Profile for R. P. Caulfield > Reviews

Personal Profile

Content by R. P. Caulfield
Top Reviewer Ranking: 5,805,761
Helpful Votes: 16

Learn more about Your Profile.

Reviews Written by
R. P. Caulfield "eddantes" (London, UK)
(REAL NAME)   

Show:  
Page: 1
pixel
A History of Britain: At the Edge of the World? - 3000BC-AD 1603 v.1: At the Edge of the World? - 3000BC-AD 1603 Vol 1 (BBC Radio Collection)
A History of Britain: At the Edge of the World? - 3000BC-AD 1603 v.1: At the Edge of the World? - 3000BC-AD 1603 Vol 1 (BBC Radio Collection)
by Simon Schama
Edition: Audio CD

16 of 16 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Well informed, 4 Mar. 2010
I've been moved to review this item mainly in response to the only other review on this site having awarded it one star, and seemingly holding against Simon Schama personally the misguided and belligerant conduct of kings.

Certainly this work is a whirlwind tour of history. A lack of detail may be a partial downfall but this is inevitable when faced with the task of fitting 4,600 years into 8 hours. Given the constraints, it's a well researched, eloquent and balanced assessment. It maintains an admirable moral distance and like all the best historical works, it reviews and reports rather than judging history, but never steps back from expressing an apt opinion - this is no simple list of dates and events.

In contrast to the other reviewer, I found great examples of social history here. Schama's analysis of the changes in societal structure caused by the plague are intriguing, as is his discussion of the shifting and uncertain balance of power between monarchy and other echlons of society.

So, flawed by the time available it may be, but it certainly provides much that the inquisitive amateur historian may be looking for in its review of the period. It is an intelligent study of causation rather than monotonous historical list-making.


Page: 1