Customer Reviews

Deverry 9: Red Wyvern

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I'm a little confused as to why this book is being called "Book One of the Dragon Mage," as though Kerr has begun a new series. The story takes up right where the last book, "Days of Air and Darkness," left off. In addition, Kerr spends much of the book returning to an earlier thread of her story that was left unfully told several volumes back. This book therefore seems a direct descendent to her first eight. But why quibble?: This is a worthy successor to her earlier work.

As mentioned above, I was pleased to find her finally completing her tale of the Civil Wars, begun so many books back and left dangling for so long. I had begun to despair ever finding out in full about the conquest of Deverry by the High King and his supporters, so many of whom have played successive roles as Kerr's series unfolds. And, I gather, this part of her story is not yet fully over. In a similar vein, I was also heartened by hints that Ebany will once again be appearing, after being rather unceremoniously dumped back in "A Time of Omens." A complete jettisoning of these plot and character elements would have done much to diminish my opinion of this series. As I have thus far enjoyed it greatly, I was pleased that my faith in Kerr's writing had been rewarded.

Much more episodic than the current and, apparently, more popular works by Martin and Jordan, this work is nonetheless their equal, and deserving of more attention. While I believe this series overall is deserving of five stars, I gave this particular entry four, as I found Part 3 somewhat weaker in plot than the rest of the book. I realize this may be due to demands placed upon the author for setting up the next book, but nonetheless found this chapter unbalancing to the book's overall structure. This doesn't, however, lessen my anticipation for the publication of the next book. And for those fans already missing the passing of Jill and Nevyn, I suspect Jill in other guise is already back, and Kerr has indicated that Nevyn will shortly follow; Take heart!

Each of Katharine Kerr's books get better and the characters protrayed improve and grow with time. Being given more detail of the ending of the civil wars and hints of what is to come in the next three books just makes me want to read the nest even more.

I was left somewhat unconvinced by the second series of Deverry novels. I didn't like how things were resolved and felt there were things missing. In the latter part maybe I should have guessed Katherine kerr had plans for her world. It seems this eries is intended to tie up the loose ends of previous series...the matter of how the Red wyvern became the ruling clan and so forth, in addition to an interesting new story, and a fine new heroine to replace Jill from the first 8 books. (I hope). You really have to have read the first 8 to have a hope of understanding this one, but this is as good as the first few which originally hooked me into this wonderfully realised celtic flavoured world. Buy them all then buy this one.

As this was the first Devvery novel I have read (now, I find out, it's actually the ninth book!) I found the plot a little confusing. However, this didn't lessen the enjoyment of the novel for me at all. The characters are fascinating, and I love the idea that we meet them again and again, in different lives.

I also found myself engaging with the world, which is far from perfect and has its own rules and logic. It was also good to see some really strong female characters, who I think I shall come to care about a great deal as the books progress.

The one negative comment I have is to agree with a previous reviewer, who felt the novel lost pace at the end. I did feel it lost direction after we left Lillorigga's time, but perhaps that is down to my lack of knowledge about the series as a whole.

An unusual and fascinating fantasy novel.

Whilst this was the first kk book I read, and so I'm biast towards it, I think it is also the best. The plot and descriptions are impresive and adds to the vividness of the world of deverry. The civil war is a great setting. You probably shouldn't read it until you've read the preceeding books but then I managed it :)

This being the ninth in the series it followed on nicely from the others and the story line is developing well.

This is the first book in a new cycle of novels set in Deverry by Katharine Kerr, and as such new readers can start out at this point. I would recommend vehemently, though, that they do not since a number of storylines from prior novels come together or are referenced in this novel.

For the first time we drift in time forwards rather than backwards, albeit for a short time, when we discover that Haen Marn is adrift in time as well as space. A soldier from a more modern Scotland is cast into the mythical isle for a night, showing us in the process that Angmar is pregnant with Rhodry's child.

The majority of the novel takes place in the past though, taking us to a continuation of the tale of the civil war that tore Deverry in two - where Maryn becomes the High King under Nevyn's tutelage. The story is concentrated on Lillorigga (who we know in the current times as Niffa, the ratter's daughter) and her mother Lady Merodda - the person who becomes Raena, the Black Raven, and causes Rhodry such heartache. Here we discover why Raena and Rhodry's Wyrds are so tangled.

This is a great return to form for Kerr. I was somewhat disappointed in the last few novels she turned out - she seemed very much to be writing by the numbers. Here her writing comes alive again - with intrigue, scheming, battle, fair maidens, dweomer mysteries, and high adventure. I loved the character of Lillorigga, who came blessed with good sense and honour.

I was somewhat annoyed with Kerr's descriptive passages that seem lifted from one book to another. On the one hand you could say that it reinforces the effect she wishes to create, but I find the copy and paste technique a little lazy.

Once again I sighed and slowed down my reading during each portion of the book that dealt with Evandar and his brother Shaetano, who has now taken over where Alshandra left off. I can understand that the Fae - as these Guardians seem based on - live in a dreamlike Otherland, and I accept that Kerr might well be writing about them in a capable manner, but it slows the book down and I find myself bored of their antics. I am particularly frustrated with Evandar's endless scheming that (as Dallandra says) brings naught but hurt to the people they affect.

In fact, all of the book that has dweomer in it directly, I find fairly tiresome. I strongly believe that Kerr's strongest ability is to bring to very vivid life the Celtic medieval world. She writes extremely capably about life in a dun; her battle scenes are fascinating and realistically chaotic; and her strong female characters are countered heavily by the responsibilities they hold in earlier times (e.g. never being part of councils, doing all the sewing for the people of the dun, always being above reproach in terms of producing an heir for their lord).

This book dealt greatly with that element of Kerr's writing and hence I award it four stars, and look forward again to the next in the cycle.

What an awful book. Kathrine Kerr should really not have bothered. The characters had no depth, the plot was unorigional and the language used was cringe making. Do one worth while thing today, put down this book and go and read a truely great science fiction book like Lord of the Rings or Northern Light...