IntroductionWhen it comes to learning languages, traditional methods are
unlikely to bear much fruit. There are only so many times you can practice
writing a letter or asking directions for a train which doesn't exist before
the exercise book or audio-tape method becomes tiring. It's therefore not
surprising the interactive CD-ROMs which have revolutionised the language
learning process have enjoyed such extraordinary success. These packages
include new technologies such as voice recognition software and interactive
games and dialogues, making software-based language learning both interesting
and easily accessible.
Whereas old-style language courses were often too rigid and
impersonal, these new packages not only make learning languages fun (something
it rarely was with a heavy old textbook) but also make the courses more
individual. For instance, it's now possible to measure your own pronunciation
against that of a native speaker, repeating it until it is accurate.
The new packages also focus on developing a fully rounded
mastery of the language, unlike more traditional methods which emphasised
reading and writing over communication. Multimedia technologies harness
speaking and listening skills to reading and writing, thereby covering the full
range of language learning capabilities. Now even such stalwarts of the old
school as
Berlitz and
Collins have introduced new
multimedia packages--which just goes to show that if you aren't learning
interactively, you're now at a big disadvantage.
Market LeadersThis is a very competitive market, and there is an
extraordinarily wide range of products on offer. Picking your way through them
can be a minefield, but with a bit of knowledge of the targets of each product,
you can narrow the choices down more effectively. Three of the best and most
popular courses are the Learning Company courses (the highly regarded
Learn to Speak range), the
A+ series and the Syracuse
Language packages (the
Smart Start Deluxe
range).
The
Learn to Speak courses come
with a full range of modern software, including voice recognition and
personalised study plans. They are among the most individual of the
courses--allowing you to progress at your own speed, showing or hiding
translations as you decide and focusing on the situations and themes that you
determine. These courses also come with a dictionary for the language in
question.
The
A+ series has some of the
same features as the Learning Company courses, such as voice recognition
software and the comparison of this to the voice of a native speaker. There
are, though, some interesting differences. The A+ series come with each course
divided into a series of lessons, each of which is introduced by a video tutor.
There is perhaps more of a traditional emphasis in A+ courses, including strong
development of the student's grammar along with features such as electronic
flashcards and writing tests to match your spelling with the correct
version.
Smart Start Deluxe courses
are superb, including study guidebooks as well as the voice recognition
technology of its competitors. They are perhaps best designed for those seeking
on-the-ground communication and comprehension, rather than syntactical
precision (although there are, of course, grammatical exercises). The courses
are designed so that you can have conversations with characters on screen, and
there is also a Web site with quizzes and interactive links. The only negative
point might be that some of the packages have a small language glossary.
There are numerous other courses which are worth looking at
before making your choice. The
Berlitz courses--while
perhaps not quite so flashy as either Learning Company or A+ courses--are
extremely professional. They also come with voice recognition software, and are
one of the clearest and most thorough at moving from stage to stage at a
sensible speed. Meanwhile, for maintaining the widest range of vocabulary and
for grasping the correct pronunciations,
Collins Intense Language Office
dictionaries--with their vast scope and impressively comprehensive
natures--cannot be beaten.
French
Experience from the BBC is another bestselling title--an
extremely comprehensive two-CD-ROM language learning course for beginners
neatly broken into sections and combining video and audio learning
techniques.
For Business People Both the A+ and Berlitz courses are probably the best all-round
bets for business people, perhaps in tandem with a
Collins Intense Language Office
Dictionary. These are courses which have the best structure in terms of
learning the formalities without which business transactions in many countries
can be a nightmare. The structure of the courses is clear, and the audio-visual
techniques will allow you to learn the linguistic formalities which accompany
business transactions in your target language. Although both courses come with
at least a 10,000-word strong dictionary (12,500 in Berlitz's case), it may
still be worth getting a Collins Intense Language Office Dictionary as a
supplement, since this comes with native speaker pronunciation of over 100,000
words, and is also very much tailored to each individual language and country.
