revolution go on around them from her privileged position, despondent at her parents ignorance of the hardships surrounding them. The Revolution then leads them to flee first to the Finnish borders, and then to Helsinki; later, after the War's end, to Paris. Hélène's teenage years are spent mostly in isolation, against this backdrop of war and upheaval, changing fortunes, lies and deceit. She grows up devoid of affection, falls into an innocent, brief affair with a married man and hatches a plot to wreak revenge on her mother. In all, we see her emerge into a hard and bitter young woman; her redeeming features being her determination to turn out differently and not succumb to the same path as her mother. It's not difficult to empathise with this bitter, young Hélène as what else has she known?

A number of Irène Némirovsky's novels carry this theme of mother-daughter estrangement and the rebellious daughter, and 'The Wine of Solitude' is believed to be the most autobiographical of these - the fleeing from the Russian Empire, the year spent in Finland, before settling in Paris. The denouement of the novel is perhaps more final than Irène's gradual estrangement from her mother (reference. Jonathan Weiss, 'Irène Némirovsky: Her Life and Works'). It leaves the reader to wonder if this is the dramatic exit from her mother's life that Irene wishes she had taken.

It's a very well-executed novel, short on words but not lacking in description; fluidly written, evocative and shocking and undeniably, a powerful coming-of-age story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


3.0 out of 5 stars A dive into depression with little hope at end, 10 Mar 2014
By 
JULIE DEXTER (LONDON, United Kingdom) - See all my reviews
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
Though beautifully written, the subject matter is difficult to turn into something positive by the end.
I would not say there's a plot to this novel at all everything is told and often shown to be what it actually is.
Some brut images of the mother and difficult tempestuous scenes.
Not an easy read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4.0 out of 5 stars Irene Nemirowski, 9 Jan 2014
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Wine of Solitude (Hardcover)
I loved this book, I purchased it after reading 'Suite Francaise', Her books are amazingly perceptive and I wonder how much she writes from her own experience. She is a great writer whose own tragic story I have still to read. Her murder at the hands of the concentration camp has robbed us of a classic writer. The book has, of course, been translated from the original in French but I am sure that she would have approved.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


0 of 2 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Book Group Choice., 4 Dec 2012
By 
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Wine of Solitude (Paperback)
Came highly recommended but I was very disappointed. It went nowhere! Some good descriptive passages but there was not a lot to discuss at our group meeting. Could not honestly recommend this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

The Wine of Solitude
The Wine of Solitude by Irène Némirovsky (Paperback - 6 Sep 2012)
£6.39
In stock
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews