3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I read this book and it's more than okay, 23 May 2008
This review is from: I play the drums in a band called okay (Paperback)
Novels made up from short stories are extremely difficult to pull off correctly. All too often they don't read as a vaguely connected collection which doesn't hold as a cohesive whole (even the master of this type of book - Ray Bradbury - only really got it right with Dandelion Wine). This book doesn't fall into that trap. It works equally well as a selection of short stories or a novel.
And what a novel!
This is one of the best books I've read this year. We follow the eponymous Drummer in Canadian indie band okay (small letters, italicised) from their formation as a group of teens in their garage all the way into middle age and parenthood. The rock and roll excesses are there but they're not the focus of the book. Why go for the clichés all over again. There are so many books about sex and drugs and rock and roll do we really need another one?
This book takes a more down to earth overview of the situation - all from the point of view of Clap, the drummer. Some of the stories move effortlessly from laugh out loud funny to complete tragedy in a matter of lines (in particular the story of the obsessed fan who waits for weeks in a hotel room for the band's lead singer - living on nothing but water and chocolate).
The writing is uniformly good throughout, the tone shifting nicely from the frenetic opening chapters to the more thoughtful and reserved later pages. Some of the images stick with you for a long while after - the girls voice described as sounding like an operatic cow yodelling down a mine shaft - after first falling down the mine shaft is a particular favourite of mine.
Five stars for me. Buy this book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Tales of excess and morality, 26 May 2008
This review is from: I play the drums in a band called okay (Paperback)
Told from the viewpoint of Clap, drummer in okay a Canadian indie band (other members Syph, Mono, and Crab) who are approaching middle age and the ill-advised albums and money making tours that come along with it.
The tales of excess and amplified ideas of importance are reminiscent of what you hear wheeled out in Nickelbacks's (shudders) mega hit `Rock Star' - cringeworthy, realistic and what you'd expect from a world famous (albeit fictional) band.
Rather than being like 'The Dirt' this has another level, which foloows Clap's journey from excess to Buddhism via infidelity fatherhood and realisation of his own mortality. It could have been approached with sarcasm and too much knowing, but Litt's depiction of the flawed yet nicest member of okay is self deprecating, and amusing without being clichéd.
Although at points the narrative seems to lose it's way, the anecdotes and the lessons learnt are worth sticking with it for when it gets back on track.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No