Profile for Son of Nietzsche > Reviews

Personal Profile

Content by Son of Nietzsche
Top Reviewer Ranking: 1,630
Helpful Votes: 1798

Learn more about Your Profile.

Reviews Written by
Son of Nietzsche "Refuse identification" (UK)
(VINE VOICE)   

Show:  
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11-19
pixel
Liquid Surveillance: A Conversation (PCVS-Polity Conversations Series)
Liquid Surveillance: A Conversation (PCVS-Polity Conversations Series)
by Zygmunt Bauman
Edition: Paperback
Price: £9.79

4.0 out of 5 stars For a wider audience, 16 May 2013
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
The notion of liquid modernity, expounded by Zygmunt Bauman in various texts, at its simplest, is the idea that the world of solid, defined structures is morphing into a seamless web of flows, and are consequently less visible and harder to theorise. This notion can be applied in an analysis of any realm of cultural theory; in the present text, Bauman joins with a prominent theorist within the relatively new field of surveillance studies, David Lyon, to consider the thesis that, as people are increasingly tracked via new technologies, surveillance is better considered as a liquid flow seeping into every realm of life, rather than as a vertical or hierarchical power technique.

The text itself takes the form of a 'conversation' between the two authors - unconvincing at times, but certainly offering the readability that aims to extend the ideas discussed to an audience beyond the Academy. Inevitably this intent tends to result in a less conceptually demanding text, although perhaps the potential of a broader audience is worth this sacrifice. Certainly, the detailed discussion of social media forms such as Facebook is liable to attract the attention of readers who may not otherwise have picked up the work.

On the question of the surveillance aspect of the discussion, it should be said that the text offers little in the way of modification to the theories already laid down by the great thinkers, such as Foucault, Deleuze, and Agamben. The most interesting aspect of the work is perhaps the reiteration of the idea expounded at length in Bauman's fascinating Modernity and the Holocaust - that the concentration camp and the Gulag have been "widely though wrongly viewed as rebellions against, rather than loyal to, the essential precepts of 'modern civilization'. Instead, they brought to its ultimate consequences the logic of the modern passion for order-building...". The point that is frequently forgotten is thus that the Nazi and Stalinist episodes of the twentieth century were fully in accordance with post-Enlightenment modernity - the same principles of modernity that continue to orient us; one need only consider the existence of Sex Offender Registries to understand that the values that built the concentration camp are still fully operative in contemporary culture.

Overall, the text is interesting so far as it goes - which is to say, insofar as it opens up new avenues of thought to readers outside the critical cultural theory tradition. Where readers may well be left wanting more is perhaps in the realm of the concluding discussion on 'what is to be done?'; if we accept the authors' thesis, has the seepage of 'liquid surveillance' reached a point of no return? As frequently occurs, the glimmer of optimism that is offered feels more of an platitudinous after-thought than a convincing line of potential.

Alexander's Choice
Alexander's Choice
by Edmund Marlowe
Edition: Paperback
Price: £8.88

4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Contemporary tragedy, 29 Jan 2013
Amazon Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Alexander's Choice (Paperback)
A stunning beauty, thirteen year old Alexander arrives at Eton naive and optimistic. He soon develops two special friendships: one with Julian - insecure, withdrawn, and three years his senior; the other with Damian, a young, newly-arrived English teacher. A personal tragedy, combined with his love of Ancient Greek history, propels Alexander to reconsider his relations with Julian and Damian against the framework of the ancient, ethical practice of 'Greek Love' - and the physical consummation that was considered a quintessential aspect of pedagogical mentorship (at least, prior to the subversion of that practice by Plato and other 4th century BCE intellectuals).

Transported to the 1980s, however, age-stratified relationships are not merely frowned-upon, but pose a threat to hierarchy, and more specifically to the carefully-cultivated image of The Child which serves as the rhetoric of every acknowledged politics; the phantasmal beneficiary of every political intervention. The image of 'The Child' is not simply the last taboo, but also the last possibility of taboo, the last universal mechanism for imposing order upon a decaying world. To contemporary culture, then, Alexander is not a living swarm of affections and passions, but rather an inert categorization, a strategic image - one which must be protected at any cost. Consequently, the irony of the novel's title is that the 'Alexander' visible to society is not entitled to 'choose' anything: as a fixed image that operates in the service of culture, he is always-already stripped of voice and life.

