Mr. S. J. G. Gilmour

Helpful votes received on reviews: 76% (87 of 115)
Location: UK


Top Reviewer Ranking: 1,701,139 - Total Helpful Votes: 87 of 115
40th Anniversary Box Set ~ Manfred Mann's Earth Band
40th Anniversary Box Set ~ Manfred Mann's Earth Band
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars AMAZING, 4 Jan 2012
Just received this a week ago in Oz - with the book signed by Mr Mann himself!! Wonderful set package design booklet and remastering. Up to 8th disc already and loving it!! Even if you already own a number of these albums, the remastered cds are a joy to behold and the packaging is fantastic - not a bad word to say!! Now back to the roaring silence!!!
Signature Box ~ John Lennon
Signature Box ~ John Lennon
82 of 100 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars A missed opportunity, 3 Sep 2010
I have hardly ever written a review for Amazon before but in this case I felt I needed to. I hope it generates some discussion and comment.

A fantastic opportunity to celebrate the life and work of JL - but this box and even with its counterpart releases seems a huge missed opportunity. I guess this is written in the light of having bought and played Neil Young's Archives to death, and currently enjoying the Tom Petty live box, the genesis 5.1 boxes etc. and excited about the imminent release of the deluxe Sandy Denny box.

My point is this box is being released as deluxe - but I have a number of questions/comments as to what is missing to make this box truly a deluxe… Read more
Live 1973 - 2007 (Audio CDs and NTSC format DVD) ~ Genesis
3 of 12 people found the following review helpful
Great to have this coming to add to my other boxes but can anyone tell me why the last 2 cds are not mixed in 5.1?

Also....and this is key - is there video content and interviews like the other boxes or not? I hope so - that's what made those boxes worth the hefty price tags.

Saying that I already have this on pre-order either way.

Wish List