I would say the cover is fit for purpose. If I was picky, I would criticise the width in being marginally too broad but that is a small point. I think the breadth has been dictated by the thickness of the leather which is not the finest.Overall does what it is made for and good value for money.
I was hesitant in placing the order as it did not look good in the picture and seemed very big. I was pleasantly surprised when it arrived. Not bad looking at all and a perfect fit for the phone - Samsung Galaxy Y. Would recommend.