Ronan M. Conroy

Helpful votes received on reviews: 91% (10 of 11)
Location: Dublin Ireland


Top Reviewer Ranking: 1,761,022 - Total Helpful Votes: 10 of 11
Beethoven:  The Complete Piano Sonatas ~ HJ Lim
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful
HJ Lim has her own ideas. Some of them coincide with Beethoven's, but others simply do not. Why are we treated to a presto section in the middle of the last movement of the Pastoral? There is, indeed, a presto section at the end, but there is no indication that Beethoven wanted the central episode played presto also. And so on. Tempo changes where none are marked and, more important, none are needed, create havoc with Beethoven's logic.

On the positive side, there is something shocking about the playing that must surely have been similar to the effect Beethoven created on his hearers, all those years ago. There is a willfulness and an undoubted technical skill. But in comparison… Read more

Wish List