Profile for Stewart M > Reviews

Personal Profile

Content by Stewart M
Top Reviewer Ranking: 467
Helpful Votes: 1950

Learn more about Your Profile.

Reviews Written by
Stewart M (Victoria, Australia)
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)   

Show:  
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11-20
pixel
American Sniper [Movie Tie-in Edition]: The Autobiography of the Most Lethal Sniper in U.S. Military History
American Sniper [Movie Tie-in Edition]: The Autobiography of the Most Lethal Sniper in U.S. Military History
by Chris Kyle
Edition: Paperback
Price: £3.85

3.0 out of 5 stars Unpleasant., 26 Jan. 2015
This is book that I think demands to be viewed in two ways – firstly as a story about a person and secondly as a story about a person who we ‘asked’ to do things by his community.

In the first aspect it’s clear that the author is pretty unpleasant. His casual disregard for any human life that does not happen to be American is clear, as is his disregard for the person he claims to love.

The descriptions of his military training as a SEAL are par for the course in this kind of book – and in fact the author deliberately leaves out sections of the training, because he is sure his readers will already be familiar with these things.

However, once the author is deployed the story line becomes full of obvious racism and bigotry – the way in which he describes his ‘enemies’ does not show the attitudes of so called elite troops. I found these sections of the book hard to read.

The second aspect of the story, where the author is doing what he is trained to do, at the behest of a democracy (well sort of) are equally unsettling. His basic task is to kill and keep killing until the declared enemy have had enough and give up. (In many ways this seems to be an echo of the ‘kill ratio’ argument of the Vietnam War). If this is really what he was asked to do, do we really have the right to suggest that he should be a monk as well as a killer and to suffer agonies of guilt for doing what he has been asked to do?

I think it will become increasing hard to differentiate this book from the film it spawned – but they seem to be very difficult.

This is an ugly and difficult book. But I also think it is shockingly honest.

It is clearly a book that should be described as ‘informative’ rather than ‘entertaining’.

Nobody does well in this account of a modern war.
Comment Comment (1) | Permalink | Most recent comment: Jan 26, 2015 10:22 PM GMT


The Narrow Road to the Deep North
The Narrow Road to the Deep North
by Richard Flanagan
Edition: Hardcover
Price: £7.95

4.0 out of 5 stars An imperfect hero., 28 Dec. 2014
I think this book is likely to suffer because of two things – firstly in won the Booker Prize, and secondly the main thrust of the narrative - the treatment of POWs by the Japanese during WWII – is fairly familiar.

Its prize wining status would suggest that the book is truly remarkable, and this is a hard preconception for a book to carry. The truth of the matter is that the book was considered the best of the 2014 entrants, and I think this is a much better way to view it.

The second consideration – that the subject is well worn – may be true, but it does not mean that the book has nothing new to say.

The book centres around one major character, his loves and losses and his struggle to understand his place in the world. If ever there was a flawed hero, Dorrigo Evans is one.

But on many levels this also seems a very realist view – we seem to give people who have achieved what we believe we could not, super-human powers. The truth, and their motivations, may be more prosaic.

I was struck that the book did seem to turn around a number of coincidences that seem so unlikely that I had a hard job believing them. Some occur early and dominate the book, and others cast a new light on things that happened in the past. But when they occur, I could not help but think ‘really?’ I have not read many ‘generational’ novels, and maybe such things are typical in them, but just did not find some of the plot twist convincing.

Having said this, I found that many sections of the book – especially the scenes in the POW camps - griping, if unrelentingly grim. Equally I found the sections where people struggle with the morality of their actions far more convincing than the plot twists.

So, this is a good four-star book.

Imperfect? – certainly (but what is not?).
Self consciously clever? – a little.
Worth reading? – absolutely
Recommended? - yes.


Claxton: Field Notes from a Small Planet
Claxton: Field Notes from a Small Planet
by Mark Cocker
Edition: Hardcover
Price: £10.49

4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars A year in fast-forward, 14 Dec. 2014
In many ways this is a fairly conventional account of the turning of the years around the village of Calxton in the Yare valley in Norfolk. While there are a few side trips to other places, the focus of the book is the titular village.

Like many other ‘year in the life of…..’ books the daily accounts are drawn from more than one year, so while they are presented in calendar order, they are not truly sequential – I only mention this because some books seem not to be honest about this format – but this one is.

The daily entries are generally short – most are just a single page (more or less) of the book – and most end with a sort of philosophical musing which seeks to place the short piece in the wider context of the world. This is both the strength and weakness of the book: each piece of writing is self-contained, but each also becomes rather too predictable in tone.