In his début novel, author Edmund Marlowe offers a voice to the movements and sensations, affects and percepts, that are concealed by this image. He quite literally creates a life: Alexander. Thoughtfully-crafted, insightful and compelling, ALEXANDER'S CHOICE is thus a courageous work of creation. Perhaps it is telling, however, that the work becomes (and can only become) an exemplification of how those satellite figures who invest heavily in constituting and maintaining the illusory image of The Child - parents, teachers, politicians, social workers, law enforcers - do so irrespective and heedless of that which always escapes their grasp. As Zarathustra predicted, "the earth has become small, and upon it hops the Last Man, who makes everything small. His race is as inexterminable as the flea...". Thus, the lingering sadness acknowledged in, and encapsulated by, the novel, is perhaps the suspicion that we no longer have ears for ALEXANDER'S CHOICE.
Comment Comments (2) | Permalink | Most recent comment: May 18, 2013 8:36 AM BST


Ali and Ramazan
Ali and Ramazan
by Perihan Magden
Edition: Paperback
Price: £6.99

3 of 5 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Monotonous and passionless, 7 Mar 2012
This review is from: Ali and Ramazan (Paperback)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
Ramazan, discovered as an abandoned baby, has been in institutions since the age of five. He is thirteen when 12-year-old Ali arrives at the orphanage. The two boys develop an immediate emotional and physical bond, which persists throughout the passing years. They remain together after they are turned out onto the streets of Istanbul at the age of 18 when, uneducated and penniless, the dynamics of their relationship begin to chart a new course.

It is difficult to offer an adequate review of ALI AND RAMAZAN, without knowing the extent to which the English translation reflects the original Turkish language. In any event, these comments must be taken to only refer to the English translation.

The novel is written entirely in free indirect discourse, which - in the hands of a skilled writer - can be an effective technique. Here, however, its deployment is also the novel's overwhelming failure. The authorial voice is the only one that can be heard, whether she speaks as Ramazan or as Ali - thus rendering both principal characters empty puppets, capable of issuing only the most trite and repetitive tabloid banalities. In short, the work is stripped of all passion, feeling and affect. Despite the potency of the subject-matter, the offered work is poorly-crafted, lacking originality and devoid of vitality - and consequently cannot be recommended.

For a truly powerful working-though of the idea that 'the true colour of love is blood', readers are advised to consider the Eric Jourdan masterpiece Wicked Angels.

This Beautiful Life
This Beautiful Life
by Helen Schulman
Edition: Paperback
Price: £8.96

3 of 6 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Unfulfilled premise, 2 Feb 2012
This review is from: This Beautiful Life (Paperback)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
A 13-year-old female, Daisy, sends an explicit video of herself to a 15-year-old male, Jake. Jake forwards the video to a friend, who forwards it to others, and soon the video has become viral. Jake is suspended from school and his parents must deal with the fall-out.

Readers intrigued by this admittedly tantalizing synopsis may find themselves disappointed. The substance of the novel in fact focuses upon the dynamics between Jake's parents: a frustrated New York housewife and an ambitious businessman, and in particular the former's struggle to be something other than 'wife' and 'mother'. The apparent catalyst - Daisy's video - feels something of a sideline amid the laborious self-reflections of Jake's parents. A BEAUTIFUL LIFE certainly does not attempt to confront questions surrounding the cultural problematization of Daisy's performance art (a youthful expression of sensuality, of the type constituting the vast majority of that which the abuse industry and media hysterically decry with their tedious neologism "images of abuse"), nor does it directly address social questions surrounding family life and new technologies.

If A BEAUTIFUL LIFE has some value, it is in the complication of the figural 'child' whose mythical and spectral presence detrimentally haunts public policy. To the extent that this seems barely to dent the tiresome bourgeois values of Jake's parents, however, it is doubtful that this complication will receive the notice it deserves. For a more engaging and direct confrontation with some of the issues promised by this novel's synopsis, readers are advised to consider instead Sarah Schulman's The Child.

Brothers' Lot, The
Brothers' Lot, The
by Kevin Holohan
Edition: Paperback
Price: £6.43

1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Impotent, 17 Sep 2011
This review is from: Brothers' Lot, The (Paperback)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
A Catholic institution, the Brothers of Godly Coercion School, forms the setting for the social critique offered by THE BROTHERS' LOT. The sadistic Brothers inflict old-school forms of violence upon the pupils, while the building seems increasingly to be caving in around them.

Portraying this implosion as a percept of the building itself is an interesting mechanism, and indeed demonstrates the author's potential. Sadly however, there is an absence of corresponding affective charge, such that, much like the School, the novel ultimately falls flat. The necessary caricatures are unable to bear the load placed upon them such that THE BROTHERS' LOT reads like a fairly-tale, in which the death of the dragon is understood as an all-too-neat and contrived cathartic end. All that has been accomplished, however, is the decapitation of one head of the Hydra.

