4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Tired and contrived, 14 Jun 2009
I love PD James and I suppose everyone is entitled to an off day. I guess that she collects ideas as they occur and uses some. I gues that sometimes her publisher pushes her for a new book and sometimes no ideas are there. So, out comes the ideas book and sadly a lot of poor ideas are thrown together. That's what I suspect happened. In a totally contrived location, as likely as a moon station off the Isle of Wight the three detectives sleuth about and eventually solve the crime not through clues that we've all been part of their discovery but by a fever induced vision. Ms James - we expect better of you and luckily knopw that you will in future deliver.