Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Part of the Greatest Story Ever Told, 16 Sep 2008
I truly believe that 'the Lord of the Rings' is one of the greatest stories ever told. The tale of Frodo Baggins and the ring of power carries on in the second part of the trilogy, where Frodo and Sam are continuing their relentless quest to Mordor to destory the ring, only to be joined by the sinister yet pitiable creature known as Gollum. Meanwhile, Merry & Pip try their hardest to escape from the evil orcs who captured them at the end of 'The Fellowship of the Ring', whilst Gimley, Legolas and Aragorn meet a king and immediatley sense something is not right. Old characters return and new ones are introduced as the tale of the Ring grows closer to it's end.
The extended edition is far superior to the original, though the amount of time it takes to watch borderlines on ridiculous. There are many (necessary) explanations and more focus on various story arcs. I was especially pleased at the extra focus on Arwen and Aragorn, one of the main stories to hold my interest.
As with the 1st of the films, each shot, every scene is spectacular to watch, and as the viewer you never question the integrity of this fantasy world - for a few hours you truly are transported into Middle Earth, the characters do exist, the elves, dwarfs, orcs, ents and hobbits are all real. The soundtrack is breathtaking and the acting is superb - the characters all look and sound the part and the script is infallible. I don't really have any complaints, except (as I mentioned earlier) for the length of the film, but as this is the extended edition, and that no matter how long this film is it never once feels boring, all is forgiven on my part and I sincerely look forward to watching 'the Two Towers' again. This is how film adaptations from books are meant to be done. Those responsible for the Harry Potter and Narnia films would do to take heed and learn from the master.
|
|
|
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The centre of Middle Earth, 10 Oct 2007
Chris Cooper's performance in 2002's Adaptation was skilful and memorable, but the Academy Award for Actor In A Supporting Role should surely have gone to Andy Serkis for his performance as Gollum in the second part of Peter Jackson's seminal movie trilogy. The Two Towers (correctly) received the Visual Effects gong, but the Academy may have missed a trick - we couldn't have felt pity for poor Smeagol without the Englishman's dazzling talent.
The Two Towers is the heart of the story in Jackson's (and Fran Walsh's, Philippa Boyens', and Steven Sinclair's) take on the tale. The book has been seriously and necessarily rejigged to suit the demands of the classical narrative. The battle of Helm's Deep, for instance, has been promoted beyond what was essentially a precursor to the final battle to something more immense: a grand, emotionally-driven climactic battle which represents arguably the best single action encounter of the trilogy.
But this last stand would be nothing were it not for the quality of the drama that precedes it. The Fellowship of the Ring set the scene; The Return of the King tore the scene to shreds on an awe-inspiring scale. The Two Towers, meanwhile, sows the seeds that will bloom into the enthralling narrative conflicts concluded in its sequel, as well as containing numerous character arcs of its own. The reluctant feud begins between Boromir (Sean Bean) and Faramir (David Wenham) for the love of their father, Denethor (John Noble); the adversity between nature and industry, represented by the mighty Ents and the tyrant Saruman (Christopher Lee), comes full circle; Grima Wormtongue's (a particularly superb Brad Dourif) fleeting power over the troubled king Theoden (Bernard Hill) and his adopted son, Eomer (Karl Urban) is a wicked war waged by an opportunist weakling. And I haven't even mentioned the surviving members of the Fellowship...
Pleasingly, Jackson et al continue their exploration of Arwen (Liv Tyler), as well as introducing another prominent female character. Miranda Otto's Eowyn is spiky and obstinate, and yet hauntingly bereft; a pale ghost wandering the prison of her uncle (Theoden). She's the most interesting female character in the series by far, deservingly foregrounded for the latter two movies.
Epic, exciting, heartfelt, and frightening - this is a brilliant hub for the trilogy.
|
|
|
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent continuation of an epic story, 30 April 2008
The Two Towers is part two of the Lord of the Rings saga. It was always going to be the most difficult to transmit into a good film in it's own right as the book was rather inconclusive. Nonetheless, Peter Jackson used his artistic license to produce an action-packed adventure that was almost as good as the brilliant Fellowship of the Ring. Howard Shore delivered another great score with the music for Rohan one of the main new themes. Some new faces are added to the cast as we are properly introduced to Gollum (Andy Serkis) and the kingdom of Rohan (Bernard Hill, Brad Dourif), and briefly to Gondor (David Wenham, John Noble). As much of the story involves Rohan, the film actually has a different, quite Nordic, feel to it. This doesn't make it less enjoyable but rather adds another dimension to the diverse world that is middle-earth.
The film is now following several simultaneous story-lines with the fellowship broken into three groups; Frodo and Sam in the Emyn Muil, Merry and Pippin being taken to Isengard by their Uruk-Hai captors, and Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli tracking them through Rohan. Meanwhile, the fallen wizard Saruman is now ready to attack Rohan with his army of Uruk-Hai. Things look very bleak but hope glimmers with the return of the wizard Gandalf, now elevated in status to Gandalf the White. The interweaving between mutiple threads is done with such great skill that you get into the movie immediately. This extended cut is a major enhancement of the theatrical version. Many scenes were left out at the cinema for pacing reasons and time restrictions. For the home viewer you get a much fuller story and a load of extra stuff on the making of the film in a 4-disc set.
The changes include a flashback of Faramir to when he and the soldiers of Gondor, under Boromir's leadership, had retaken the west bank of Osgiliath. We learn why Boromir, and not Faramir, goes to Rivendell for the Council of Elrond, making you wonder how things would have turned out if the positions had been reversed. We see Frodo and Sam go through the sewers under Osgiliath, which explains how they cross the Anduin river without detection by the Orcs on the eastern bank of the ruined city. Another important addition is the revelation of Aragorn's age (he is 87) and ancestry as the last of the line of legendary Numenorean Kings, a lineage bestowed with wisdom, unusual long life and great power. This is recognized by Boromir in the later parts of Fellowship of the Ring and explains why he has accepted Aragorn as his king and leader, rather than as a mere equal. The climax is also improved with the Forest of Fangorn arriving at Helms Deep to take it's revenge on the Uruks. This coincides with some gentle fun between Merry and Pippin in Saruman's store-room after the storming of Isengard. Overall, it adds depth and understanding of things that didn't seem initially clear, and keeps the story well set-up for the final movie. I couldn't wait the 12 months to find out what happened next so I read the books!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|