|
28 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Beware: plot spoilers! But an honest review, 8 Jul 2005
I'm glad I went with the reviews on this one. The actors are true to the story and most of the important bits are included in it when it comes to the build up of the relationship between Jane and Rochester. In all that it does, the film manages it okay(with a few story mixes to involve the Rivers.. see later).On the down side: It's just too short! The story spends about a fifth of the time on Jane's time at Lowood only covering her time as a pupil and spends about ten minutes on her time with the Rivers. This is the downfall of this film as I always find the long section that follows Jane on her tortuous journey from Thornfield to the Rivers is so painful and heart wrenching and this is completely missed out, plus the fact that she finds family is completely omitted. Again, the pain felt when she finds out about Thornfield in the village is also omitted, leaving it to the viewer to work out Rochestor is blind. The large plot that sees Rochestor use Blanche Ingram to make Jane jealous at the house party falls completely flat. Yet it holds itself with many other great moments between the two. What can I say to summarise? A good film, but there are times when the book is far superior (if only they had followed it properly), and you can almost watch it without reading the book, but there are times when it woud be helpful to have read it in order to fill in the gaps. Oh, and they missed out the "love calling" bit. Bad idea. Watch it, but make sure you read the book. Lots.
|