Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Could do better, 7 Dec 2006
Years, decades ago I bought a recording of Sibelius' 5th Symphony conducted by Serge Koussevitsky. On the other side was the 3rd Symphony of Roy Harris, a composer I'd never even heard of before. The recording was crude by today's standards, but the performance was electrifying, and I soon fell in love with this music. Later I was privileged to hear a live performance conducted by Leonard Bernstein, and this expanded my appreciation even more. The old vinyl recording is long gone, and I thought I'd like to hear the 3rd Symphony again, so I bought this one. Perhaps I'd been spoiled, but the recording by Marin Alsop and the Colorado Symphony doesn't quite do it for me. I don't know whether the problem is with the performance or the recording. I'm no musician, and my ability to express myself in technical musical language is poor, but here goes.... This is one of the greatest American symphonies. In less than twenty minutes it can take you to vast plains, big skies and endless snow-capped peaks. It should be bursting with self-confidence, every instrument clear and vying for our attention. This offering seems a little, well.... muddy. Given the budget price of this CD, perhaps I'm being a little harsh on it. It's enjoyable enough, but if your a fan of this music you might want to splash out on one of the other offerings available.
My enjoyment of the 'Folk Song Symphony' wasn't affected by my having heard it before, and I really did enjoy it. Musically it is no match for the 3rd Symphony (in spite of being over twice as long), but perhaps it will grow on me. The singing by the Colorado Symphony Chorus is vigorous, with the words crystal clear. The tunes are all familiar and accessible.
This is a generally good CD, and good value for money, but merits only three stars because of the somewhat lacklustre rendition of one of my favourite symphonies.
|
|
|
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, 2 Jan 2008
Harris's Third is a glorious work, suggesting vast open spaces and a typically pioneering American spirit. It should soar (as it does in Bernstein's version, once coupled with an equally noble Copland Third). This Naxos performance is a let down, however. It's all too leaden and earth-bound; nothing soars and the recording quality is well below this company's normally high standards. The Colorado orchestra sounds second rate and Alsop is merely routine. It's a great pity because I had high hopes, especially given the opportunity to hear an unfamiliar Harris symphony, the 4th, which is twice as long as the great 3rd. Twice as long and half as inspired, as it turns out. Seek out Bernstein for the real thing.
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
A good recording of a fabulous symphony, 2 Oct 2009
This is the first Roy Harris work I've heard. Symphony #3 is simply gorgeous. It's practically the only thing I've listened to for the last month. There are suggestions that this is not a great performance, but having just heard Bernstein's version, I have to disagree. Bernstein certainly milks it more, it's more romantic and he draws some lovely sounds from the orchestra, but there are many sections in this Naxos recording that I far prefer. I like the calm, refined sound in the Naxos. The shimmering violins are delicious in the Naxos and all but drowned out in Bernstein. While I see what he was getting at, the drums towards the end of the Bernstein version are just not visceral enough. But they're fabulous in the Naxos version. On the other hand there are many underplayed aspects of the orchestration in the Naxos version, and its wonderful to be able to hear these parts properly in Bernstein. My point is that this is a good version that's worth buying, particularly if you haven't heard this wonderful symphony before.
The folk song symphony is amusing. It reminds me of Copland's old american songs that I used to love many moons ago. It's more sophisticated and interesting than Copland's songs, but I prefer solo to massed voices.
|
|
|
|
~ William Schuman
~ Roy Harris
~ William Schuman
