|
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Sound conclusion to "Book of Ond" trilogy, 5 April 2001
By A Customer
I was equally delighted and frustrated by this book, and indeed the whole Book of Ond trilogy.The main stregnth of this book is the wonderful cultivation of the central characters' personalities, and the interplay between them. The ongoing rivalry between Hal and Spar is mirrored superbly by the development of May as a central figure from her position of a fringe player in the preceeding Runespell trilogy, and her relationship with Brid. In this series Jane Welch has created some of the most memorable and likeable characters in recent fantasy fiction. Where I feel Ms. Welch fails to replicate the excellence of the Runespell trilogy is in the area of plot. Whilst Lord of Necrond and indeed the entire trilogy fulfills the essential criteria of all good fantasy series' I cannot help but feel that Ms. Welch has crammed too many events into this trilogy, whilst simultaneously failing to spend adequate time on most of them. There are several instances of events (both good and bad) which befall our intrepid characters and are resolved within a single chapter of the book. I would have enjoyed this book more if there had been fewer such events, but more time devoted to each. In this respect I prefer the works of such writers as Tad Williams, Terry Goodkind, Robert Jordan and J. V. Jones, who have perfected the use of periods of relative plot/character inactivity as counterpoint to their important plot events and discoveries. That said, Jane Welch does conclude the book very well and wraps up a number of themes which run throughout the trilogy, whilst leaving sufficient loose ends for possible future development.............. Overall, this book will delight Jane Welch's legions of devoted fans and will not disapoint any reader of fantasy fiction. However, to those who have not yet discovered Jane Welch, I would strongly recommend they read the superior Runespell trilogy.
|