Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
87 of 87 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Palin's Peak Practices, 24 Nov 2004
If you've been following Michael Palin's Himalayan excursions on the television, then you'll know almost exactly what you're getting here. If you haven't, but have been a spectator to some of Palin's other epic voyages, you may find that his approach to the Himalayas is a little less frenetic than, say his round the world trips. Given the dominance of the mountain range and the lack of oxygen, a slightly more laid back approach is understandable.Michael Palin does what he always does - he acts like a thoroughly decent human being, good humoured, good natured, absorbed by the people and country around him. In an era where holidaying has become an excuse for booze, sex, and coarse behaviour, regimented by airlines, tour operators, and the lure of grotesque theme parks, Palin again demonstrates that travel and adventure can be a gentlemanly, gentle act. He conveys a polite humanity and sense of wonder, proving that you can travel the world without glossy brochures. For most people, simply being there might be excitement enough, but Palin finds mini adventuresa plenty ... with local herdsmen, school kids, or simply sitting on a train. The landscape dominates the whole trip. It is the ultimate landscape, the roof of the world, but it's a landscape wounded by conflict. Palin counterbalances the warfare by interviewing the Dali Lama. He doesn't take sides, he doesn't judge, but you get a sense of his exasperation - surely peace is easier that war? Palin clowns, he observes, he listens, he describes. The camera work picks out the visual wonders of the land. It's the sort of production which makes your mouth water and your feet start to itch, the sort of production which has you pouring over maps and deciding you won't be going to Belgium for your holidays this year. Beautifully shot and produced, Palin his usual charming self - this is a delight from start to finish. It's stimulating, it's entertaining, and it's excellent value with three discs giving you the television series plus some entertaining extras.
|
|
|
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The high point of Michael Palin's career?, 2 Jun 2006
Actually, I think I liked the first three of Michael Palin's travelogues ("Around the World in 80 Days", "Pole to Pole" and "Full Circle") better than the three that follow ("Hemingway Adventure", "Sahara" and "Himalaya"). So from that point of view it's not correct to call "Himalaya" the high point of Michael Palin's career.
The big difference is that each of the first three series was documenting a trip made by Michael Palin, and the trip itself was the central element that provided a focal point for the TV series.
In the last three series, and especially in "Himalaya", one gets the feeling that the traveling was secondary, and that the purpose of the whole exercise was primarily to find places and people and events that would make "good TV".
"Himalaya" was, of course, a fantastic trip, and the TV series that covers it is very interesting. Many countries around the Himalayan Mountains were visited, some of them well off the tourist track and some of them with security problems such that the team needed armed guards. Specifically, Pakistan, India, Nepal, Tibet, China, Nagaland, Assam, Bhutan and Bangladesh were visited. A total of 3000 miles was traveled during 125 days (4 months), and many beautiful and exciting images, encounters and interviews resulted.
Some of the best parts in the series include Michael Palin making several treks on foot up into the mountains, the highest trek going to Everest Base Camp at 5480 m (18000 ft). Well done, considering that Michael was 60 when he did the trip.
Other high points (ha, ha) include visiting the Dalai Lama, milking a yak, talking to a retired headhunter, buying booze in Pakistan, having an almost-encounter with Maoists in Nepal and sailing off into the sunset in the Bay of Bengal. All situations where the special Michael Palin wit and charm comes through strongly.
The down side is that it all seems a bit too artificial, a bit too motivated by "is this good TV?" The traveling itself is hardly mentioned at all, and in reality the filming and traveling was done in several visits to the area over a period of 11 months. Nor is there a continuous route from start to finish; instead Michael and the team seem to jump back and forth from place to place in order to find the elusive "good TV" locations and events.
The DVD version of the TV series is on three discs containing the six one-hour programs. In addition there is the following extra material:
- an introduction by Michael Palin, 3 minutes.
- 125 minutes of additional scenes - mixed quality, some good, some not so interesting.
- an interview with Michael Palin, 27 minutes, very good.
Highly recommended. Despite my negative feelings about the producers focusing on finding "good TV" instead of focusing on the trip as an undertaking, this is, of course, really good TV.
Rennie Petersen
|
|
|
31 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Palin's Peak Practices, 30 Jun 2005
If you've been following Michael Palin's Himalayan excursions on the television, then you'll know almost exactly what you're getting here. If you haven't, but have been a spectator to some of Palin's other epic voyages, you may find that his approach to the Himalayas is a little less frenetic than, say his round the world trips. Given the dominance of the mountain range and the lack of oxygen, a slightly more laid back approach is understandable.Michael Palin does what he always does - he acts like a thoroughly decent human being, good humoured, good natured, absorbed by the people and country around him. In an era where holidaying has become an excuse for booze, sex, and coarse behaviour, regimented by airlines, tour operators, and the lure of grotesque theme parks, Palin again demonstrates that travel and adventure can be a gentlemanly, gentle act. He conveys a polite humanity and sense of wonder, proving that you can travel the world without glossy brochures. For most people, simply being there might be excitement enough, but Palin finds mini adventuresa plenty ... with local herdsmen, school kids, or simply sitting on a train. The landscape dominates the whole trip. It is the ultimate landscape, the roof of the world, but it's a landscape wounded by conflict. Palin counterbalances the warfare by interviewing the Dali Lama. He doesn't take sides, he doesn't judge, but you get a sense of his exasperation - surely peace is easier that war? Palin clowns, he observes, he listens, he describes. The camera work picks out the visual wonders of the land. It's the sort of production which makes your mouth water and your feet start to itch, the sort of production which has you pouring over maps and deciding you won't be going to Belgium for your holidays this year. Beautifully shot and produced, Palin his usual charming self - this is a delight from start to finish. It's stimulating, it's entertaining, and it's excellent value with three discs giving you the television series plus some entertaining extras.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|