I think this may be due to the way in which they were originally published – weekly or at least a few days apart. Reading them one after another compresses a week or a month into minutes and the pace (and predictability) seem too much.

Equally, I think that that the rapidity with which you can move through the book makes some of the recurring themes recur a little to often as well – the link between the soil and the rest of the world, the shape and effect of a passing peregrine and the sound of geese all occur regularly in the book.

All this being said, I really enjoyed the book and the writing is very evocative. Its clear from this and the authors other books that he has a great eye for detail.

So, would I recommend the book? Absolutely!

But I do suggest that you read it over a longer period of time than a few days – read a couple of days each day, so that the year in the book unfolds at a more realistic pace and I am sure you will enjoy it.


Storm
Storm
by Tim Minchin
Edition: Paperback
Price: £12.08

1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A Storming Book, 1 Dec. 2014
This review is from: Storm (Paperback)
This is a really interesting little book. And two words here are important – ‘interesting’ and ‘little’.

The book is ‘interesting’ because of what it seeks to explore – belief and rationalism, which are hardly the normal stuff of comedy. And the book is ‘little’, not because it is insignificant, but because if you just read the poem that is the core of the book, you will complete the book in 10 – 15 minutes.

If you are already aware of Tim Minchen’s work, this book will contain few surprises, but much delight. This beat poem, with its strange rhythms and off key rhymes, is an account of the kind of ‘rant’ that many of us may have wished to unleash when exposed to hocus-pocus and pseudo-science – in this case it happens at a dinner party where we meet an Australian called Storm.

Believers in auroras, spirit healing, the therapeutic value of crystals and (possibly above all else) homeopathy will find little joy within these pages.

This is a book for lovers of science, logic and evidence.

It’s a storming book!


1066: History in an Hour
1066: History in an Hour
Price: £0.99

0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The Year it all Changed, 5 Nov. 2014
It would not be hard to mount a case claiming that 1066 was one of the most important years in English history. It may well be one of those turning points in history the effects of which we are still living.

Language changed, law changed, landscape changed.

And for the most part, only one aspect of this year is remembered – the Battle of Hastings. 1066 was a far more complex year than that, and this book is a good introduction to the intricacies of that period. The other battles, the family infightings and politics are all introduced, and I suspect that for many people these aspects of 1066 may be new.

Of course the book is not comprehensive - that is not its aim. But it does show how close history came to having a very different pathway.

Recommended.


Waterloo-City, City-Waterloo: The Waterloo and City Line (Penguin Underground Lines)
Waterloo-City, City-Waterloo: The Waterloo and City Line (Penguin Underground Lines)
by Leanne Shapton
Edition: Paperback
Price: £4.76

2.0 out of 5 stars More of an idea than a book, 4 Nov. 2014
I struggled with this book – and in the end it defeated me.

While this book is part of a series of volumes about the London Underground, I really found to hard to connect this books with the specific line – the Waterloo and City Line – that the book is supposed to be about.

As far as I could tell the books was a series of disconnected conversations (presumably) lifted from commuters on the line in question. While this ‘stream of consciousness’ style may given some idea about the conservations that occur in trains in general, this book is supposed to be about some specific aspect of the Waterloo and City Line itself.

The book actual has two parts – which are intended to read from one end of the book or the other. One being the journey outward, the other, inward. I could detect no real difference between these two parts.

I think this is more of an idea than a complete book – “lets listen to conversations on an outbound and inbound train and just write them down”.

I really can’t recommend this book at all – I only read (most of) it because it was part of a boxed set.

There are much better books in this particular series, so in this case I think you should proceed with extreme caution.


The Riverbank
The Riverbank
by Professor Charles Darwin
Edition: Hardcover
Price: £11.35

4.0 out of 5 stars Darwin for children, 28 Oct. 2014
This review is from: The Riverbank (Hardcover)
This is a rather splendid children’s picture book based on the (reasonably) well-known final paragraphs of Darwin’s ‘On the Origin of Species’.

In many ways Darwin summarized much of his thinking about variation, natural selection and evolution in that paragraph – and this book highlights a number of aspects of his thought in pictures. Having said that, the nature of the language used by Darwin will need to be explained to children - so, talking about what this book means may be as important as reading it.

The pictures themselves sit at the boundary of ‘cartoon’ and ‘naturalistic’ drawing, and are at their best when they show the small creatures that dwell in the riverbank – Darwin’s entangled bank. The images are at their least good when they depict people – with the faces looking more than a little artificial.

As an antidote to talking mice and evil foxes this is a very good book – but I suspect it will appeal to more adults than children.