A society encounters precisely those 'monsters' that it deserves. There is a continuity in Western culture, deriving from a transcendental foundation in the image of Western thought, that has produced, and continues to produce, major fascist atrocities (the Inquisition, the Concentration Camp, Hiroshima, Sex Offender Registries) as well as the 'minor' emanations of these same fascist desires (here, the violence of the Godly Coercion School). In conceiving of a particular institution as a standalone target, Holohan is unable to construct a powerful critique, side-stepping as he does the very culture that the institution in question expresses.

If the novel fails as an indictment, what remains? The Brothers, the pupils, the parents - caricatures, all - cannot themselves be engaging. Overall, then, the result is humdrum. Vaguely entertaining in a laborious way, THE BROTHERS' LOT otherwise has little to recommend it.

Dirty One
Dirty One
by Michael Graves
Edition: Paperback
Price: £10.24

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars New trajectories, 17 Sep 2011
This review is from: Dirty One (Paperback)
The inherent queerness of The Child is gay culture's secret shame. In its post-1970s scramble for assimilation, queer culture has collaborated in sustaining the last bastion of foetid hierarchical structure: the nuclear family. The child's queerness is locked away in the attic like a mad aunt, only to be suddenly born as the archetypal 'confused' seventeen-year-old high school senior whose mythical presence saturates coming-out novels. With DIRTY ONE, author Michael Graves joins the exalted rank of those (very) few writers who dare to offer an authentic voice to the queer child.

In this collection of standalone short stories, loosely based around the Larry Clark-esque 1980s post-industrial wasteland of suburban Leominster, the populating voices are anything but archetypes. In "Comb City", a Hefty Smurf provides the connection for 7-year-old Philip's need for intimacy; in "From Kissing", 6th grader Butch fears that he has contracted AIDS from his dalliance with Milo; in "Do It", 12-year-old Denise worries that her boyfriend seems to prefer intimacy with his teddy-bears; in "Dirty One", 12-year-old Noah shaves his pubic growth to maintain resemblance to his love, Ben...

DIRTY ONE features nine stories in all, each working to decompose the images of child and family that foster dominant cultural homogeneity. These are not coming-out stories, nor even coming-of-age narratives, since they operate from the understanding that queerness is a fluid state of affairs, rather than a stable identity or state of being. In this exhilarating, iconoclastic collection, Michael Graves's sparse, fearless, and unapologetic writing carves out a new direction for queer culture; unreliant on imagery of the past, the voices that unfold are of spectacular and haunting immanence. Highly recommended.

What I Did
What I Did
by Christopher Wakling
Edition: Paperback
Price: £11.20

1 of 13 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Banal, 6 Aug 2011
This review is from: What I Did (Paperback)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
A simple premise: a six year old, Billy, out with his father, runs into a busy road. His father pulls down his trousers and beats him. A woman who is passing-by attempts to intervene. Social Services become involved, and Billy's family's life faces upheaval.

This premise certainly had potential, invoking the oppressive and deceitful invocation of "protection" that has, since the 1970s, arisen as the rancid heart of every social policy 'initiative'. The battlefield laid out by WHAT I DID posits this notion of 'protection' as a struggle between the Nuclear Family on one side, the State on the other, with Billy as the putative subject. This is reinforced by the novel's choice of narrator: six-year-old Billy himself. Indeed, the most remarkable feature of the novel's format is Billy's relentless voice ("Have you ever put your finger in a plug? ... Can you ride a bicycle? ... Do you like soft-boiled eggs? I do.") - vaguely charming at first, though very quickly becoming tedious.

Unfortunately for WHAT I DID, this triangular presentation (family - child - State) underscores the failure of the novel to generate any new sensations or sensibilities. Over two centuries ago, the fledgling capitalist State and the nascent nuclear family carved a territory out of the body socius - this territory they named 'The Child'. The two parties divided up ownership of this territory between them, each exploiting it for their own purposes. Hence it becomes clear that 'protection' refers never to the putative subject (here, Billy), but only to securing the respective parties' vested interests.

Accordingly, any presentation of a 'struggle' between family and State (whether that be over sex education in schools, compulsory education, child labour laws or - as in the case of WHAT I DID, corporal punishment) is a false problematic, portraying only trite, and inevitable, territorial skirmishes at the borders of two controlling interests. Billy-as-narrator is consequently a hollow device. Freeing the potentiality of the forces long ago territorialised in 'The Child', and returning them, undividuated, to the full collective body of the socius whence they were mined, would in fact necessitate neutralising both State and Nuclear Family.

