Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Donald Fagen finds his bad self...and does just fine, 25 Mar 2006
A state of uncontrolled excitement came over me when I discovered Donald Fagen was releasing a new solo album - this great man's music has given me unparalleled enjoyment over the years. With 'Morph the Cat', Fagen has again crafted an absolute masterpiece of songwriting, musicianship and groove - entities that seem to have become conspicuously absent in the majority of popular music. The advice from the ghost of Ray Charles appears to have been taken literally by Fagen - "Don don't despair, take some some time, just find your bad self you're gonna do just fine" - well it's been 13 years since Kamakiriad, he's certainly found his "bad self" and the music is pure joy. As with all the classic Steely Dan albums and The Nightfly, there seems little point in highlighting "stand-out" songs, as with each listening, every track becomes a favourite. The musical nuances are gradually revealed, the subtle irony in the lyrics starts to fit together, the groove becomes thicker than ever, and another piece in the complex jigsaw of the Steely Dan character (and concept) fits into place. Where to start? Well firstly this album SOUNDS so fantastically gorgeous it's nearly impossible to switch it off. Elliot Scheiner has replicated the lovely 'live' feeling of Everything Must Go - Fagen's vocals are fantastically well-recorded: punchy and direct on Brite Nitegown, soothing and soulful on What I Do. The assertive and soulful tone of Freddie Washington's bass underpins the whole album - how wrong I was when I thought Tom Barney was the only man for the modern-day Dan. The music is full of challenging harmonic changes (check out the bridge on Brite Nitegown...oh my god!), carefully crafted melody (The Great Pagoda of Funn) and subtle counter-melody in the horn arrangements. For me, one of the most beautiful moments comes in 'What I Do' with the entrance of the backing vocals in the closing moments of the song - Brother Ray would be proud! As ever, Fagen provides character analysis like nothing else - the tragic suicidality of Mona, the perverse infatuation on Security Joan, the contemporary paranoia in Mary Shut the Garden Door, and perhaps a love song in the Great Pagoda of Funn? I like to think so. Superlatives aside for a moment, if I had to make a criticism it would be in the tenor sax department - for his angular qualities and beefy sound, Walt Weiskopf is great, but sorry Don, I'd much rather have the complex and swinging post-bop of the mighty Chris Potter. Becker and Fagen believe Keith Carlock is "destined to be one of the greats", and let's face it - they'd know. The Steely Dan drummer's chair has been occupied by a veritable Who's Who of modern drumming (Purdie, Porcaro, Gadd, Lawson, Chambers, Erskine, Colaiuta), and to this album, Carlock brings class and versatility. The rhythm section works incredibly well, and adding in Jon Herrington on guitar (the modern-day Larry Carlton?) makes for a tight ensemble. As for 'Phonus Quaver' on vibes, I'm inclined to think this particular character may be another figment of Fagen's imagination...! There is music in this album that I will continue to discover for many years, and I find it a privilege to be around at a time where Steely Dan are having such a fertile period. So my advice - buy, borrow or steal this fantastic music from somewhere, you won't regret it!
|
|
|
23 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Brilliant, but fallible, 21 Mar 2006
Having listened to Donald Fagen's new album only a few times, owing to work commitments, my comments are still provisional and may well change as this is one of those Steely Dan/Fagen albums that takes time to acclimatise oneself to and I may well end up loving this one as much as the others. As of now, however, I have slight reservations. The band's last release "Everything must go" was, by comparison, very accessible, with lots of strong melodic hooks and relatively transparent arrangements. This one is more like "Two against nature", in that some of the tracks are accessible (such as "H Gang and "Security Joan"), whilst others contain complex chord sequences and unexpected melodic twists that are challenging, to say the least, on a first listen ("Pagoda of Funn" being the prime example of this). Interestingly, from the reviews posted here and the Steely Dan chat rooms, it would seem that two very distinct camps are forming within the Steely Dan fan base. The first camp loves the strong melodies and quirky arrangements of the early Dan. These fans tend to like "Everything must go", and are inclined to be somewhat dismissive of the latest effort. The second camp, which is waxing lyrical about this record, is the portion of the fan base that liked the more complex, multi-layered arrangements of "Two versus nature". If you're in the latter camp you will love this album, as it is all of a piece with TvN. I'm pretty fanatical about all Steely Dan's music, but I have to admit that I'm slightly uncertain about "Morph the Cat". I can see why it is dividing opinion, but I don't understand some of the more extreme comments posted here. There are plenty of strong melodies here, so the view expressed by some reviews that Fagen has thrown melody out of the window in favour of grooves is far from the mark. On the other hand, however, I don't think this is Fagen's best work since the Aja era. Compared with "Aja" and "Gaucho", there's less rhythmic variety here, and there is a sense of urgency about much of the music which means that the overall sound is less spacious or measured than on the classic Dan albums of the 1970s. It's very difficult, for example, to imagine either Fagen or Steely Dan opening an album now with a slow paced ballad such as "Babylon Sisters". Instead, the emphasis here is on giving every track a strong R&B groove. This has always been a crucial element of the Dan sound, but here it is ubiquitous and at times it contributes to a sense that the music lacks real surprise (which isn't really true as there are plenty of unexpected twists in the arrangements and instrumental solos). On the first few listens also, I didn't hear anything as spine-chillingly brilliant as "Jack of Speed" from TvN or "Godwacker". Again, this may change as I acclimatise myself to the more difficult tracks. If you've enjoyed Steely Dan in the past, you should definitely buy this album as you will find much to enjoy. But claims that it is the equal of "Aja" and "Gaucho" are exaggerated.
|
|
|
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Steely Dan in all but name?, 24 April 2006
This is quite simply a great album. If you don't know Donald Fagen or Steely Dan, and some people don't except through hearing their music sampled, then the best description is that it's adult pop with slightly world weary lyrics mixed in with Jazz riffs and techniques and this is one of the best examples of that style of music. It's not Jazz fusion, although it bears some resemblance, it's not crass easy listening, although it'll probably be played on "smooth" radio stations, it's something quite unique.
More realistically if you do know Steely Dan and Fagen then all I can say is that not since Aja or Gaucho have either Becker or Fagen produced anything which felt like a natural successor to the Steely Dan albums I remember playing. Well this is it, as another reviewer has written this could sit well alongside Aja or Gaucho, updated yes, written for the noughties yes, but unmistakeably a return to the slightly "edgier" chords (Yes the mu major chord is in there!) that Steely Dan fans like so much. I am in fact surprised that this album is from Fagen, Steely Dan's Two Against Nature and Everything Must Go, enjoyable though they were, made me feel that they had departed in a direction taken by Fagen in Nightfly and Kamakiriad, hopefully this album shows he still enjoys the style and sounds he and Becker used to produce. Home at last!
If you're not familiar with Steely Dan and are thinking of buying this because you liked Nightfly and Kamakiriad then be prepared for a difference. The quality is as good, the melodies are as catchy as ever and the wit and adult cynicism are just as evident. You will hear vague reprises from both but this is fundamentally in a different style. Buy it anyway!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
With an Amazon.co.uk Gift Certificate, you can get them what they want (even if you don't know what that is). 
Amazon Home