J. Roycroft

"Sci Fi Fan"
Helpful votes received on reviews: 88% (14 of 16)
Location: Dublin, Ireland

Frequently Used Tags


Top Reviewer Ranking: 1,069,791 - Total Helpful Votes: 14 of 16
1635: The Dreeson Incident (Ring of Fire) by Eric Flint
2.0 out of 5 stars Oh so humdrum, 13 Dec 2010
This is not the Eric Flint that we have come to know and love. While the book is interesting in parts it does not follow the well trodden path of action and fertile imagination that so many other books in the series demonstrate. I enjoyed it up to a point but could put it down and forget about it. In essence this book delves in depth into the detail of daily Grantville life with really very little in the way of action and the almost casual disposal/termination of the poor Mayor. I guess this very slow pace is down to the influence of Virginia DeMarce. Would not recommend the book.
1634: The Ram Rebellion (The Ring of Fire) by Eric Flint
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars Pure Drudgery, 20 Sep 2010
Dire, simply dire. I waded through this book, hoping against hope that I would find something to engage me. No such luck. Perseverance is all very fine and Lord knows I persevered but I could have spent my time much more enjoyably reading other books by Eric Flint or virtually any other author. It seems to me that what has drawn people to this series is the wonderful underlying premise, which offers so many different possibilities, including the eternally appealing story of the underdog fighting and sometimes triumphing against the odds, the clash of ideas and ideologies, religion versus individual freedom and a cast of intriguing characters to name but a few. And, of course, the Action… Read more
Grantville Gazette IV: 4 (Ring of Fire) by Eric Flint
2.0 out of 5 stars Dull and duller, 20 Sep 2010
It would seem that the Gazette series is getting more dull with each new publication. Yes it is "interesting" up to a point but it not military sci-fi as it lacks any military action. Some of the material in the Gazette series has been very interesting and enjoyable at times especially where it involves the main characters or the main themes of the primary series. And, I admit, up to a point the detailing of how stock markets etc might work in the new dispensation has an interest but only when mixed with stories with a bit more action and bite. Can we mix and match a bit more please?

Wish List