Profile for alaporta@vodafone.net > Reviews

Personal Profile

Content by alaporta@vodaf...
Top Reviewer Ranking: 5,257,235
Helpful Votes: 0

Learn more about Your Profile.

Reviews Written by
alaporta@vodafone.net (London, England)

Show:  
Page: 1
pixel
Excalibur: Restoration Bk. 3 (Star Trek: New Frontier)
Excalibur: Restoration Bk. 3 (Star Trek: New Frontier)
by Peter David
Edition: Hardcover

5.0 out of 5 stars Calhoun is Back!!, 14 Dec 2000
This much-awaited conclusion to the trilogy is as enthralling as the other New Frontier books published. The return of Mackenzie Calhoun (it had to be) was well constructed and in line with his character Peter David has created.
Whilst New Frontier readers expected Calhoun to bring action, the introduction of Elizabeth Shelby on her own ship with her own problems was a welcome addition. The only really disappointing part of the book is the way the previous book's cliffhanger was concluded. With the mastery shown by David in creating this series, I expected a much more involving conclusion to this confrontation, not an insert to clear up any questions. For passionate (as I am myself) New Frontier fans this will be a major down point to an otherwise excellent book.


Page: 1