|
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Jackman the Shining Star, 23 Feb 2004
I heartily agree this CD would be best enjoyed if the show had been seen in person. This review, though, is based off the CD alone.Pro: Following the life of Peter Allan, the Boy From Oz is an undeniably enthusiastic rendering of his life, using songs Allan wrote. Con: This enthusiasm, however, does sometimes bleed over into happy "cheese." Many people have never heard of Peter Allan until now, and his music does have a somewhat dated sound (70s). Note: If you don't like Liza Minnelli's voice in real life, you won't like how she's rendered here - it's pretty good! The same goes for the style. The Boy from Oz might be a bit like "Hair" - you either love it or hate it. Pro: His music was meant to be performed from the get-go, few songs have been converted to the stage. Con: The CD doesn't do a great job of conveying the character nuances you'd get from seeing a live performance. Pro: Here Jackman proves his roots as a song and dance man. The Bonus Track "Tenterfield Saddler" (was it cut?) is probably the best as it really shows off Jackman's voice. Jarrod Emick as 'Greg' in "I Honestly Love You" is also talented. Con: The majority of the show is so 'full on' that the other singers seem to go flat/sharp more often that they should on a professional recording. (In particular, 'Don't Cry Out Loud' is a bit soured because the actress goes sharp a number of times.) Pro: The show matures as you listen. I tend to think Act II is much better than Act I. Nitpick: I don't think the CD is that well produced, found a typo, and in 2 songs when 'Minnelli' is singing the sound goes a bit loud/fuzzy as if she's standing too close to the recording microphone. This should have been fixed! (I've checked, it's not my speakers). The pictures are great, however! So why 4 stars? Though I've highlighted a few 'cons', I think they generally balance out with the 'pros.' In the end you get a pretty good, busy CD with a lot a decent vocal talent. Jackman and a few others shine above the rest. I don't think it will be remembered forever, but it's not a bad addition to the musical genre.
|