Profile for A. Neubert > Reviews

Personal Profile

Content by A. Neubert
Top Reviewer Ranking: 432,156
Helpful Votes: 32

Learn more about Your Profile.

Reviews Written by
A. Neubert

Page: 1
Live At Knebworth 10th Anniversary Edition [Blu-ray] [2013] [Region Free]
Live At Knebworth 10th Anniversary Edition [Blu-ray] [2013] [Region Free]
Dvd ~ Robbie Williams
Price: 21.73

32 of 34 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Blu-ray Mastering went totally wrong!, 3 Aug 2013
The concert was recorded in european HD-standard 1080i50 and therefore released in 2003 on DVD with 50 frames per seconds in 576i50.

For the Blu-ray release 10 years after the concert though, something went seriously wrong:
The 1080i50 production was converted for no reason to NTSC standard 1080i59,97 and what's even worse: Using totally unprofessional processing.

The new videoframes of the target NTSC format have been generated by just mixing the nearby neighbouring frams of the recording format.
That results in pumping of the sharpness depending on the time-distance between original an newly generated frames.

Such conversions are necessary when live sports broadcasts from the US are aired in the UK, because TV-stations only use one fixed framerate depending on the country.
And: Even expensive hardware converter-boxes offer way better quality than the software that was used on this release.

For Blu-ray mastering though the conversion is totally pointless:
Every Blu-ray player can play both systems (PAL+NTSC)!

I've got the original DVD from 2003 and I've bought the Blu-ray to finally get the concert in HD-quality.
Due to the faulty video mastering, a lot of the fantastic original production quality has been spoiled.
While steady scenes are slightly oversharpened, scenes with movement and fine details (crowd, hair, ...) look strange.

The audio isn't too good eigther:
The drums could be more compact, guitars tend to be too loud and isolated, and the brilliant horn arrangements (KIDS!) sound horribly thin.
Expecially the baritone sax sounds like a kazoo!

Universal has delivered a poor job on this release!
Comment Comments (2) | Permalink | Most recent comment: Aug 24, 2013 12:17 PM BST

Page: 1