|
|
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Difficult loves sung in the shadow of 9/11, 14 Oct 2004
By A Customer
From the early publicity surrounding Delivery Man, I thought I knew two things about it. One, that the American public had been thought too childish or too prone to righteous violence to be allowed to hear the apparent reference to suicide bombing in "Pulling Out the Pin", which was dropped from the US release. And two, that this is an album characterised by a pub-band-style rough and readiness. I'll say a bit about both preconceptions.First the lyrical content. It is true that "Pulling Out the Pin" seems to refer to suicide bombing. It begins with a woman pulling a pin out of her hair, but this is just the first step in her preparation for an act of destruction involving the removal of another pin. EC is developing a taste for subverting the opening image of a song and telling a story with a twist, and in this respect "Pulling Out the Pin" works like the hostage-taking in "Radio Silence" on When I Was Cruel. Dropping it only shows the deep stupidity of the American (self-)censor. In a decision worthy of the old Soviet Union, the most obvious offending image has been suppressed while all the quietly dissenting stuff slips through. "Monkey to Man", for example, the current single, talks of "flying bombs" and seems to be saying that 9/11 and its aftermath reveal the essential viciousness of humankind. What a waste of a species we are! The album opens with "Button My Lip", the first lines of which are "Don't want to talk about the government/Don't want to talk about some incident" - which one do you suppose that might be then?! Later in the same song we hear "It serves you right/now you are suffering" and the piano even delivers an ironic, broken version of "I like to be in America", the immigrant's song of praise to the land of the free from West Side Story. I could go on. These songs are full of lines that should offend a certain American opinion. Take, as a final example, a reworking of the nativity with Mary reduced to a wayward woman knocked up by someone other than her husband: "I've got this harlot that I'm stuck with carrying another man's child/The solitary star announcing vacancy burned out as we arrived". But don't think this is a polemical album. There's no big thesis here, he certainly doesn't take sides, and the state of the world is really just the backdrop to a set of stories about troubled lives and failing loves. For every jab at America there is an attempt to reach out to it, most obviously through the music itself. EC draws on the roots of American music: blues, rock, and plenty of country. There's even a measure of jazz, which gives the drums and keyboards a prominence we don't often hear on an EC album. Steve Nieve clangs away at times or spirals, on "Bedlam", like Terry Riley's improvisations of the 60s. Whatever it is, then, this isn't pub-style thrashing. It isn't even Blood and Chocolate, although some of the rougher textures may have fooled casual reviewers. On the contrary, this album is contrived, artful and controlled, almost to the point of showing off. And it has an exhilarating sense of purpose. If anything, it draws together the best of EC's various experiments. I'm very excited by it - can you tell?
|