For the serious business learner, or for someone trading in a highly specialist
field, this package will prove an invaluable addition to the A+ or Berlitz
courses.
Popular courses for business
people:
·A+ range of language
learning software
·Berlitz range of language
learning software
·Collins Intense Language
Office Dictionaries
For Travellers The Learning Company and Syracuse Language courses are perhaps
best for travellers. These are the courses which come with some of the most
developed interactive technologies, and, as a result, they are ideal for people
who are going to have to use a language on the ground in a wide range of
unpredictable situations. As well as being fun, though, they are of course well
structured and deal effectively with a wide range of grammatical themes and
situations. But it is their individuality and strong interactive elements which
really make them stand out for travellers needing to learn a foreign language.
Again, depending, on the seriousness of the level of study, some travellers
might want to supplement one of these courses with a Collins Intense Language
Office Dictionary.
Popular courses for
travellers:
·Learn to Speak range of
language learning software
·Smart Start Deluxe range
of language learning software
For Children and Younger
Learners Among the best courses for children and younger learners are
The Times
GCSE courses, designed specifically for students in the UK taking their
GCSE exams. These courses are fun, interactive and at the same time highly
effective in reinforcing and expanding the learner's knowledge of a language.
Each take the form of a mystery scenario: learners are enlisted to help catch
the criminals, and have to perform tasks or take part in games (all are
executed in the target language) in order to receive clues to help solve the
crime. What is most impressive about this course, though, is that the aim of
learning is not sacrificed to the fun--relevant dictionaries and glossaries are
available in each area, and the games really do address important areas of
grammar.
Unfortunately, some courses aimed at this age group are not so
effective at combining fun and learning: the
Multimedia series is a
case in point which, although claiming to be both fun and precise, doesn't
fully achieve both these goals.
Alternatively, you can introduce children to language learning
in a more subtle fashion. Tivola have a number of children's fun and learning
software titles that are educational in content, yet game and activity-based to
guarantee enjoyment.
Oscar Flies into the
Mountains is an interactive journey through nature, and the
CD-ROM can be played in English, French or German.
LeapPad
is a learning system allowing children to get to grips with reading without
even noticing the work. This software system combines a "magic" pen with an
interactive book designed to help children spell, follow a story and improve
their vocabulary and concentration, and provides an introduction to foreign
languages which involves choosing an everyday activity then choosing to hear
the words in French, Spanish, German or Japanese.
Choosing a Course Notwithstanding any of the above, it is important to consider
some of the following questions before deciding on a language learning
course.
·language specificity
: some
courses are better at focusing on particular linguistic catchment areas than
others. This is especially important in a language like Spanish, where there
are wide differences between the accents and vocabulary in Spain and Latin
America--most courses tend to be specific to Castillian Spanish, but, if
heading to Latin America, it makes sense to seek out a Latin American course.
The
Collins Talking
Spanish-English Dictionary is strong on differences between
Spain and the Americas.
·reason for use
: why are you
studying? This is a key question, and the answer (see the various suggestions
in the main article above) will help to guide you towards the course which is
best for you.
·multimedia features and extras
:
how tech-savvy are you? If you like a wide range of interactive features, then
one of the more advanced and hi-tech products is probably best for you; if such
things make you nervy, it may be best to opt for one of the more
straightforward packages.
·existing knowledge
: are you
completely new to the language, or do you have some previous knowledge?
Although most courses are tailored for beginners and upwards, some (such as the
Syracuse Language courses, which have 3 levels, or The Times
GCSE courses, which run entirely in Spanish) are more useful for those with
some sort of starting base--otherwise you may find that too many of the lessons
are just covering old ground.
Browse Languages &
Translation software
Got the travel bug?
There's more to explore in
Travel & Holiday
books.
Going places?
Our
travel software buying guide
will make sure you make all the right turns.
Need accessories?
Visit our
Computer Peripherals
shop.
Toby Green is the author of
Meeting the Invisible
ManandSaddled with
Darwin and regularly reviews CD-ROMs for
Amazon.co.uk
.