Sadly, therefore, with its limited grid of intelligibility, WHAT I DID can only paddle perfunctorily in the shallow waters at the edge of a lake, unaware of the ocean that lies outside its field of vision. As such, this novel unfortunately has nothing interesting or new to offer.

Double Bound
Double Bound
by Nick Nolan
Edition: Paperback
Price: £8.09

0 of 2 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Lightweight, 4 July 2011
This review is from: Double Bound (Paperback)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
It is awkward, writing a critical review of a novel that is bound to, because it was designed to, have populist appeal. The romantic-thriller is a popular genre precisely because it does not seek to challenge the reader. It operates as a comfortingly familiar extension of the fairytale, offering a mythical world in which there exists good and evil; the former is challenged by the latter, and the outcome is always already known. The characters are necessarily two-dimensional caricatures, typically with a tedious tendency toward moralizing.

Behold: the McNovel. Standardized ingredients offering the fleeting satisfaction of empty-calorie high-fat food. The homonormative novel is no different in this regard. Enter: DOUBLE BOUND. It falls, like its prequel STRINGS ATTACHED, squarely into this territory. Here, the 'good guys' from that prequel - Arthur, Jeremy and Carlo - are sent to Brazil by ruthless and wealthy Aunt Katharine, to oversee her investment in an island resort. The trio are inevitably put through various personal and physical challenges, including a kidnapping and the well-worn hurdle of a love triangle.

Again, if this genre of novel is popular, it is because it seeks not to provoke but to conform and repeat. As such there will be many prospective readers for whom DOUBLE BOUND will be a wonderful read - with all sincerity, if you are looking for familiar comfort-food, this novel will undoubtedly satisfy. For those yearning for something more from their reading experience, on the other hand, DOUBLE BOUND will feel bland, vapid, and wholly interchangeable with a thousand other novels. Horses for courses.

Brotherhood [DVD]
Brotherhood [DVD]
Dvd ~ David Dencik
Price: £6.99

11 of 14 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars "This is my life, my family and my friends", 24 Mar 2011
This review is from: Brotherhood [DVD] (DVD)
Resentful and bitter at having been passed over for promotion in the army, Lars (in his mid-30s) resigns his commission. He renews contact with some old friends who are involved with a proto-Nazi group, who oppose immigration in general, and Muslim presence in Denmark in particular. Initially, Lars resists involvement with the group, despising its typical thoughtless thuggery. Directionless, however, he soon becomes caught up in the sociability it offers.

Increasingly at odds with his parents, Lars takes up residence with another group member, Jimmy. Jimmy, also ex-army, and a few years Lars' senior, resents Lars - but part of this resentment is the basis of the courtship ritual that soon begins. The tension builds excruciatingly, as the two men are increasingly drawn to one another, yet constantly battle against the fascist ideology by which they have sworn to live.

BROTHERHOOD (Danish, with English subtitles) is a timely film, set against the backdrop of the insipid anti-immigration racism that is gaining alarming momentum throughout Western Europe. One of the film's key strengths is perhaps its invocation of a Lars who had no strong sensibilities in that direction at the outset, and for whom the patriot-nationalist-racist continuum was a far-off horizon. Its increasing immanence attests not to 'ideological beliefs', but to the collective intensities of community... the uniforms, the chanting, the speeches, the open homosociability.

From a technical perspective, the camera work is thoughtful and cohesive, working sympathetically with the strong musical score. If there is one notable issue, it is the lighting: much of the film is shot at night or in dark rooms, and visibility can seem a problem in places. This is a minor grievance, however, and overall BROTHERHOOD is certainly a compelling film; well-paced and brimming with palpable tension. Recommended.

Tiger, Tiger: A Memoir
Tiger, Tiger: A Memoir
by Margaux Fragoso
Edition: Paperback
Price: £6.89

8 of 22 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars Dull fiction, 14 Mar 2011
This review is from: Tiger, Tiger: A Memoir (Paperback)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Programme (What's this?)
Like all 'memoirs', TIGER, TIGER is necessarily a work of fiction. Unlike many memoirs, however, this one fails to engage the reader on any level. The (wholly-unreliable) narrator constructs seemingly-interminable narratives surrounding her affective connections with her immediate family and a character named 'Peter'. Sadly, the narrator is presented as a self-absorbed and extremely unlikeable persona, and is capable of imaging her lived experiences only through naïve formulae and trite cliché. Unfortunately, this intensely dull novel ultimately has nothing to offer.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11-19