Still, a book designed for children, which starts them thinking about one of the most powerful and influential ideas anybody has ever had, cannot be a bad thing.

Recommended, but don’t expect it to become a bedtime staple.


Sprinter and Sprummer: Australia's Changing Seasons
Sprinter and Sprummer: Australia's Changing Seasons
Price: £13.66

4.0 out of 5 stars Slightly misleading sub-title, 23 Oct. 2014
This is an interesting, if slight misleadingly titled, book.

The basic idea behind the book is that the use of seasons based on the division of the year into four equally long seasons, all of which are named for the equivalent season in the Northern Hemisphere, is inappropriate for Australia (and many other parts of the world as well).

This seems to make sense from the very start of the book, and the author suggests a system of six seasons, with two new seasons - the Sprinter and Sprummer of the title - and amended dates for the other four. Generally, these new seasons as identified by the activity of plants, rather than the date on the calendar or the location of the earth on its journey around the Sun. Again, this seems to make sense - if you base the seasons on what is happening around you then the classification of the seasons may help you understand the world around you. (The converse of this is that using an externally imposed system of seasons does not help us really understand what is going on.)

Strangely, the author often uses introduced plants as part of his markers of seasonal change - which seems to be a step away from being in tune with the natural environment. Having said that, in some parts of Australia - heavily urbanised areas for example there may be little other vegetation to look at!

The book also has a slightly strange "feel" - the use of frequent sub-headings makes the book read a little like a textbook, but the relaxed and informal use of language in the text is not textbook-like at all. Equally, the lack of captions on the images in the book is a little strange. These are not "deal breakers" by any means, but I did find these aspects a little strange.

My contention that the book is misnamed comes from the sub-title of the book that is "Australia's Changing Seasons" - and while the impact of climate change on the dates of seasonal activity is examined in one chapter, a better sub-title for the book would have been "Changing Australia's Seasons".

An interesting read with relevance to more than just Australia.


Feral: Rewilding the Land, Sea and Human Life
Feral: Rewilding the Land, Sea and Human Life
by George Monbiot
Edition: Paperback
Price: £6.99

5.0 out of 5 stars A great place to start thinking, 20 Oct. 2014
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This is a really rather good book – not perfect, but one that makes you stop and think ‘do I agree with what I have just read?’

In reality this is almost two books rather than one – the first is about developing a greater connection between people and the land on which they live. This is ‘re-wilding people’. The second is about taking a less interventionist approach to wildlife management, by allowing nature a freer hand to build new ecosystems.

The first is a reasonably well-trodden path - and is based on the assumption that people and the land do better when they are connected. Connection. Interest. Care. Passion. And in the end, survival. This all seems to make sense.

The second theme of the book – actually re-wilding landscape – is probably a little more contentious. Especially as one of the key things that the author suggests in terms of re-wilding the landscape is the re-introduction of large predators – such as wolves – to some ecosystems. While any such introduction would clearly rely on human intervention in its early stages, the idea is to re-establish the kind of ecological processes that have been removed from many ecosystems by humans.

There is little doubt that conventional conservation management is not always successful – with large areas (the book really takes most examples from the UK) being maintained in some sort of agriculture dominated state – the classic example here being the UKs uplands which are often just sheep, deer or grouse maintained habitats, which lack the diversity they once had.

I think there needs to a well informed debate about how land is managed into the future – and this book is as good a place as any to start thinking about what this debate could mean or should include.

Highly recommended.


Drift: The Hammersmith and City Line (Penguin Underground Lines)
Drift: The Hammersmith and City Line (Penguin Underground Lines)
by Philippe Parreno
Edition: Paperback
Price: £4.85

3.0 out of 5 stars For completists only.., 13 Oct. 2014
This is a strange addition to the set of books published to celebrate the 150th anniversary of the London Underground.

In contrast to all the other books in the series this is a picture book, rather than one based on text. The pictures all seem to be pen and ink style images, and (as noted elsewhere) some don’t seem to conform to the high level of technical excellence often seen in art-based books.

But I think a criticism of the book for its lack of artistic merit rather misses the point – I think the aim of the book is to provide some record of the authors (?) journey along the Hammersmith and City Line.

My interpretation of the images suggests that the line runs from decay (mushrooms) to open space (planes and play), via some rather darker spaces (Ned Kelly looking people and protest)

This of course may be well off the mark!

Would I recommend this book to be read on its own? Well, probably not.

Would I recommend that you read (look at?) this book if you have read most of the other 150th books – well, yes I would; if only to provide an alternative version of what thoughts railway can generate.

So, probably not book for general consumption or train buffs – but certainly one for readers who like to complete all the parts of a series!


Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11-20