Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Sassy and Superior Shostakovich: Grab It!, 8 Dec 2006
In 1930, shortly after Shostakovich returned to Soviet Russia from his first extended trip to Western Europe he composed the score for a ballet that came to be called 'The Golden Age' (or, as it is often translated into English, 'The Age of Gold'). During his sojourn he had been much influenced by his exposure to jazz, to the cabaret-style music of 1920s Berlin, and to the spirit of 'I don't care' encountered in jazz age Europe. The evening-long ballet was premiered in late 1930 in Leningrad and although it had a respectable run, it was not a great success largely because the choreography was, according to some, inept. The plot of the ballet was supposedly a satirical look at capitalist Europe vis-à-vis communist Russia. It depicts the triumphant exploits of a Soviet soccer team visiting an industrial exposition, 'The Golden Age of Industry', in a Western city called simply 'U-town.' The plot was also seen as a satire of the disarmament conference in Geneva. Certainly the music Shostakovich provided was satirical in the extreme. Interestingly the ballet has since been revived at least a couple of times with a completely different narrative (without the soccer team) and with different choreography.
Fortunately, the ballet music works perfectly well as a stand-alone work. The present recording presents the work in its final form as approved by Shostakovich; we are told (but I have not been able to verify this) that this is the first such complete recording. José Serebrier certainly has the measure of the music. He dives right in and gives us almost 2 1/2 hours of sparkling vintage Shostakovich. Most familiar, of course, is the 'Polka' (subtitled 'Once Upon a Time in Geneva') from Act III. This two minute piece is surely one of Shostakovich's most familiar works, having been transcribed for all manner of ensembles. It was the very first music I ever heard by Shostakovich, back in the 1940s, when the composer was so poorly known in the US that the musician who introduced me to it pronounced the composer's name as ShosTOCKovich. I remember being absolutely charmed, and a little puzzled, by the composer's wrong-note style and ebullient rhythms. Another excerpt from the ballet is the somewhat less familiar arrangement of Vincent Youman's 'Tea for Two' that Shostakovich called 'Tahiti Trot.'
Most of the music in the ballet goes at a fairly fast tempo and Serebrier makes the most of this, moving the many short individual pieces right along. The result of this is that the ballet comes across as cheeky, satirical, good-humored and endlessly inventive. Frankly the only passage that I thought fell a little flat (and I suspect this is more the fault of the composer than the present performance) is the ten-minute section in Act I called 'Dance of the Diva.' On the other hand, there are so many delightful sections that the diva's adagio is soon forgotten. For instance, there is 'The Supposed Terrorist', which features flexatone in an oily waltz, or 'The Football Match' which begins with a referee blowing an actual whistle and which depicts the Soviet team mopping up the playing field with their opponents, or the sly 'Everybody amuses oneself in one's own way' in Shostakovich's trademark side-slipping harmonies. The entire Scene 5 of Act III, called 'Music Hall Divertissement' (and which contains the 'Polka' as well as a Tap-Dance and a Tango, is too delicious for words. The ballet ends with the Soviet system triumphing over that of Western capitalism, but one can hear in the orchestra that the triumph is overtinged with bombast and wishful thinking.
Serebrier and the Royal Scottish National Orchestra cannot be praised highly enough. This is a superior performance with vitality and just the right touch of sly humor. They are given lifelike sound by producer Tim Oldham and engineer Phil Rowlands; . I was also delighted to find the names of all the RSNO players listed in the CD's booklet; they deserve the recognition.
This is definitely a set to grab.
Scott Morrison
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent recording of classic but forgotten ballet, 3 Aug 2007
Shostakovich composed three full length ballets, though the third (The Limpid Stream) utilised a significant amount of music from The Bolt...
The Golden Age is the finest of the three scores and, with its parodies, theatricality and youthful energy, is one of the 20th Century's most enjoyable full length ballets. If you don't already own Rozhdestvensky's recording of the score for Chandos, then is probably the one to go for.
If you do, then it's debatable.
Billed as the first 'complete' recording, the 'extras' over the earlier recording mostly consist of a few extra repeats that don't really add anything significant... It does, however, take it's titles from the original Leningrad performance... Time wise, it's 143 minutes against Rozhdestvensky's 133...
The playing on the Naxos version however tends to be slightly tighter and more theatrical than the earlier recording. It highlights the parodistic elements of the music that little bit better and has a greater sense of youthful exuberance... On the other hand the older version has a more biting sense of sarcasm underpinned by a touch of bitterness and maybe a better sense of the overall architecture... But the difference between the two is not great on any count... Both have good booklet notes and both are well recorded.
Neither set is likely to disappoint, though the Naxos version has a considerable price advantage...
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic value, 19 Mar 2009
The other reviewers here say it all really - I'd just like to add that the quality of the whole production is fabulous. Fully cued notes, an orchestra sounding as if it's got the LSO in its sights (i.e. brilliance of sound, precision of ensemble, bite and glitter), a conductor who's inspired, magnificently recorded with depth and a huge dynamic range. And then you notice the price. How does Naxos do it?
|
|
|
|
~ Adam Myrczek
![Shostakovich: Odna (Alone) [Silent Film Score]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/61693DYKigL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
~ Dmitry Shostakovich
~ Dmitry Shostakovich
~ Dmitry Yablonsky
