This product was delivered quickly and is well made and protects my iPhone 4S well but the flap closure should be longer with a larger area of velco to secure the flap. With the phone inside the flap reaches about an inch down the front of the pouch and doesn't sit flat so can easily catch on clothing etc. If the flap was redesigned this would be just about perfect for its intended job and I would purchase it for future phones. If the manufacturers would like to alter the design and sent me a free item to evaluate I would heartily recommend this product!!!