8 of 12 people found the following review helpful
This book tries to answer those questions that book 7 will answer, and as it's nothing but hit and miss guesswork it makes me wonder, 'why bother'? With Deathly Hallows published, and not long from now it will be, a theory book like this is pointless. Not anywhere near as insightful as it thinks it is, in turns obvious and dull, the book left me bored.
I'd say you're better off spending money on something else Potter related, something the actual author of the series wrote perhaps.