Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
23 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A terrific final season, 30 Jun 2009
I've always found Stargate Atlantis a generally much more appealing show than its parent series SG-1, boasting a more interesting setting with less reliance on the military and an extremely likeable cast of characters with genuine chemistry. The fifth and, sadly, final season of Atlantis demonstrates all these qualities admirably, with a very consistent batch of episodes that include some of the finest the series has ever produced. If you've seen the previous four you're most definitely not going to want to miss out on this.
A bit lighter and with more variety after the darker, more involved tone of season four, the series starts out by resolving the explosive cliffhanger of 'The Last Man' and does away with Samantha Carter as the commander of Atlantis, replacing her with Robert Picardo's Richard Woolsey, an initially unpopular move that ended up being an enormously successful gambit. Picardo is a great actor, welcoming the opportunity to somewhat humanise the previously unlikeable and somewhat neurotic IOA man. While being something of a stickler for the rules, Woolsey soon realises that the situations that Atlantis has to deal with aren't as clear-cut as he expected, forcing him to make some difficult decisions. I'd say that Woolsey is without a doubt the best commander the series has seen, certainly better than Carter who spent much of her tenure looking a bit lost, and it's a shame that we only got one full season of him.
Elsewhere, the regulars are their usual loveable selves all of whom get a chance to shine over the season. Indeed, the always slightly bland Teyla gets her best showcase ever, channelling her darker side in the disturbing, political power play of 'The Queen'. While some fans seem to have taken great exception to Jewel Staite's character Dr Jennifer Keller, I must admit that I fail to really see any problem with her. That said it's still fantastic to see a few hugely welcome guest appearances from her much-loved predecessor Carson Beckett over the course of the season. The delightfully sinister and dryly amusing Wraith "Todd" pops up a lot too, enhancing every episode he appears in.
The episodes are generally pretty high quality, with some exceptional offerings to be had in the form of 'The Shrine' (quite possibly THE best episode of the entire series), 'First Contact'/'The Lost Tribe' (featuring a guest appearance from Daniel Jackson who gets to share plenty of witty banter with Rodney), 'The Prodigal' (Michael returns for a final reckoning with the Atlantis team), 'Vegas' (a thrilling alternate reality episode that good-naturedly spoofs the CSI franchise) and the series finale 'Enemy at the Gate', a jam-packed hour of television that provides a wonderful, visually-stunning ending to the series. There are also some interesting and very successful experiments, like the mini horror movie 'Whispers' and the earthbound environmental-themed comedy 'Brain Storm'.
There aren't any outright duds, although dull, clichéd body-swap caper 'Identity' comes dangerously close and 'Remnants' wastes some awfully good drama on a pretty poor twist from the very worst kind of Star Trek episodes. 'Tracker' and 'The Seed' are enjoyable but a bit by-the-numbers. 'Infection' is a fun offering, but it's the first real sign that the Wraith storyline is in need of being wrapped up as it brings nothing really new to the table. I would mention 'Inquisition', but that manages to rise above being something of a clip show thanks to some fantastic character moments.
A great season of a hugely entertaining series that still had plenty of life left in it. There are story threads set up here that were obviously meant to be explored further in a sixth season that ultimately never came, but should still get some pay-off in the forthcoming Atlantis movie. Hopefully we won't have too long to wait.
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An intelligent character driven science fiction show, 27 Aug 2009
As a serious Stargate fan from the very beginning it's hard to be objective when reviewing a season box set. I admittedly love Atlantis and am sad it finished at only 100 episodes (I use the world "only" in the context that SG-1 ran for 214 episodes, and not as any disrespect to fans of short lived series such as Firefly. 100 episodes is a lot and makes for much replay value).
What I will admit is that there were mistakes made by Atlantis in the past - killing Carson Beckett, poor use of the Aiden Ford character, repeated use of the Atlantis set in other contexts, beaming the crew out of danger at the last minute - and an ongoing problem (reminiscent of Star Trek: Voyager) of having advanced the technology level so much that it no longer makes any scientific sense. Season 5 goes a long way to rectify at least two of those points - Carson Beckett is back for no less than five episodes, and despite heavy use of the Wraith ship set, the stories are good and justify it. The characters are as well written as ever, but I really felt the writers stepped it up a notch this season.
Speaking of Star Trek: Voyager, the idea of bringing Robert Picardo back as Richard Woolsey and promoting him to the role of Commander was a stroke of genus. No disrespect to Commander Weir and Colonel Carter, but in Richard Woolsey, Stargate Atlantis had finally cast its ideal leader (and that's not a sexist comment - other reviewers on these pages may drool over Joe Flanigan but one of the reasons I love Stargate so much is an attraction to strong-minded, intelligent women). There are also a couple of deadpan in-jokes about his holographic Doctor character hidden in the dialogue, which are extremely funny when you spot them.
Despite the technology getting more and more advanced, there is less of a reliance on the technology itself selling the story. There is more focus on the characters than before and all the characters get at least one episode where they take centre stage in the story - for example, David Hewlett puts in an incredibly moving performance in The Shrine where McKay is struck down with a fast acting Pegasus equivalent of Alzheimer's. Very good use is made of the popular Wraith characters Michael and Todd, and the budding relationship between McKay and Keller is a refreshing antidote to some other sci-fi series where the awkward tech geek never gets the girl (Seamus Harper in Andromeda being a prime and excruciating example).
Oh, and thank you Atlantis for the episode Vegas - it finally gave me the push I needed to listen to Johnny Cash's music.
|
|
|
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
one gate closes..., 18 Jul 2009
i'm not kidding here, but i remember watching the original stargate movie with kurt russell and james spader in the cinema way back in 1994, and i remember thinking half way through this would make a good tv series! all they have to do is figure out that the stargate can go to other planets and there's your show! well, someone out there must have heard me as we now have not one, but two stargate series with a third on the way!
while not being quite as good as stargate sg1, atlantis is still a very enjoyable and fun show in it's own right. the stargate franchise is now the new star trek. there are some enjoyable episodes here, and even the slightly naff ones have something in them to keep you watching mainly thanks to the excellent cast. the final episode enemy at the gates is terrific, and the episode before that, which sees joe flannigann's john sheppard in an alternate reality as a cop in las vegas is good fun and also is a good spoof of c.s.i. this isn't quite the end for stargate though, as the next direct to dvd movie, stargate exctinction, will feature the atlantis crew, and we have a third series, stargate universe on the way which i can't wait for.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![Stargate Atlantis - Season 5 - Complete [DVD] [2009]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51I-abRWw8L._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Stargate Atlantis - Seasons 1-5 - Complete [DVD] [2009]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51cqX-rrRfL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Stargate Atlantis - Series 4 - Complete [DVD] [2007]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51EVorHirOL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Sanctuary Complete Season 1 [DVD] [2007]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51fmO3Q0yfL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Stargate SG-1 - Children Of The Gods [DVD] [1997]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51-MA93WvSL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Richard Dean Anderson
![Stargate Atlantis - Series 4 - Complete [DVD] [2007]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51EVorHirOL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Amanda Tapping
![Sanctuary Complete Season 1 [DVD] [2007]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51fmO3Q0yfL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Amanda Tapping
![Stargate Atlantis - Series 3 - Complete [DVD] [2006]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51rrINIxiAL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Joe Flanigan
![Battlestar Galactica - The Final Season [DVD] [2009] [2004]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51Fb03q3KZL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Edward James Olmos
