Profile for Pol Pal > Reviews

Personal Profile

Content by Pol Pal
Top Reviewer Ranking: 1,009,334
Helpful Votes: 8

Learn more about Your Profile.

Reviews Written by
Pol Pal

Page: 1
Westminster: a Biography: From Earliest Times to the Present
Westminster: a Biography: From Earliest Times to the Present
by Robert Shepherd
Edition: Hardcover
Price: £18.00

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Lots of interesting trivia, 14 Dec 2013
This is an interesting read with plenty of memorable anecdotes drawn from centuries of history and politics. It takes a broadly chronological approach to the history of Westminster and ranges across the iconic buildings, institutions and personalities that have shaped the area and thereby the UK as a whole. Although it's full of quirky and revealing nuggets of information, it doesn't hang together particularly well. Whilst the 'parts' are great to dip in and out of, the 'whole' does not leave the reader with a particularly strong analytical overview of its subject. The evolving relationship between the legislative and executive branches is not especially well described and evaluated, and Westminster's position within the wider UK political system is not considered.

It reads like the author has taken a theme and shoved whatever historical trivia he fancies into the chapter. Some of the information doesn't really follow what has preceded it, such as the chapter 'Assassination', which is about PM Spencer Perceval's assassination in 1812, but which ends with a rather random paragraph about the emergence of Hansard as the official record of parliamentary debates. The book has many moments when it feels like the author is selecting material on a somewhat ad hoc basis. It means that there is plenty here to find interesting and informative (on the re-building of Parliament after the fire of 1834, for instance)but one is left feeling that a fuller account is to be found elsewhere. Given that it is called a 'biography' it doesn't spend much time exploring the inner life of Westminster. It's a tale of the surface changes and developments over the centuries (how road layouts have changed; how Downing Street developed; how the Palace of Westminster was re-built in the 1830s and 40s). It's the equivalent of writing an individual's biography by running through the events of the person's life without much reflection or analysis: a kind of 'this happened', 'then this happened' approach to biography. Given that the author attempts to consider the history, politics, geographical development and cultural significance of Westminster across 1200 years maybe he has taken on more than a 350 book can handle. It one wants to understand how policy is initiated and developed look elsewhere, and if one wants to explore the features of the great reforming governments that have shaped the UK this is not the book for you. It is a book of (partial) narrative history, rather than a book which looks to combine history with political analysis.

Having been quite harsh, I would recommend this book, but I would feel comfortable advising readers to dip in and out of it without feeling any guilt and I don't think one can expect to come away with a comprehensive knowledge of the subject.

OCR AS Government and Politics Student Book
OCR AS Government and Politics Student Book
by Jon Sutherland and Diane Canwell
Edition: Paperback
Price: £28.25

6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Lightweight and Patchy, 22 Nov 2010
This is a disappointing textbook. Promisingly, it's written with the AS OCR Govt and Politics specification in mind, but its coverage is thin in many places and it offers far too few specific examples. It touches on all the most relevant topics and is reasonably clearly laid out, but many important issues barely get a mention. For instance, given the importance of electoral reform in the OCR specification, the advantages and disadvantages of the Westminster voting system are only touched on in a very brief table. Many of the points raised are fine, but cry out for a few examples and the whole book never digs beneath the surface of each theme. It is too short and the font too large to cover the topics adequately. I couldn't give it more than a C-. It simply won't equip any student with the information and analysis necessary to achieve a good grade at A Level. Students would be better advised to try the new Paul Fairclough book on UK politics.
Comment Comment (1) | Permalink | Most recent comment: Jan 21, 2011 8:12 PM GMT

Page: 1