Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
31 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Modern Classic, 15 Sep 2007
The terrible, apparently ironic, English title and regular comparisons to Saving Private Ryan do this film no favours. Unlike the Spielberg film, Debouzzel's film engages the mind as well as the heart. It makes interesting and subtle points about the relationship between the coloniser and the colonised. The "message" that most people took from this film, including, famously, the French government, was that France had treated those who had fought for France disgracefully; indeed this film led to a change in government policy which is an outcome not many films achieve. For all its underlying seriousness this a compelling film to watch (more than once); several of the performances are outstanding and the cinematography is breathtaking. This is war film for even those who "don't like war films".
|
|
|
20 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Debt Owed, 3 Oct 2007
In French the word Indigènes, used as the original French title, means 'those who are at home in or belong to a country'. Rachid Bouchareb masterful film takes up this theme of the forgotten armies of indigenous Moroccans, Berbers, Algerians and others from the French colonies who fought bravely in France's wars. Here the film encapsulates all these forgotten days of glory in the acts of WWII. To this date this is a controversial issue in France, highlighted by the 'race' riots in Paris and Marseille over the last two years.
Rachid Bouchareb reminds us of the shame that the names of those who fought bravely for our collective freedom were all but erased from the official history books. As a direct result of Indigènes, African war veterans now finally had their war pensions reinstated.
The film tells a fictional story of four friends interwoven with those these men encounter as liberators and sometimes as lovers, in due course meeting the enemy not just in the opposing forces but also in the institutionalised discrimination and prejudices of the day. Excellent performances and acting by all characters makes this a gripping film to watch.
A highly recommendable work which should also be made available to schools. It shows that everyone's blood is red and that there is no difference in rank or origin when death calls.
I recommend this film together with another outstanding new war movie from Argentina 'Blessed by Fire'.
|
|
|
19 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
something of an ironic title, but a simply superb film, 8 Sep 2007
So World War 2, and everybody is fighting side by side against a common and hated enemy...nice idea, but it was never that way, and this film highlights this fact brilliantly. Four Algerian men, none of whom have ever set foot upon French soil, heed the call for troops to help liberate what to them is seen as the Motherland. Enlisting without any real thought about what they are doing this for apart from some barely realised idea of duty and honour, the men soon discover that racism exists, even in war, and even from your own side. Regarded with derision (the term "wogs" is used frequently throughout the film) by their own side and their own officers, the men are treated differently and although they fight the same fight, dodge the same bullets and shed the same blood, they are never really recognised for what they are...decent men fighting a horrible war for a country that unfortunately regards them as second class citizens.
The four main characters are superbly realised as living, breathing human beings with hopes and fears just like the rest of us. From Messaoud (Roschdy Zem), a man who falls in love with a beautiful French woman and wants nothing more than to return to her once the fighting is done, through Said (Jamel Debbouze), a dirt poor illiterate young man who joins up in a welter of patriotic fervour and soon discovers that it is not going to be glory after glory, Yassir (Samy Naceri), who has joined up for the money (whether paid or looted) and wants simply to protect his younger brother Larbi, to Abdelkader (Sami Bouajila) the corporal who leads the men and fights against the injustices he sees meted out on his men at every turn (whether it is being overlooked for deserved promotions or simply not getting the same food as the regular French soldiers), each one of them is allowed to grow as the film progresses, so that the viewer feels that they know each and every one of them (an idea Spielberg tried with some success in Saving Private Ryan, but with nothing like the effect here).
Directed by Rachid Bouchareb, this is a film that moves slowly and allows us to empathise and then sympathise with the characters. Whilst it contains some effective action set pieces, in particular a nerve shredding battle towards the end of the movie, this film is not about the violence of warfare, it deals with a very different theme, liberty and the right to be treated with respect. That this film served to force a change in French law, whereby the pension paid to colonial veterans were brought in line with those paid to regular French troops, and brought about similar changes in Holland, Italy and even Great Britain, just goes to show that cinema still has the power to change things for the better. This film is an honour and a privilege to watch, and a true testament to the bravery of men who fought for a country they didn't even know, but they did love.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|