|
|
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Listen up, girls: Tina Fey has something to say, 17 Feb 2005
There are three things I already believed before I went to go see "Mean Girls," and which were not changed by watching the film. First, you cannot be too mean to a mean girl because they are pretty much impervious to just about everything. Both this movie and the book which inspired it, Rosalind Wiseman's "Queen Bees and Wannabes: Helping Your Daughter Survive Cliques, Gossip, Boyfriends and Other Realities of Adolescence," have been the topic of talk shows where they have brought in real, live "mean girls," and nothing on earth can get through their head that their are wretched human beings. In this movie the effort to get the chief mean girl, Regina George (Rachel McAdams), by our heroine, Cady Heron (Lindsay Lohan), does not go nearly far enough to really get through to her. The point of a movie like this is for the villain to get her comeupance, and what happens here does not really satisfying the anger in my soul at such human beings.Second, the worst year for mean girls is the 8th grade. These mean girls are juniors in high school. Granted, junior girls are as bad as it gets in high school, because senior girls tend to unclench their hair and enjoy their last year, but they have nothing on 8th grade girls. That is when they hit puberty, before the boys and at a time when the boys are not worth pursuing, so they turn on each other. Most of the mean things the mean girls do to themselves and each other in this film my youngest daughter says happens in her school all the time and she is only in the 7th grade. These girls are getting off lucky. Third, Tina Fey is the sexiest woman on television. She is the sexiest woman on television because the head writer on "Saturday Night Live" is the smartest woman on television. Not that her character is pretend smart, like Jennifer Garner's Sidney Bristow is smart on "Alias," but really smart, as in a wicked bad sense of humor. The fact that she is even more cute with those glasses on is just gravy, just like her first appearance in this movie. Fey wrote the script for "Mean Girls," and if anything she has softened her barbs because she actually has an important point to make to her audience and this movie is perfectly suited to bring her target group in because when I went to theater there were dozens of groups of young girls, teenagers and young, there to see the film. The big question is whether or not this film will have any impact on the behavior of these girls. If I had to make a bet, it would be that this film is going to inspire them to gang up on the mean girls at their own schools and turn the tables on them (not that this would necessarily be a bad thing given the notion of cosmic justice). Lohan's character is considered a "Martian" by her new classmates, because she has been home schooled until the age of 16 while living in Africa, so she knows nothing about the social do's and don't's of high school (a state beyond that of Rory being a "Mary" on the first season of "Gilmore Girls"). She gets the perspective of both extremes of the high school girl world with Regina on the one side and Goth-girl Janis Ian (Lizzy Caplan) on the other. All this really does is teach her where the battle lines are drawn, but what she really needs is a crash course in how to play the game. Fey tries to refrain from actually teaching girls to be mean girls, which puts her in a Catch-22 because she cannot give us satisfaction without being really mean and being really mean endorses the idea that is the only way to get satisfaction. The only real flaw in the set up of "Mean Girls" is that there really is not a good reason for Regina to admit Cady to the Plastics inner circle, but you have to accept the idea so we can get on with the festivities. After all, Regina does not need to co-opt the new girl in school to have her ostracized by the assembled masses. The other concern I have is whether Fey should have given the articulation of the film's message to her own character when she points out to them why calling each other fat, stupid, and even worse names is not productive. This 2004 film, directed by Mark S. Waters ("Freaky Friday") has a handful of "SNL" performs. Ana Gasteyer is wasted as Cady's mom and Amy Poehler is the film's one adult caricature as Mrs. George, but it is Tim Meadows whose controlled comic performance stands out among the older actors. Of the kids the one who commands attention is Lacey Chabert as Gretchen Wieners, the Queen Bee's left hand dancer until Cady comes along. Just watch Chabert's eyes as her character goes through all the agonies of trying to figure out the right thing to say to keep her place in the pecking order.
|