Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
81 of 83 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
requires a real Eye for Optical Theory..., 28 Mar 2004
The Draughtsman's Contract is one of the great British films... a wonderful fusion of baroque 17th century mystery, with pop art sensibilities and a plethora of arcane references to neo-classical literature & art. All of Greenaway's principal trademarks are here, with infidelity, jealousy, revenge and vulgarity acting as the lynchpins of the multi-layered narrative... whilst the lushness of the design and the ornate perfectionism of the mise-en-scene certainly acts as a foundation for later works such as the Cook the Thief his Wife & her Lover, and the more similar parable, 8 ½ Women. It is a film rich in intricate details that make it impossible to forget; with the filmmaker creating a multi-faceted story which encompasses everything from high-tragedy to high camp - sort of Barry Lyndon meets Blackadder - whilst also playing with the notions of self-reference... both in terms of the knowing dialog and in the intricate visual design (Greenaway filling the screen with windows within windows leading in and out of worlds within worlds).The plot is always unfolding, often subtly, with Greenaway never signposting events; always confident with the subjective power of the film to let his camera drift over the lush-vistas of the English countryside as Michael Nyman's grandiose-Purcell-influenced score resonates beyond the cinematic framework, to give the film an even greater sense of playfulness and frivolity. The acting is fairly standard, though this has never been a great concern for Greenaway, who instead is more interested in playing witty and arcane cinematic tricks with the audience, such as layering clues to the mystery within swathes of seemingly banal dialog and the almost two-dimensional compositions (created to mirror the sketches created by the titular draughtsman). This was a real turning point in Greenaway's career as a filmmaker, as it is his first example of a narrative film, after years of short, conceptual doodlings (c.f. Dear Phone, A Walk Through H, and Water Wrackets), and is a definite precursor to future classics like A Zed & Two Noughts, Drowning By Numbers and The Cook The Thief His Wife and Her Lover. The disk, released by the BFI, is lovingly created... with a real sense of input from the usually reserved Greenaway. Here we find an extensive director's commentary in which the filmmaker discusses the intellectual complexities of the script, his varying inspirations, and the various narrative layers, as well as the process of shooting his first film in general. There are also archive-deleted scenes, a filmed introduction with Greenaway in the style of Prospero's Books, an interview with Michael Nyman, details of the re-mastering process and a collection of hidden-features. The screen transfer, in it's original 1:66.1 aspect ratio, and the crystal clear sound gives the film a whole new lease of life, allowing us to appreciate Greenaway's evocative framing and subtle use of sound-design all the more. Some have argued that the Draughtsman's Contract - like the majority of Greenaway's back-catalogue - is an elitist film, the type of which can only be enjoyed on a purely artistic level. I would disagree. The Draughtsman's Contract is one of THE great British films: funny, witty and deeply interesting... in a way that future Greenaway films (or most other UK films for that matter) could only dream of.
|
|
|
34 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The masterpiece of a flawed genius, 17 Mar 2004
By A Customer
The current obsession for non-stop action films with music video style editing, bland dialogue, by-the-numbers soundtracks, actors whose salaries are in inverse proportion to their talent and formulaic cinematography makes it is hard to believe how different cinema was back in 1982 when "The Draughtsman's Contract" hit the big screen.It was a superb cinematic event then and the recent release of a digitally enhanced DVD marvelously re-captures the feeling. An excellent, informative director's commentary is the highlight of the DVD extras. What makes it a great film? Firstly every component part, every individual involved, is out of the top drawer or at the peak of their powers. The atmosphere is extraordinary. Never has the English landscape played a greater role. Never has dialogue been more carefully crafted to create the mood of the time. Never has a painter's skill been so well brought to the creation of cinematic images. And the Michael Nyman soundtrack, a marvelous creation echoing Henry Purcell is, for me, unsurpassed - even by Morricone's haunting "Mission". It is a film to be watched with all your faculties concentrating fully and your efforts will be rewarded. What's it about? In 1694 a confident young draughtsman of some talent eventually agrees to draw ten pictures of a country house for the wife of its owner in exchange for eight pounds a drawing, bed and board for himself and his servant, and ten private liaisons with the wife for sex. He is amazed when his terms are accepted as he made them extortionate not really wanting the commission. From that introduction Greenaway leads us - via beautiful lighting, exquisite camerawork, outstanding dialogue and excellent performances from an underrated cast - to intrigue, murder, politics, religion, pomegranates and a shocking denoument. Watch it as a murder mystery, and it is very good - obscure clues and red herrings. Watch it as a perfect cinematic portrayal of an english country house at a turning point in English history as its images will delight you. Watch and marvel at how long Greenaway's scenes can be without a single movement of the camera. But above all WATCH IT. I admire several other Greenaway films, particularly Belly of an Architect and Drowning by Numbers, (though not The Cook, The Thief, etc.) but none compares with this. If you read my review Mr. Greenaway, thanks for an absolute masterpiece which I finally own - after a "J R Hartley-esque" search for several years. But tell me, is there really a four hour version somewhere? Now I don't suppose I could have sight...
|
|
|
25 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
English Masterpiece, 9 Mar 2004
When it was released in 1982 The Draughtsman's Contract was unique - still is. Oh yeah, there was Kubrick's staid adaptation of Barry Lyndon with its sui generis lighting and slow, slovenly pace much admired by Scorcese, but Greenaway's film was considerably different. There was no reverend text to follow, nor was this a film about Kings and Queens playing bedroom gambits or being liberal with the choppping block (see Carry on Henry). This was utterly original. The sense of place and time are remarkable. The use of landscape (so few British films have any use for the English countryside) is extraordinary. The music is a revelation. The acting is top - Anthony Higgins gives a performance not unlike Nyman's music, all swagger and irony. The dialogue, whilst arch and puffy in places, is even quotable. Did I mention the photography, the costumes: fantastic. The DVD restoration work is exemplary - have the black areas on this film ever been so black! The extras are interesting, though not exhaustive. And from what I've heard of the commentary, it is, unlike so many easy-money wordless hour and a halfs (no, not halves, think about it), delivered by a director that not only adds to what he's talking about, but begins to become interesting in his own right.So, okay, Greenaway dropped the ball pretty quickly, but he never scampered into novel writing (Parker, you fraud!) and he had the vision to praise Blue Velvet on TV in the mid-eighties whilst everyone was whining that it was a bit much (So you liked A Room with a View and Letter to Breshnez did you?). I adore this film and have no trouble with its idiosyncrasies; in fact, I would be amazed to find a film I adored in which I did not find any idiosyncrasies, and so I award this the maximum five stars. This is not a film for everyone, but then, you are not everyone.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|