Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
34 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
don't waste time, watch "Jacob's Ladder" instead, 7 Jun 2007
Another genre-free movie, although inappropriately labeled as "thriller". Actually neither a thriller nor a horror, this is an example of sci-fi/drama subgenre just like "Memento", "Donnie Darko", "Jacob's Ladder", "The Machinist" and "The Butterfly Effect". But I must say that all these movies surpass "The Jacket" on every aspect.
The movie awkwardly blends life, death, time-traveling, shellshock, amnesia, delusion, mystery, romance and medical malpractice into a messy HODGEPODGE of ABSURDITY.
Anyone who gets a bizzare enjoyment from movies featuring HELPLESS VICTIM types with multitudes of giant plot holes and unexplained points will find an EXTRAVAGANZA of OBSCURITY and DISINTEGRITY here. Be prepared for haunting questions to beat your brains out: who's Jack; does he have a background; where is his family; does he have any friends; what's the role of his wartime past with the story except for amnesia caused by a bullet wound; while doped and strapped in a urine-stained strait-jacket, how a morgue drawer gets him travel to the future; is there some kind of magic carpet laid in it; what happened to veteran benefits ????????
The plot, embellished with sudden flashbacks & trips back and forth in time, seems to be a groovy idea, but the starkness of presentation makes for difficulty in following the story. Non-linear, fragmented storytelling in a movie is not a cinch, but it is an art (please watch Adrian Lyne's "Jacob's Ladder" and Christopher Nolan's "The Prestige", you will understand what I mean). If you do not do it properly assuring the coherence and integrity, you run the risk of losing your audience. I think "The Jacket" suffers from this kinda clumsiness.
On the positive side, the film's energy comes from Adrian Brody, playing the mentally incompetent, doped and haunted victim outstandingly. His best performance since "The Pianist". For sake of good cinematography and his appearance, I'm giving 2 stars.
|
|
|
20 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Long live the Organization for the Organized!, 6 Aug 2005
Here lately, the best way to find the boldest, darkest, most intellectually challenging films is to follow Jennifer Jason Leigh. Having watched The Machinist and The Jacket back to back, I feel a whole lot better about the future of motion pictures than I used to. There are actually scriptwriters and directors out there that are almost as dark and twisted as I am. Of course, The Jacket is primarily a showpiece for Adrien Brody, who gives a marvelous, haunting performance as Jack Starks, an ill-fated man who comes to know the past through the future - it's rather complicated (but it all makes sense in the end).Starks' problems begin when a little Iraqi kid plugs him in the head as his unit is trying to control a crowd during a combat mission in the Gulf War. He is left for dead and may in fact have died (but I don't want to get into a tricky metaphysical discussion on this point). Then, it's a year later and we see Jack walk down a wintry road and help a woman and daughter get their car started - a seemingly innocuous event but one of great importance in this story. Then Jack bums a ride with a stranger, the car gets pulled over by a policeman, and the next thing Jack knows, he's on trial for killing a cop. No one believes his story, much of which he doesn't remember anyway, and there's no denying the fact that he suffered a serious head injury in the war, so he ends up being confined in a mental institution for the criminally insane. There are definitely some insane people at the institution - unfortunately, some of them are on the staff. I'm still trying to figure out who told Kris Kristofferson he could act, but he shows up here as Dr. Mengel- uh, I mean Dr. Becker. His idea of treatment is shooting Jack up with some kind of hallucinatory drug, confining him in a straitjacket (you didn't think the title referred to a Members Only jacket, did you?), and shutting him up in a morgue drawer for hours on end. As a claustrophobic, that gives me all kinds of heebie jeebies, let me tell you. The thing is, though, that Jack starts seeing things while he's stuck in there - fragmented memories come at him a mile a minute, and in time he begins to see the future. He meets up with the little girl (Jackie) he helped earlier in the film (who grew up quite nicely into Keira Knightley) - only it's 2007, which is fifteen years in Jack's future. Actually, you can't really say it's Jack's future because he finds out that he died (or will die) on New Year's Day of 1993. Finding out you're dead is a bit of a shock, of course, so he tries to find out exactly how he died - his only hope to learn the truth is his link to 2007 and Jackie - and he can only see that future world while he is in the jacket and in that dark place. Jennifer Jason Leigh plays a less evil doctor in the institution who comes to share a special bond with Jack (one she is reluctant to accept at first). Hey, it's not easy for a guy in a mental institution to convince one of his doctors that he is seeing the future. Things get rather complicated, as you might imagine, but the movie handles the time issue wonderfully, and the whole movie really does make perfect sense. Maybe they stretch things a tad at the very end, but it's not a problem. The Jacket isn't for everyone; it's too dark and mysterious to satisfy those looking for pure entertainment. For the serious-minded viewer who loves dark sojourns into the depths of human thought and possibilities, however, The Jacket is a movie you'll be telling all of your like-minded friends about.
