Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
44 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An extraordinary debut from a highly underrated composer, 22 Mar 2001
By A Customer
Anthony Phillips was one of Genesis founding members, their first guitarist, and one of the main responsible for the band's earlier sound. After Genesis second album "Trespass" (1970) Anthony Phillips left the band due to physical problems coming from stage fright. Having abandoned completely the musical scene, only in 1977 Phillips returned to studio to record his first solo album. This was mostly due to the insistence of his friend and also Genesis co-founder Mike Rutherford, with whom Phillips had a long lasting musical relationship started even before the Genesis days. Both guitarists' fond of 12-string, classical and other acoustic guitars, and their joy to explore different sound textures, originated "The Geese and The Ghost" an album that was, at some point, intended to be released as a duo effort, but that Rutherford, strongly committed with Genesis, preferred to leave as his friend's solo album. With Rutherford's strong presence, and Phil Collins voice in two songs, it's not odd to think of this album as a Genesis lost work, or to guess from it which way the Genesis sound would have evolved, had Phillips stayed in the band. The sound is predominated by acoustic guitars, and medieval atmospheres. Rutherford is most of the work, except the short overture "Wind - Tales", three beautiful and melancholic songs, two sung by Collins: "Which Way The Wind Blows" and "God If I Saw Her Now" (this one a duet with Viv McCauliffe), and the third "Collections" by Phillips himself; and the relaxing piano orientated coda "Sleepfall: The Geese Fly West". Two long and exquisite suites dominate the album. The first is "Henry: Portraits From Tudor Times", that in 6 parts sets the medieval historical context. Phillips and Rutherford explore the pastoral environment with the use of different guitar tonalities and a small orchestra, making it a highly enjoyable and surprising piece. The short "Chinese Mushroom Cloud" works as a prelude for the two-part suite "The Geese And The Ghost", where Phillips and Rutherford, in my opinion, reach the album's highest point. Again starting with acoustic guitar sounds, the composition evolves, through complex textures, towards a more classical progressive rock sound. A brilliant piece that showcases the two guitarist's abilities and compositional skills. The CD version of the album also includes the extra track "Master of Time" a nice demo song sung by Phillips, who despite having a rather limited voice manages not to lower the level of the remaining album. Overall a great album, relaxing, delicate and imaginative, starting a trend, some rock guitarists have, to explore renaissance sonorities and classical music influences. A spirit faithfully illustrated by the beautiful painting that is the album cover. Surely one of the best works in Anthony Phillips' long career. A good complement for those who enjoy the "Trespass" Genesis period, acoustic guitar in general, and the best way to start to discover a talented and underrated composer.
|
|
|
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Lost prog Rock Classic, 19 April 2004
Most people who know of Anthony Phillips will do so from his "Private Parts and Pieces" series and these albums are a fantastic collection of largely ambient instrumental pieces demonstrating AP's guitar/keyboard and piano prowess.To go back in time to his very first release (indeed Private Parts and Pieces 1 - probably the best in the series - was originally given away as a freebie with this album)is to see what might have been with AP having produced a real prog classic. In some ways it is closest in tone to Steve Hackett's Voyage of the Acolyte but is much more pastoral and gentle in tone. Featuring Phil Collins on drums and vocals and Mike Rutherford on some tracks this is almost a Genesis album that never was but I think there is sufficient distance from the Genesis back catalogue in approach for this to deserves its place as a classic in its own right. The stand out piece is arguably "Henry - Portraits from Tudor Times" - a multi-sectioned quasi classical piece in many ways with numerous changes in tone and texture. My favorites are, however, the two Phil Collins sung tracks - "God if I saw her now" and "Which way the wind blows", probably the two most wistful pieces Collins has ever sung and far more sincere than any of the later ballads he bacame famous for, excepting his first solo album. "Geese and the Ghost" and the closing track (on the original LP) "Sleepfall, The Geese Fly West" are lovely instrumentals and, again, match anything by Hackett or Genesis (and I regard myself of a major fan of both). This will be a real find for anyone who likes early Genesis and Steve Hackett and will act as a great (albeit not necessarily representative) introduction to Anthony Phillips.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Midsummer Knight's Tale, 23 Dec 2003
Well, let's cut to the chase and the bit you want to know - should I buy it? Yes. It's not for everyone but if early Genesis tickled your fancy, I think you'll like this. One of the things that attracted me to Genesis is the wonderful spangly chords (the musical sort rather than the 70s flares they wore) played out on majestic 12-string guitars (that we seldom see these days) and here they can be found too. All that delicate guitar work is here as you would expect from one of the founder members of Genesis a'la Trespass. Expect ethereal storylines that weave medieval/madrigal tapestries of yesteryear with all the benefits of modern instruments. I'd also recommend this album to Mike Oldfield fans, in that although I believe this album was written and recorded a few years earlier than Mikes (or at least the ideas for the songs were) it's very much in the same vein as Tubular Bells. A good album and a nice introduction to Anthony's work.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
~ Anthony Phillips
~ Steve Hackett
~ Mike Rutherford
~ Camel
~ Anthony Phillips
See all 12 tracks on this disc
With an Amazon.co.uk Gift Certificate, you can get them what they want (even if you don't know what that is). 
Make sure you always get what you want with an Amazon.co.uk 
Amazon Home