Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
26 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great for Pratchett fans - an excellent adaptation, 10 Nov 2008
I LOVE the Disk World series and was very much looking forward to this film. It's a great adaptation of the first two books AND there's an interview with Terry at the beginning, which is almost worth the price of the dvd on its own. The man is seriously funny.
I know that Terry endorsed the choice of David Jason as Rincewind, but I'm sorry, he's just not Rincewind. He gave it his best shot, and David is a national treasure and a great actor - but he just wasn't the best man for the job in this case.
Sean Astin did his best as Twoflower, the Tourist.
The Luggage was excellent, but didn't feature as much as I would have liked.
It was great to see Tim Curry brought out of seclusion to play Trymon, the baddie and all the other wizards were suitably kooky as well.
The Librarian/Orangutan was a leetle bit artificial ... it was clearly a man in a mon (oops!) ape suit, which was rather a shame, but you can't have everything, I guess, and maybe there wasn't an orangutan available for filming.
The scenery was great, the humour was there in abundance and I highly recommend this to all Pratchett fans.
|
|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
He's a hero, isn't he?, 16 Jan 2009
A live-action Terry Pratchett movie is either doomed to fail in every way, or succeed in practically everything.
And "The Colour of Magic," adapted from the first two novels in Pratchett's brilliant Discworld series, is more the former than the latter. This one is no "Hogather" -- it has rather slack direction at times -- but it preserves Pratchett's wry satirical sense of humour. And of course, it's all about a mercenary, cowardly failed wizard.
Rincewind (David Jason) is ejected from the Unseen University, on the very day that Twoflower (Sean Astin) arrives with his many-legged Luggage. He's come to the Disc... to "look at it." But after Rincewind tries to con Twoflower, the Patrician (Jeremy Irons) orders Rincewind to be the guide/bodyguard of the Disc's first ever tourist.
After a massive fire sweeps through the city, the two end up fleeing Ankh-Morpork and running into all sorts of weird things -- a very assertive magic sword, a floating island full of see-through dragons, a dramatic dragonlady in a leather bikini, astrozoologists trying to determine Great A'Tuin's gender, the aged Cohen the (retired) Barbarian, druids, and even getting thrown clear off the Disc in a strange spacecraft. And you thought YOU had problems.
Unfortunately the Unseen University is having troubles of its own -- the magical book Octavo is acting weird, and power-hungry Trymon (Tim Curry) is scheming against the Archchancellor. Even worse, a strange red star has appeared in the sky, and the world is facing destruction. The only thing that can save it is the spell in Rincewind's head.
Perhaps it's because it's based on the first, roughest Discworld books, but "Colour of Magic" is not quite as funny or tightly-written as its predecessor, "Hogather." The writing is not quite as complex or as witty, and the direction sometimes feels a bit slack (such as the bar fight scene, or Trymon skulking and schemind around the University).
But despite these drawbacks, "Colour of Magic" is still a vastly entertaining story -- it has a solid plotline and it chugs away nicely after a somewhat sluggish beginning, and blossoms into full-out complexity about halfway through. Once it gets underway it starts to resemble a road-trip through fantasy-land, with our quirky tourist and wizard bungling their way across the Disc.
Along the way there's some fun action (an upside-down duel), humorous dialogue ("You weren't born with a mysterious birthmark in the shape of a crown, were you?"), and a general air of tongue-in-cheekness. Best of all, it's a fantasy spoof -- Vadim Jean preserves Pratchett's clever satire aimed at the staples of your average fantasy: fantasy babes, prophecies, magic swords, retired barbarians, powerful artifacts, and even the idea of reality warping itself to save the "hero."
Jason is wonderfully snivelly and sour as Rincewind, a failed wizard who basically finds himself repeatedly swept up into bizarre, deadly circumstances even though he didn't want to be involved. Astin is even better as the hilariously oblivious Twoflower, who regards every disaster as yet another great adventure ("We're going to run out of world!" "I have to see that!").
And there's a talented supporting cast -- Curry chews the scenery with sneering aplomb, Karen David plays a humorously over-the-top dragon-lady, and Irons has a small but wonderful role as the chilly, efficient Vetinari. And of course, the brilliant Christopher Lee takes over as an increasingly disappointed Death.
"Colour of Magic" isn't as tightly directed as it could have been, but it still manages to be clever and quite amusing.
|
|
|
16 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An okay adaptation of a flawed book, 8 Nov 2008
This second live action adaptation of the Discworld brings the first and second books of the series, The Colour of Magic and The Light Fantastic, to life in a good if not great adaptation. While it is true that The Colour of Magic isn't as good as the previous adaptation of a Discworld book but then Hogfather was a far better book than either The Colour of Magic or The Light Fantastic so that is only too be expected.
In The Colour of Magic, Rincewind the Disc's worst wizard is forced into being the guide for the Disc's first tourist Twoflower as the naive traveller arrives in the great city of Ankh-Morpork. Complicating matters however are ambitious wizards, legendary heroes, a box with many legs and a living spellbook with its own plans.
In a similar manner to Hogfather, this adaptation of The Colour of Magic has an all-star cast with David Jason playing Rincewind and Twoflower being played by Sean Astin. In addition to this Tim Curry and Jeremy Irons both make an appearance as does the voice of Christopher Lee as Death (a role he also voiced in the animated adaptations of both Wyrd Sisters and Soul Music). This casting is mixed with Tim Curry and Jeremy Irons both great but I am still somewhat unconvinced by David Jason who although better than I thought he was going to be still doesn't seem right for the part.
The special effects used in this adaptation very considerably. The effects range from the spectacular such as those for the dragons and those at the finale through the somewhat mediocre Luggage to the truly disappointing such as when anyone is on a horse. As well as this I do feel that they could have done the Librarian better than they did. The writing and acting is also somewhat hit and miss but then so was the dialogue in the original books. There is also quite a bit left out of the adaptation, such as everything with the gods, and although this is somewhat disappointing it is nonetheless understandable as they were trying to cut two books down into three hours of screen time.
Overall this adaptation is good but is definitely something for fans more than casual viewers. Personally I would say that to fans this would probably be worth a low four but people who haven't read the book would probably only give it three stars at best.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![The Colour Of Magic [DVD] [2008]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/516MquU7T7L._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Hogfather [DVD] [2006]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51sE6SoTazL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Hogfather (2-Disc Edition) [2006] [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51HVG2rDcOL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Hogfather [DVD] [2006]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51sE6SoTazL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ David Jason
![Hogfather (2-Disc Edition) [2006] [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51HVG2rDcOL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ David Jason
![Hogfather Limited Edition [DVD] [2006]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/61NPR8cFgjL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ David Jason
by Terry Pratchett