|
|
|
10 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Jacket, 25 Sep 2005
In an explosive and thrilling opening "The Jacket" introduces us to the tragic figure of Sgt Jack Starks a US Soldier serving in the first Gulf war. In an attack on a village he offers the hand of friendship to a small boy only to have the boy pull a pistol on him and shoot Jack in the head. Against the predictions of the military medial staff Jack survives although we suspect untold damage may have been done.A year later Jack it hitching through the snow covered Vermont countryside. He comes across a stranded vehicle and the stranded figures of a young girl and her mother. The girl, Jackie, asks Jack if he can help them out whilst her mother is seemingly incapacitated either on drink or drugs. After fixing the car Jack is picked up by a lone driver who agrees to take Jack as far as the Canadian border. The two chaps don't make it that far however as they are pulled over by a highway patrol vehicle. In a flash of scenes we discover that the cop that pulled them over has been killed and Jack is facing a prison sentence unless the unsettled appearance of Jack's mind can convince the jury that he belongs in a secure mental hospital rather than a prison. Jack, who can remember nothing of the incident is eventually committed to a secure unit and begins a regime of sever and awful treatments. The doctor in charge, Dr Thomas Becker has devised a method of strapping his patients into straight jackets, drugging them and then placing them into a mortuary body container for hours on end. Jack is understandably scared stiff by the treatment and rebels at every opportunity and when he starts to hallucinate inside the chamber things start to get worse. In one hallucination he is transported 15 years into the future to the year 2007 where he meets the grown up version of the girl he rescued at the roadside all those years ago. When he's convinced Jackie he is who he says he is, things turn even more frightening when Jackie reveals that the "real" Jack has died on a date that means Jack has only 4 days to live. In a desperate effort to discover what has happened to himself Jack even contrives situations to be placed into the jacket so he can go into the future, meet Jackie and continue their investigations. Films that have featured this warping of time have come and gone before and this film is as intriguing as the rest of them. Where this one differs is the bleakness of the situation of the time traveller and the viewer really pities the disturbed Jack as he tried to make sense of what is happening. This pathetic character is excellently played by Adrien Brody and his mournful face is really suited to the role. Keira Knightley, Jackie, is likewise superb and the couple generate a great relationship. There's also good support from Jennifer Jason Leigh as the more kindly Dr Lorenson and even Kris Kristofferson weighs in with a decent effort as Dr Becker. I do feel though that "The Jacket" is one of those films that you watch for the first time and are blown away by it, but when you either watch it again or analyse the content the shine does dull slightly. For example, there are three manipulations of time in the film and only one of them actually "works". See if you can follow this, Jack and Jackie learn in the future that Dr Lorenson used an electronic shock treatment to cure a young patient, so Jack goes back in time and suggests the treatment to Dr Lorenson. She tries it and hey presto it works, but who actually thought of it? Nobody, so really the suggestion of the treatment can have never been there to suggest, if you see what I mean. Likewise the story around Dr Becker was a little open ended, and I'm not sure it served the story at all. The Film is good, don't get me wrong, it's very entertaining and even though some of the scenes are particularly harrowing the story does have a certain feel good factor about it which doesn't make it too grim.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|