Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
25 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Album of Cale's career, 6 Oct 2003
A review of a John Cale compilation in one of the popular music magazines a few years ago said something to the effect that "Cale is doomed to spend his whole career in the shadow of two albums he made in the late Sixties", referring of course to the groundbreaking work he did with the Velvets. In trying to escape that shadow, he has made some of the most consistently interesting music of the past three decades. It hasn't always been great, or acclaimed, but his wit and personality have ensured a cult following.
In this album, however, we can see a new John Cale, who has everything and nothing to do with any of that stuff. The first glimpse of the new John Cale (who is, finally, just the old John Cale, only older) came with the release of the "Five Tracks" EP, the best twenty minutes of music released in early 2003, but they are even more evident here. Some things about the new (old) John Cale:
Where the old (young) John Cale made angular songs that shifted radically from melodic melancholy to screaming art-rock, the new old new Cale is more subtle. The musical left turns are still here, but they are handled so elegantly that they feel as though they belong. This is partly to do with Nick Franglen's co-production, partly to do with Cale's beloved Pro Tools software, but mostly to do with Cale's maturity as a songwriter.
Another thing: the new John Cale really likes the Beta Band. Why does this matter? Because this is a thoroughly modern record. Just listen to his tortured falsetto howl on "Magritte" and you'd be forgiven for thinking that you were hearing the best thing Radiohead have ever done. It's not contrived in any way, though: Cale is not trying to be trendy, he is, as always, his own man.
The new John Cale is NOT a nihilist. There is anger here, but it is focused (as on the superbly accusatory "Zen"). None of the old cliches apply, so forget the following: Godfather of Punk! Classically trained! Avant-garde! Mates with Eno! If Cale can ignore these cliches long enough to make a relevent album, then so can you (and that goes for the music press as well).
Best cuts: the witty "Things", already a live favourite, its deranged deconstruction "Things X", the lovely "Caravan" and the devastating "Over Her Head".
All in all, the most intelligent, socially conscious and beautiful album of the year so far.
The Velvet What??
|
|
|
15 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Contemplative, 4 Jan 2004
This 2003 album by the art rock veteran is a great improvement on 1996's Walking On Locusts, but certainly no outstanding masterpiece. The first three tracks, Zen, Reading My Mind and Things are standard Cale numbers, with nothing extraordinary in either the lyrics or the tunes.The same goes for The Look Horizon, a rock ballad that contains a spoken female vocal. Magritte has some moving lyrics over a jagged rhythm with innovative tempo changes and instrumentation, whilst Archimedes is a brooding experimental track embellished by great instrumental touches. The slow song Caravan is a poetic contemplation of death in moving lyrics and imagery, whilst the up-tempo pop song Twilight Zone mercifully breaks the mould with its buoyant vocals and lilting beat. Letter From Abroad has a harder edge with a complex structure and atmospheric parts, quite an experimental outing. In general, Hobo Sapiens is a quiet, contemplative album with many similar sounding mid-tempo tracks. It lacks the type of powerful rock song that is so brilliantly displayed on the Island Years compilation. I recommend that album or the other excellent compilation, Seducing Down The Door, if you want to own his best work. But Hobo Sapiens will satisfy the fans.
|
|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Album of 2003, 31 Dec 2003
I have been a John Cale fan for 20 years now, merely a neophyte considering his 40 year career in music. It is amazing that as Cale hits 61 years old, he releases the finest album of his long career (and that includes his numerous collaborations [Velvet Underground, Brian Eno, Lou Reed, Nico, et al.]). Whereas earlier albums thematically tilted one way or the other-- Paris 1919 = polished pop; Honi Soit = art rock; Words for the Dying = classicism; Walking on Locusts = adult contemporary (this is not an insult); Fear/Slow Dazzle/Helen of Troy = Avant-Pop; Music for a New Society = minimalist rock, etc-- Hobosapiens is a seamless synthesis of Cale's sometimes competing sensibilities. What comes of this is a work of "art" (yeah, I know, it is a music CD, but...) that transcends trends/styles/labels. Repeated listening enriches the experience and reveals the depth, musically and lyrically, of the material. I hope that Cale's current productivity with EMI (5 Tracks, Hobosapiens) mirrors his prolific work during the Island years. I can't wait to hear what's next! Stand-out tracks include: Things, Magritte, Archimedes, Over Her Head, and the incredible Letter From Abroad (as defamiliarizing as Gun was in the 1970's). EMI--> give this thing a formal release in the USA!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![Fear: Remastered [VINYL]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41Dp1LSgpzL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
