14 of 301 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Full of contradictions and apprehensions-complete waste of time, 11 April 2012
Firstly, the title is misleading and does not represent the book or it's storyline.
As the author attempts to take a clinical view of authenticity of documentation and records of Sunnah and Ahadiths, it's start by spelling 'Sahih al-Bukhari' INCORRECTLY. I found the written has taken on a task to bitterly gone to the limits of his ability to turn the picture extremely dark and full of contradictions. There are plenty of evidences and places to be visited personally to clear one's head from such doubts. The author somehow tries to implement his grasp of the history and material but completely failed once was was through first 50 pages!!
I would not recommend it to any one as its misleading and can easily put you on wrong ideology.
My first and last read from this author. Hardly find any good references for the author- DONOT KNOW WHY TIME PUT IT AS MUST READ!
MISLEADING AND FULL OF CONTRADICTIONS & APPREHENSIONS- may be author needs to clear his head up before writing or try to find work that's within his grasp.
Regret buying it..