Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
36 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Reviewing the Wii Limited Edition Bundle, 12 Sep 2009
Fun:5.0 out of 5 stars
There's lots of discussion about the game, but not very many people talking about the bundle. I wanted the LE bundle because of durability concerns about the original RB instruments, and because I'm a bit of a sad middle-aged Beatles fan.
As well as the game, the LE bundle includes:
-- the game. Important because the guitar controllers that are sold separately do not contain the game. But the LE bundle does.
-- the Hofner bass controller. This is gorgeous to look at, quite the most beautiful plastic game controller I've ever seen. It has two sets of buttons, and it needs them, because it's longer than average for a guitar controller so kids will need the upper fret controllers. From the front it looks amazingly like a real bass; looking down as you're playing you can see the button colours but they're almost invisible from the front. The pearl button on the third fret is indented so that you can feel where you are as you play too.
-- the Ludwig Beatles drum kit. The individual drums are damped, and I don't find this sounds loud when played. It's incredibly rock solid and heavy (it compares favourably in build quality with a £50 toy drum kit we bought our son a few years ago). The pedal has a metal footplate with a Beatles logo, and feels pretty solid to me but I am a rock band novice; I understand that traditionally in RB the pedal is the first thing to break. The drumsticks look like actual wooden drumsticks. We were all delighted by the little popup screen that imitates the bass drum head, with The Beatles on it. No functionality at all but we love it anyway.
In play, we've found that the wireless drums occasionally lose their sync, requiring a restart of the game. This is covered in the faqs and we haven't lost data, but it's a bit of a pain. Reconnecting by pressing the connection buttons never seems to work for us.
-- one mic, which is I think a standard rock band mic -- it is heavy and works pretty well. You need to eat the mic to get a good score, and I'm speaking as someone who has a strong, loud, singing voice.
-- one mic stand, which is very solidly built and great for singing. It's hard to drum and sing at the same time using this mic stand though (I mean, it's hard to drum and sing at the same time full stop! But it's difficult to find a position where you can get close enough to the mic).
-- eight postcards; they're quite pretty but I'll probably just use them as notecards.
-- set up information (just about ok) and a woefully inadequate manual. If you have never played a rhythm game then you'll probably need the RB support pages, which include lots of information that should have been packed in with the game.
Overall it's very good, and I think substantially better value than the 'Value' edition that features the original rock band instruments.
One note about the game; if you are the sort of person who likes to play a game through to the closing credits as fast as possible and then never pick it up again, then Beatles Rock Band is not for you; the skill required to get to see the closing animation is minimal and it only takes a few hours (most of the 45 songs are short). The real game comes in trying to five star every song, pick up accomplishments, play with friends or family, play all the different instruments and so on. And that's great fun.
|
|
|
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
John, Paul, George, Ring and You!, 9 Sep 2009
Fun:5.0 out of 5 stars
Surprisingly, it's been 24 years since The Beatles figured in a computer game. Other than McCartney's `Give my Regards to Broad Street', (`Band on the Run' appeared as the last song on `Guitar Heroes World Tour') and the Gary Marsh text adventure `Beatle Quest', both on Spectrum and Commodore, anything Beatles related has been missing from the software market (no doubt due to the legal minefield that is copyright). Now, however, with the keeper of the Holy Grail of music licensing finally relenting, we can be our favourite of the Fab Four. There's no point in explaining what this game is about, as anyone reading this will know, so let's look at what you get for your money.
Forty-five songs, with an additional 31 downloadable throughout the remainder of the year make up the game (there's actually 44 listed but one is a two song amalgamation from the `Love' CD). Amongst other things, when completing certain parts, prizes of unseen photos can be `won' as can the elusive `Christmas Album'. For the ears of the completists who must have everything, there's previously unissued studio chatter and snatches of instrumental music to be heard at various junctures. (I can imagine some buying this just for that.) One of the best options available is that of singing three part harmonies. Unsurprisingly, this has not been available on other `Rock Band' titles, but as The Beatles were fortunate enough to possess two of the all-time great singers and the vocal dexterity of the group was an important factor, it had to be included. This could be great fun on a Beatles Karaoke night.
One problem I can see is that many of the songs are less than three minutes in length, which may mean that some could complete the game sooner than anticipated. In addition, whilst the visuals are excellent, you will be concentrating too much on following the notes to watch - though you could always let it play on its own. However, the music is what The Beatles were about, and although there is no crossover between other `Rock Band' packages, this will introduce the group to many who are unaware of what the fuss was about. Conversely, as you won't be able to use any of the extra songs on other software, those who may want to try out being George cannot. Another failing in this and the others in the series is the absence of a piano. I mean, the keyboard is pretty funky in `Get Back' Maybe Harmonix, EA and anyone else involved could consider bringing one out as an add on instrument for future releases.
One change from the usual formula that keeps intact the aura that still surrounds the group is that you aren't booed if you go wrong, or cheered if you do well. That could never be included in anything Beatles related, so you'll merely get a song failed message and a chance to try again. In the studio sequences you'll hear one of them make a comment as to your playing (and how many hours of tape did someone listen to just to get these?). Don't expect everything from the canon to be made available; `Revolution 9' might prove a tad difficult to play and both `Good Night' and `Eleanor Rigby' make the instruments redundant, though the backward guitar parts of `Tomorrow Never Knows' could be an interesting exercise.
Undoubtedly destined to be the biggest seller in the franchise, my only gripe, and no doubt that of everyone who buys this, is the eye watering cost; with the other two guitars, it's £340 for the whole package. Though I'll still get the complete set, I'm still allowed to register my dissatisfaction. Yes, I know there's a stand-alone version that can be used with the Wii controller and other `Rock Band' instruments, but that somewhat defeats the object of playing along with The Beatles.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beatles Are Back, 10 Sep 2009
Fun:5.0 out of 5 stars
Lennon would have loved this. It's a full blown psychedelic dream boat of a game, the production levels is as high as The Fab Four circa 1969.
The Beatles, in their latest incarnation are beautifully animated and each song has its very own music video, all of which, in their precision and evocativeness, are a real treat. Expect deep gratification as you drum along to the big backbeat of Twist and Shout, or enjoy trying to match the harmonies with George and Paul on Here Comes The Sun: this is as close to being the fifth Beatle as you're ever going to get.
Unlike Guitar Hero games, the emphasis is very much on you playing WITH the band rather than instead of them. In other words, the original tracks will be right there for you to hear, as well as your voice. It works well and saves their exquisite back catalogue from being blasphemed by your mates' pained vocal cords and mal-coordinated strumming. Ultimately, this is a party game and the more the merrier, with up to 6 Beatles able to play.You don't need to buy another wii controller either, as the instruments act as separate controls
This reviewer really loves playing the guitar or drums at the same time as singing. You get a mic stand to encourage you to do this, it feels fantastic once you get the hang of it. You can play online, with friends or take the chronological story mode. Both are cool but the latter would probably be more for the fans. Which, let's face it, is most of us.
All you need is Beatles.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Work through the Story mode and unlock exclusive content
Even the likenesses have been authorised by the band
The gameplay works just the same as regular Rock Band
